Mafiascum.net

Yes I am ok sorting by postcount here for now.

where im from people vote for who they think is scum, not by who has the least post count

whats your read on Flavor Leaf?

I think they have been villagery, although a certain paranoia exists in the back of my head.
If they start to primarily incite pushes onto villagers it should be examined later, however I don't see them being caught as wolf on day 1 ever and this is all certainly in their town meta.

okay what's your read on me

In post 427, koopashell wrote:this is all certainly in their town meta.

i haven't played with FL yet

tell me

And where I'm from, when I start to feel too many active players are villagers, I start to go through the low posters and incentivize them to play by pressuring them.
Please do not lecture me on how to wolfhunt, I know what I am doing.

I think in recent postings you have been villagery however I still currently see decently likely worlds where you are a wolf, so I am content with letting you live for now and see if those worlds get deconfimed in the future.

haters would say these worlds are not real

tell us about these worlds

and also what do you think of my case on FL

I'm good for now - like I said I want to withdraw for now and not continue to dominate the conversation. We can go back to this later, I will explain what I thought at this time later.

And I think your case on FL mirrors thoughts I have however it is simply explanations for what he is doing *if* he is wolf and does not discount the viability of the fact that these are all actions easily plausible as a villager who is simply confident on a read/wants to drive the game that way. FL is clearly a player who enjoys thread control so your accusation does not really hold too much weight, especially since Italiano is in a possible wolf world right now. I think these kinds of cases only serve to frustrate the player on the receiving end, which I find not useful.
I guess I'd like to state that if I do end up getting nightkilled night 1, do not let FL use the argument "koopa townread me why would I kill them" - as I am very clearly a player who updates their reads with new evidence and a kill on my slot can come from players who recognize that kind of possible future threat.

I'd rather not get caught up in only pushing people who are active as that is an easy way to get into V/V tunnels while wolves sit back and low-mid post.

are you like an FL fan? Thought you're new here, you seem like you know so much about FL — from knowing his guide somewhere and now knowing his town meta

also what's the italiano case

koopa, dont lurk. if you're town, you can help me by talking to me about your reads.

"don't lurk"

Seeya.

noooooooooooooooooooooo

Imagine lurking

still mindmelding with me? what's your take on Flavor Leaf?

In post 439, humaneatingmonkey wrote:still mindmelding with me? :P what's your take on Flavor Leaf?

Not really, or at least nothing that clicks that we're mindmelding. As I consider mindmelding completely different than having the same reads.

I haven't fully caught up to be fair, will get back to you.

Koopa, what makes FL villagery for you?

In post 436, koopashell wrote:
"don't lurk"

Seeya.

Stop doing this…

Activity is not AI….

The hyper posters need to chill out with throwing around the “lurker” tag..

It’s the weekend, a couple of you are about to be gravely disappointed.

not me im a lurker

I find it kinda interesting that Koopa is voting for Salad on the basis that a low activity player is likely to be mafia, but they strongly TR'd Facebones earlier in the game after they'd only made about three posts.

I thought Facebone's posts were alright for what it's worth and they pointed out a notable contradiction in Mala's play, but if Mala is town then there's absolutely no reason Facebones can't be mafia...there's nowhere near enough info to be making such a concrete read, and it's odd that they'd be so keen on TR'ing them when they think a low activity player could be mafia.

I do also simultaneously feel like it's a potentially unusual/odd play from mafia though...parking a vote on a player who's done nothing so far is obviously bound to get people talking.

Facebonez has towntold more than Scorpious, who has spent the majority of his posts complaining.

In post 420, koopashell wrote:I have a pretty wild theory but I feel there is a lost wolf/traitor based on the fact I cannot feasibly find pairing higher than 2. I am going to read the game with the assumption there is one later on and see if I can't find someone trying to signal - but I think it's a decent possibility here.

I also think I feel comfortable parking here now: VOTE: Salad

The most recent conversation does not particularly help me much and instead just made me roll my eyes at Malcom attributing playstyle to alignment.

Perhaps its ego but that statement did make them fall in my reads for me. A few others have shifted as well but I am withdrawing from the overall conversation to let things play out for now as I have contributed plenty at this point.

That's not really what I was doing though. Nothing wrong with your playstyle itself and I think there can be some value in throwing lots of things out there early on, it's more the fact your play feels inconsistent to me - on the one hand you seem to have really decisive reads at times, but on the other hand your vote is currently on a player who's done nothing either way so far and your reads seem to change quite easily considering how decisive they initially appear.

I'm not even necessarily sure how I read you yet for what it's worth, I don't think mafia puts the vote on Salad there, but just feel like there are inconsistencies in your play.

In post 446, koopashell wrote:Facebonez has towntold more than Scorpious, who has spent the majority of his posts complaining.

They have a total of three posts so far, one of which was an introduction, I don't see how you can be anywhere near convinced of their alignment either way. I like their tone so far but it's not as if all mafia make it obvious where they stand, good scum will deliberately want townies to like them tonally because it makes them less likely to get voted out.

In post 446, koopashell wrote:Facebonez has towntold more than Scorpious, who has spent the majority of his posts complaining.

This is just nonsense..