A Musical Mafia! (Game over)

[The Pied Piper]

I DID
I just can't see where they claimed they would out PRs, then said they had no info on PRs

This is because we didn't do that.

dwlee, read the rest of the thread. It's not hard, you just need to move your eyes from left to right a bunch of times while moving the scroll wheel on your mouse.

[Flubbernugget]

ogre what is you're read on dwlee?

Actually I have the same question for tpp

[Dwlee99]

i skimmed your wall and called you out for more bs and you just ignored it

[Dwlee99]

wait I could have sworn there was something else I called out

[Dwlee99]

oh yea.
So you say your claim wiuld out prs becauss you can tell who prs are (such as a vigilante) and yet that makes no sense because your claim wouldnt out that

[The Pied Piper]

I'll townread him if he busses seniors!

pedit: I didn't say that my claim would out PRs. I said that explaining what I'm softing would do that. I can explain what I'm softing without roleclaiming at all. Now can we please just put this to rest and go back to lynching your buddy?

[True Ogre]

ogre what is you're read on dwlee?

Actually I have the same question for tpp

Honestly. He might be town. I'm having trouble understanding where he's coming from because I think I saw him post somewhere that he was quite young so I'd be hesitant to credit him with high-level scumplay, but then again he's just saying over and over and over that Piper's scum and it seems like it might be a really easy way to fail to develop reads. So the other option is he could just be town and really certain he's caught scum-Piper.

I was hoping to have a better time reading Sakura, but alas. (Dwlee now occupies the slot.)

Sakura did this thing where she implied she had a PR - but I can actually see Sakura-town more likely to make that statement in an effort to draw an NK as (yep, I'm saying it) a non-PR.

Best I've got.

[Dwlee99]

Dont bring up my age to discredit my scumreads <3

[True Ogre]

I'm not, or I didn't mean to, sorry.

I was really trying to get my head around how you as a person might think.

<3

[Dwlee99]

I'll townread him if he busses seniors!

pedit: I didn't say that my claim would out PRs. I said that explaining what I'm softing would do that. I can explain what I'm softing without roleclaiming at all. Now can we please just put this to rest and go back to lynching your buddy?

you soft stuff about your role. Are you saying tictac is town because of a supposed interaction you had that gave vig vibes?

[The Pied Piper]

Cakes says he's usually like this. I've only played with him once back in October and I was scum and wasn't paying all that much attention to him. I think he's irritating but I think he's probably intelligent enough to have realised that he'll have more luck nightkilling us than mislynching us. It does feel a little easy, though.

dwlee, how often do you get mislynched as town?

pedit: no, that's not what i'm saying about tictac. Now stop fishing.

[Dwlee99]

I get mislynched all the time, what does this have to do with the fact you are fake claiming scum?
You should just full claim, I refuse to give you more time to sit ariund and craft a fake claimm.

[SirCakez]

Tictac is out of the game though TPP

[The Pied Piper]

I get mislynched all the time, what does this have to do with the fact you are fake claiming scum?
You should just full claim, I refuse to give you more time to sit ariund and craft a fake claimm.

It has to do with how I should approach trying to read you, which is what Flubber asked me about. You're making a lot of useless noise and getting in the way of lynching Seniors and I need to figure out if that makes you scum or not. I just got out of a micro where literally everybody was mislynch bait but two of them were actually scum and we had to figure out which two.

pedit: I am aware that tictac was replaced by flubber.

[Dwlee99]

I'm getting in the way of lynching seniors because unlike you he's town. =_=

[The Pied Piper]

Keep telling yourself that.

Anyway, it's May Day so I'm out.

[dramonic]

christ I feel really bad for Nacho

[davesaz]

The information we have on multiple people's PRs comes from a variety of sources.

Not gonna quote the rest of the post, but you're making a bunch of assumptions that you are reading the signs correctly. There is a big difference between thinking something is true and knowing it is true. The past couple days discussion came from a post where you placed so much emphasis on knowing that reasonable people are going to infer that it's a PR result and not the result of analysis.

[Flubbernugget]

christ I feel really bad for Nacho

You just said nacho was fake and now you feel bad for him?

[Axelrod]

Can I add my vote to the people who are tired of all the vague hinting on information that's going around? I also feel that if like 1/2 the people who are saying they know stuff actually know stuff then this game could be broken open.

[podoboq]

^^^^ yup ^^^^

[Cerberus v666]

The only people who have done that have been TPP and TO. TO already claimed to be a flavor cop who received no results the first two nights. TPP has hinted at knowledge of MORE than 2 other slots roles. That means any information beyond two slots (most likely ) came from a crumb they picked up/an asumption they're making based on prior experiences.

That means that information is not necessarily useful in solving the game, because it could be wrong. There is little reason for them to share that information, unless they have cause to believe they will be lynched today, OR shot tonight.

[Axelrod]

u r wrong

[SirCakez]

TPP is basically the only one withholding info that I can see.

[dramonic]

christ I feel really bad for Nacho

You just said nacho was fake and now you feel bad for him?

I feel bad for him cuz of his hydra buddy vomiting obvscum all over the thread. I like nacho!~