Mafiascum.net

In post 4279, Yeet wrote:

In post 4276, VP Baltar wrote:

In post 4268, Yeet wrote:VP what would you be doing differently if you were scum this game?

Not listing so many people off and drawing so much attention to myself. I probably would have played nice with Nero earlier and wouldn't have opened the day in a very aggressive manner. I'd be calling town players who are on the wrong track smart and be playing with my long term survivability in mind.

Yeah, this kind of checks out, honestly. I'm once again fine with you being town here.

I'm not bothered enough to look back and fact check this, but I recall VP not long ago saying that the aggressive play was NAI?

(Also if scum he's not going to say that people trying to elim him are smart)

Of the main wagons, my preference is:

VP >>>> Malcolm >> Scorp

I still think VP is scum.
Malcolm I am not totally sure of and I can see a world where he is mafia. The theme of "but there are others worse than me!" in 4196 could be scum genuinely confused as to why they are being pushed for reasons that they see as applying to weaker town players. Obviously this could come from town in a similar mindset but it is something that I tend to associate a bit more with scum. Despite my reservations, I have to admit that I wouldn't be devastated at this elim because 1) if malcolm's scum then woohoo, 2) if malcolm's town then I feel it forces people, particularly April to re-evaluate the game in a way that I feel would be overall positive.

I don't townread Scrop as strongly as tene does, but the cases against Scorp don't convince me of scum motivation and my guess would still be... town, I guess. Main reason for this being worse than a Malcolm elim imo is because the reaction to a scorp-town flip would be "eh... moving on", while I think a Malcolm town-flip would have more positive impact.

In post 4300, DeasVail wrote:I'm not bothered enough to look back and fact check this, but I recall VP not long ago saying that the aggressive play was NAI?

(Also if scum he's not going to say that people trying to elim him are smart)

There is a point where you need to care more about your social game as scum than you do as town, generally speaking.

In post 4295, MalcolmTucker wrote:But I do worry how much we'll actually find out if VP comes back town post-elimination.

Just follow my reads if I flip town. Scum wanted me dead for a reason. I think Nero will also deserve scrutiny if yall end up feeling that cape and skitter are town later.

*galron

In post 4299, DeasVail wrote:At least as of this post, remains fence-sitting re: Malcolm, probably hesitant to opportunistically switch wagons but also not wanting to close it off as an opportunity.

I already voted Malcom.

In post 4296, MalcolmTucker wrote:I won't push this too extensively, because it doesn't look like it's going to go anywhere, but why is this an inherently bad idea?

It seems like common consensus right now that a lot of us are inherently unsure about the top three potential vote-outs in the game. Why have we not spent our time, as a result of this, trying to deduce potential alternatives when we had around half a week remaining to do so? The game has slowed down - who is inherently benefiting from this and why? I just find it interesting that a lot of players seem to have stopped pushing any new potential wagons and seem content with a state of play we're agreeing is less than satisfactory. Maybe it's just the confusion with all the replace-ins, hard to tell.

i mean im not agreeing that it's less than satisfactory. i think only a couple people wish there were alternate wagons. im pretty happy with the top 3 wagons being who they are bc i think there is very likely at least 1 scum in them

In post 4305, VP Baltar wrote:

In post 4299, DeasVail wrote:At least as of this post, remains fence-sitting re: Malcolm, probably hesitant to opportunistically switch wagons but also not wanting to close it off as an opportunity.

I already voted Malcom.

Apologies, by "this post" I meant the April post quoted, but I realise that was unclear.

In post 4274, tenebrousluminary wrote:

In post 4258, VP Baltar wrote:

In post 4256, tenebrousluminary wrote:

In post 4248, MathBlade wrote:My last wish is deaths in this order regardless of VP’s flip

1) Galron. Dude scumslipped and faked reads and it’s freakin obvious. Skitter30 also had a tell of pings.
2) April. April needs death. The fact they haven’t got an elim off at this point and Ari’s defense of Galron is bad AF
3) Titus unless she pushes a scum elim fast. As I said there was a scum in Datisi/Wu

Wake me in dead thread if there is still a game after that

Explain how it's a scumslip like I'm 5? I see the inconsistency but it seems like such a silly mistake, idk.

Math is saying that Galron gave a "town" read on Math so Galron would look like he has accurate and good reads this game. Math is alleging that Galron already knew Math was a mason (something galron seemingly confirmed?).

It seems like the case is basically that Galron is stupid then?

That’s exactly my point VP.

I would love a Galron elim.

And no. The point isn’t Galron is stupid.

The point is Galron faked reads

I don’t attack the player attack the play. Galron is one of the smartest people on MS he just made a mistake

April what are you doing.

I don't think fire can't be scum at all but, do you really think we can get 9 people to vote for fire in 2 days?

In post 4107, fireisredsir wrote:i mean maybe it is malcolm with the poor reaction to his wagon, and the lady doth protest too much methinks over him and VP being mentioned as a possible team, and saying he would come back and be productive and useful or whatever in the morning but then he disappeared

In post 4108, fireisredsir wrote:then again ig he did disappear last friday too so maybe that's just an irl schedule thing. kinda weird tho that he said multiple times "i will defend myself tomorrow!!" and then never came back

Hm this sequence of quotes pings me a little idk.

Fire is the deepwolf here, if he is scum, that's for sure

Do we really get a yeet a deepwolf on D2 like this, idk

Why Enchant is so scummy this game is beyond me. Feels like he's just lolcatting scum? But I still kind of refuse to elim there like in the next few game days because fua was so towny, but I would like Enchant to play and help town more I guess

I'm sorry Math what Galron did does not look like a slip to me.

Here's kind of where I'm at:

Math
Galron Nero enchant - TRs
Baltar cape deasvail - TLs
tenebro eyes Titus April - north of null
Scorpious frog fire std - null I guess?
Malcolm - South of null

VOTE: Malcolm

I'm just ready to move on, and I dont want VP dead.

ok let's even em up then

VOTE: malcolm

the extent to which the game feels stuck here the last few days is weird af and probably meaningful in some way but ill let the smart people figure out what that means

my instinct tho is that it means either scum is in the leading wagons and the rest of the team isn't positioned well enough or isn't active enough to push a counter/commit to a bus, or that the leading wagons are all town, and scum are apathetic about which one goes through. but on play i think the first option is the case

In post 4278, VP Baltar wrote:Ok, so I checked the timestamps and what Galron is saying does check out, at least chronologically.

I told galron at 9:38am (my time) that Math was a mason.

At 9:52 am, galron posts his Math "looks like he is town".

I think if you're being generous to galron, that could read as him lumping a bunch of ideas together into a single post. In that case, he would be saying something like 'I read the last few pages, here is what I think, oh and regardless Math is town.'

You could also interpret that post as galron trying to give a town read of Math for town points, but my thought would probably just leave it in the NAI bin since we can't know for sure.

…That’s like not what he said though lmao

VP and Galron scum team

I am not interested in the Malcolm elim at all.

If it’s not in Galron VP Titus or April I kinda don’t care who it is not going there

ok yea i wasn't really that convinced of that being a slip, but you're right that VP's interpretation there is extremely generous to galron