Mafiascum.net

I feel like ydrasse might be moved back into null/townlean category btw, feels really solvey town!ydrasse and tone is much better than yesterday
-S

that would be a trust tell but from my sample size (of 1) from reading newbie 2028, I think he didn't mention it
-S

yeah last page was a lot better than earlier content, agreed

I don't think I've been hyperfocused on ydrasse at all?

In post 427, Happy Unbirthday Boon wrote:I don't think I've been hyperfocused on ydrasse at all?

i found at least two recent questions directed at ydrasse so eh... recency bias exists
-S

is it a trust tell if 72 doesn't invoke it?

if it's one regardless i'll drop it

I guess Nico is drifting more into my "would fade" category if she keeps not posting but that's not really a scumlean, just a slot I'm not excited to keep waiting to do anything

In post 429, Ydrasse wrote:is it a trust tell if 72 doesn't invoke it?

if it's one regardless i'll drop it

probably?

72 not being aware of it probably doesn't count as deliberately trust-telling
-S

Either of you have reads on Ari?

In post 430, Happy Unbirthday Boon wrote:I guess Nico is drifting more into my "would fade" category if she keeps not posting but that's not really a scumlean, just a slot I'm not excited to keep waiting to do anything

is this getting ready to policy all lurkers?
-S

pedit ari is in this game huh?

ari failed the vibecheck when he was around

i read the iso, doesn't make me excited at all
-S

yeah, 13 posts even, that's 3x the number of posts of TheGoldenParadox!

[TGP, Nico, Ari]
[Pelican]

Pelican is the slot I think has above rand slot being scum off what they're saying
[TGP, Nico, Ari] probably has two fadebait and one low effort scum, but who knows it could have 2 scums

hopefully they come back and start pumping out posts Soon

GX
Gamma, Ircher, Endless Terror, Tsunami Slayer
BEF, Ydrasse
[Bell, Samantha, HBB] -- open to reads on these slots
Ari, TGP, Nico
Pelican

Think this is where I'm at right now

is your pelican read based off the intentionally-awkward posting?

No it's based on disliking several different points Taly has made and not seeing a lot there that I like despite volume. I don't feel like walling tonight, but basically I have a pretty easy time seeing almost every post Taly has made as coming from scum. Titus's posts could go either way but aren't particularly townie

In post 438, Happy Unbirthday Boon wrote:GX
Gamma, Ircher, Endless Terror, Tsunami Slayer
BEF, Ydrasse
[Bell, Samantha, HBB] -- open to reads on these slots
Ari, TGP, Nico
Pelican

Think this is where I'm at right now

interesting. ive sorted all three of your nulls, but dont even know who the fuck nico is. tgp is pretty null to me, as is ari. why are ydrasse and BEF above null? why isnt this hydra your top townread? we've declared ourselves to be an IC.

-tay

In post 440, Happy Unbirthday Boon wrote:No it's based on disliking several different points Taly has made and not seeing a lot there that I like despite volume. I don't feel like walling tonight, but basically I have a pretty easy time seeing almost every post Taly has made as coming from scum. Titus's posts could go either way but aren't particularly townie

elaborate? analyze a post of your choosing maybe

In post 440, Happy Unbirthday Boon wrote:No it's based on disliking several different points Taly has made and not seeing a lot there that I like despite volume. I don't feel like walling tonight, but basically I have a pretty easy time seeing almost every post Taly has made as coming from scum. Titus's posts could go either way but aren't particularly townie

elaborate? analyze a post of your choosing maybe

Talk to me about Pelican, I'm feeling townie!tone there.

HUB, didn't you scumread ydrasse? what happened to that?
-S

also noraa youre being very quiet and its scaring me
-this and the double post were tay

yeah i’m not seeing what you’re seeing from taly so i would also like an example

or let me order a wall post about it express order for tomorrow

Screw it

In post 134, The Pelican Brief wrote:Gamma feels scummy but different than the last game we finished together.

Ari, which claims do you think are fake?

~Titus

Gamma point is scummy -- "scummy but different from one game" is a low information point that sets up lazy shade/distancing
the Ari question feels pointless

In post 133, The Pelican Brief wrote:Those posts were meant to feel unnatural, I'm grasping for a handle on any slot right now read-wise.

In post 145, The Pelican Brief wrote: I don't like that your focus here is to state that my posts were scummy without actually explaining what the issue you found with them was.

My reply about those posts came

after

your vote.

~Taly

In 133 Taly says he made deliberately unnatural/scummy posts but then acts like I need to explain why the posts he says he crafted to be scummy are scummy

this is not how town plays

In post 231, Taly wrote: Just reminding you

HUB

, I'm not ignoring you, 147 felt waaay too rolefishy for me to respond, so if you'd like to engage with me on my

"awkwardness"

or another player, that may lead to a better resolution of your read on both slots in this post.

Saying I didn't like the way they presented their role is not "rolefishy" and this seems like a pretty scummy overreach to me

In post 235, The Pelican Brief wrote:

Meanwhile in the Hydra PT

"You can work with the vote for now."

"GIRL, THIS IS THE PERSON WHO ENDS HALF OF THEIR D1'S W/O VOTING... usually not by choice due to chaotic hammers, but yeah."

uhhhh

VOTE: Happy Unbirthday Boon

Hopefully this entices you to read 232 with extreme judgment. I want to know if my impression of you is blind or not.

this is a big attention grabbing vote that they do nothing with

In post 282, The Pelican Brief wrote:VOTE: Samantha

~Titus and Taly

switching to Samantha here because why?

In post 297, The Pelican Brief wrote:

In post 295, Happy Birthday Boonskiies wrote:Taly, I'm down to jam if you're not going to scam

OK, humor me. I dare you to make as many statements and ask as many questions as I am about to.

I think the universal townread on

Gypyx

is likely accurate but I'm confident scum also see the slot as a potential pocket... coming from someone who is often universally townread, too.

Actually, I'm weary of veiling most of my townreads right now because I don't want to come too quickly to a conclusion on any one slot, or scum to know where my POV lies within this game on D1.

How experienced would you say you are with

Titus

and I as players in mafia?

It irks me that

HUB

has the same reads in 87 as he does in 289 despite his presence.

I thought

Sam

would respond more to the counterwagon on her when the one she placed on

BEF

fell apart, I'm leaning on

Titus'

gut with this slot.

What is your angle of solving or read on

Ydrasse/TGP/ET

?

People I want to communicate more with are

Gamma/Bell/Ari

.

I think this is a fun and useful exercise, do you?

~Taly

I think a lot of what's going on in this post is pretty scummy, the weird paranoia around GX reads is scummy, making excuses for lack of townreads is scummy, complaining about me having "the same reads" after basically nothing has happened is really scummy, rest of the post doesn't strike me as townie either

It's the reason why I voted

ET

to drive dialogue from

Bell

. 55 to 58 Ascetic claim voting ascetic claim. 15 35 I am transparent about this now because

Bell

seems awol, and I feel confident with my read on

ET

as of this moment.

Taly's Scum Games

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... 9&start=25 - First completed Mafia game ever, I was an SK. Very old. Meta has changed.
https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=52&t=63741 - I was bussed mid-game. Old.
https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=56&t=76118 - I was multiball scum in a very different setup, still, scum.
https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=52&t=76098 -

Perfect scum victory

... also not that long ago, relatively-speaking.
https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=56&t=76341 - Replaced out, but I was a traitor here.
https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=54&t=79036 - Hydra scum. Traitor still. Lost because we outlived groupscum.
https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=84&t=78138 - A 2-for-1 game. Town in one, scum in another... I want to forget this game haha
https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=54&t=82724 - Replaced out. Bad head space. I was 3p, though. Most recent non-town roll.
https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=52&t=82289 - 4p hydra, other recent scum roll.

Gamma

, you claimed N1 lightning rod in your first post. Do you stand by that claim?

~Taly

idk this just seems random for day 1, why is Taly posting so much scum meta? this comes out of nowhere and feels like overcompensating

This is my top scumread by far

i

will sleep on this