Mafiascum.net

like it adds 0 to the game and does nothing but light shade the replace ins

I don't like the way Nero handled this

that's pretty much trying to make people think about the theory and if it can be legit (light shading like you said) and then distancing from it as someone else suggested it.

I'm trying to make people think about it? I wish I could put thoughts into people's heads but I can't. dope super power though.

Inception

you know what I mean though. you of all people with this vast gaming experience should know that even if someone said that somewhere, its so moot and gateway to all sorts of fallacies. so didn't understand why you thought it's a good idea to even consider it and then attack it on the next post yourself

that just didn't sit well with me

I'm not asking anyone to consider it. I literally said it brings nothing to the game b/c it doesn't. It's a dumb post.

In post 429, Frozen Angel wrote:should know that even if someone said that somewhere, its so moot and gateway to all sorts of fallacies.

In post 429, Frozen Angel wrote:then attack it on the next post yourself

you can't have it both ways. You can't attack me for attacking him while also attacking me for not liking a post that adds nothing to the game.

In post 424, Nero Cain wrote:In fairness, there actually is a theory that most replace outs are done by scum but bringing it up is dumb

Simply I just didn't this post coming from you.

I'm not having it both ways. I just said it's unsettling the way you mention it exists but call it dumb in one post. I know you didn't contradict yourself there and that wasn't my point. I'm just saying to even considering such a theory exists by you makes no sense to me.

or was there some sort of major theory crafting out there for real about this while I was gone from the website?

It's been talked about multiple times in MD. Why is he talking about it in this game? IDK he's just scum that's hiding behind theory talk? maybe but whether or not said theory exists is irrelevant here, it's his motive that matters.

but I thought you were in agrement that his post was bad. So why is it bad that I think his post is bad?

It's not your conclusion that was unsettling with me even though I don't find him using that inherently scum motivated.

So he said because of this theory, I think to replace ins are more likely scum: This is pretty much a low hanging fruit slot with 0 contexts before this, saying something completely pointless again

2 people vote for him and I express my concern, then you first and then call him bad for using it. Now again I don't find that contradictory I just don't like how it was constructed to that point because I know you.

Now about my own read so far is that it was that they tried to use that to generate a read on that moment and if it's not their typical playstyle (which would be an awful one) and he had no other legit reasons behind it (especially since he specifically mentioned me when there were 3 other replace ins), it's pretty much fabricated.

In post 261, Frozen Angel wrote:Fast switch between these two posts. I always find fast switches scummy. Town mindset is way more progressive than branching. Branching is what scum mindsets prefer so they can add themself to the discussions and gain others' trust.

everyone is different so its not like town do this and town don't do that, scum do this and scum don't do that but on average I think town are quicker to vote and scum are more hesitant. In my most recent game (the one before this) scum attacked me for moving my vote within 12 hours.

In post 287, Scorpious wrote:Can we all just appreciate Stephen?

can you brown-nose more?

In post 360, wavemode wrote:I don't fully follow 65. I get it, andante said 27 was scummy and some people agreed. you're just going to sheep that as your whole reason for voting hockey? there's a lot more in hockeyfan's ISO than 27 and 155

yes he does

ok, randomly votes T3 in 7

says he's town reading DW in 28

argues with fire about his meta in 39

ask Dante to go into further detail about his scum read on him in 40

reaffirms his town read for DW in 41

50 is blasting overkill for making a slightly useless post and tells DW he's used the being suspected and as DW why surye is scummy.

51 congratulates himself on getting a pagetop

55 defends his 27

56 continues to call overkill scum while sitting on his RVS (could argue that this was a joke but eh)

What exactly is town here? You could argue that all this is null at best but if I'm voting him for 27 why does a bunch of null posts make me want to unvote?

Also, keep in mind that 155 didn't even exist by the time I voted in 64. If you believe that I should have unvoted him for his posting after 155 then ok let's talk about it? It seems like it's mostly asking others about their reads. I mean 412 is a pretty good post but it's also the natural response to Eyes anyway.

but you yourself have this funny half in half out "town" read of him. Why is it not a full town read? If you think I'm scum and voting him but you don't think he's town does that mean you think he's being bussed?

In post 349, wavemode wrote:I *want* to believe greeting and hockeyfan are town

its page 18 and he's still sitting on his RVS

Is there anyone here who townreads HockeyFan?

wavemode does, sorta kinda

We need to book him for my ESPN debate show then

We need to book him for my ESPN Live debate show then

yeet

HockeyFan [3]:

Nero Cain, Surye, Stephen A Smith

Eyes without a face [3]:

wavemode, fireisredsir, Dwlee99

Frozen Angel [1]:

HockeyFan

Greeting [1]:

Eyes without a face

Stephen A Smith [1]:

Greeting

Andante [1]:

Scorpious

not voting [3]:

0verki11, Frozen Angel, Andante

mod notes

~ this is a mod note.

flavour

In post 364, Frozen Angel wrote:there is no such thing as a certain read without role actions btw

or mafia. scum already knows all the alignments.

In post 367, wavemode wrote:Well, no. I get that *andante* said it was scummy. But that doesn't mean I find it scummy (personally I'm leaning town on hockey), and that certainly doesn't mean I like nero sheeping that reasoning

So b/c you don't find it scummy I can't find it scummy? WTF!?! I mean, yeah....there's scum motivation in sheeping but its not like all sheep votes or agreeing with someone else's logic comes from a red alignment. I don't think AD ever went into detail about why 27 was scummy to her but I can tell you why it was scummy to me.

In post 27, HockeyFan wrote:Goddamm, looks like I already found all of t3's partners

im assuming that this line is a joke

In post 27, HockeyFan wrote:I like this, and I agree with reasoning, town pings

it was an RVS vote on p1. Highly doubt it was serious and hockey town reading Fire for that felt forced.

In post 27, HockeyFan wrote:Why do you want only pressure on 1 person to start the game? Doesnt make sense, a wagon shouldn't be formed on page 1 for the most part imo

Like the first time I read it mafia against the formation of wagons and wanting to stay in RVS. I mean maybe he was actually concerned that Dante wanted an early wagon.

cause mine is the 9th vote, not the 8th vote. everyone knows the 8th vote is the suspicious one

Fire said this and then Hockey said

In post 27, HockeyFan wrote:Like 2nd part of the post(no town pings tho), but the first part of it(bolded) is ???, seems a bit awkward to come out and say that(I think Dwelee said this? and i agree with them)

I thought it was an obvious joke and it was pretty lame to throw shade there.

In post 407, HockeyFan wrote:

In post 406, Greeting wrote:

Scorpious

is unusually enthusiastic about this game.

My gut tells me it's because of

Stephen A Smith

though.

Does them being enthusiastic about this game affect your read on them?

I thought the context of the post implied that I think it's NAI.

In post 413, Eyes without a face wrote:Maybe not but statistically scum replace out more than town do and especially so at the start of the game. Someone who doesn't like to play scum or someone who didn't like their teammates or someone who thought one of their own are going down too early. I do not promote it to be a 100% plan but early replacement have a higher %age of being scum than you would expect.

Personally, I haven't seen a higher proportion of scums seeking replacement than town in any of the games I played. I don't think that's a very credible theory.

In post 409, fireisredsir wrote:@Greeting, current opinions on waveform and hockeyfan?

I spoke of in 229 and my opinion hasn't changed.

I'm assuming you mean . I have rather mixed feelings about that slot and I'm open to eliminating that.

His early behavior is rather erratic. I don't like 158 nor the subsequent explanation in 164. is a rather nullish, inactive slot. My vote on him was RVS, and once that ended I lost interest in that slot completely. While hasn't contributed much, I don't think there's enough stuff to raise anyone's suspicions. 's posting history does not indicate any willingness to put pressure on him. And yet, later in 351 he speaks highly of the questioning process, none of which he exhibited himself.

Which is why I think these two posts come either from a "meh, I'll just pick lhf and stick to it" perspective that only makes sense if coming from scum.

Another slot which is easy to suspect is who is also their current choice of vote. Sure, they're also rather questionable, but I feel that it's just the easy road for scum to go after someone who's obviously standing out for not posting very much when in fact it's more likely to be NAI than scum. The speed in which the wagon gained votes is concerning. Then again, he does have a point with 355 - that is a read that can be explained from a town point of view. If is town then I guess we just differ in the judgement of 217, which I think isn't very scummy and is NAI at best. This could unfortunately also make a point from a scum point of view if is treating as an easy Day 1 miselimination.

As for 360, I haven't been paying much attention to and that slot didn't really pick my attention either. I don't feel like analysing it right now though, maybe later.

I also don't see as particularly scummy this game (referencing 363). It is, however, my gut read based on the fact that his scum game often tends to be unenthusiastic and he seems to be really into it this time. I'm not ruling out scum , but I think there's more scummy slots than that.

Overall, has been clinging on to low hanging fruit all game and I feel like I'm on different wavelengths with them when it comes to reads. In my opinion, this makes a chance of them being scum higher than average.

In post 434, Frozen Angel wrote:It's not your conclusion that was unsettling with me even though I don't find him using that inherently scum motivated.

So he said because of this theory, I think to replace ins are more likely scum: This is pretty much a low hanging fruit slot with 0 contexts before this, saying something completely pointless again

2 people vote for him and I express my concern, then you first

give the theory some legitimacy

and then call him bad for using it. Now again I don't find that contradictory I just don't like how it was constructed to that point because I know you.

Now about my own read so far is that it was

weird and so sudden

that they tried to use that to generate a read on that moment and if it's not their typical playstyle (which would be an awful one) and he had no other legit reasons behind it (especially since he specifically mentioned me when there were 3 other replace ins), it's pretty much fabricated.

I like this post very much. Maybe I should look into after all?

In post 436, Stephen A Smith wrote:Is there anyone here who townreads HockeyFan?

Me.

In post 442, Nero Cain wrote:I thought it was an obvious joke and it was pretty lame to throw shade there.

hmm the maf game he linked early had someone calling him out for not getting a joke on page 1... he had a similar kinda stilted manner in the first few pages of 830... i already talked about this a little when i first called him out for not having the banter tone he does as town, but maybe him not getting jokes (or just taking things too seriously early) is an actual scumtell for him

In post 406, Greeting wrote:

Scorpious

is unusually enthusiastic about this game.

My gut tells me it's because of

Stephen A Smith

though.

Real game day 1 Stephen was an absolute treat. They did a great job with a gimmick slot. It’s tapered a bit .

So far this group is also very interesting, far from the travesty we were involved in a few weeks ago.