Detective Penguin & City of Fogport [Game Over]

[Marquis]

it really feels like jjd is town here guys

[Marquis]

VOTE: bingle eh

[Marquis]

UNVOTE:

[Croag]

VOTE: bingle[/unvote]

It’s him or vecna

[Croag]

VOTE: bingle

[Marquis]

but i've been ignoring penguinpower all game and it shows

[FakeGod]

VoteCount 5.3

Judge Joseph Dredd [2] - Bingle, PenguinPower
Bingle [2] - Judge Joseph Dredd, Croag

Not Voting [2]

- Vecna, Marquis

With 6 alive it takes 4 votes to lynch.

Countdown to deadline: (expired on 2019-10-03 16:00:00)

[Bingle]

but i've been ignoring penguinpower all game and it shows

Penguin, just like croag, doesn’t get lynched today. Penguin, just like croag, can only be scum with JJD or solo. Penguin, just like croag, if solo scum doesn’t win if we lynch jjd. Which is why croag was willing to put her own lynch on the line to save JJD. Because she is never the lynch today, even if she outright scumclaims.

Take a good look at her vote on me. Not “Bingle is scum” but “I’ll lynch literally anyone but jjd.” There’s been no effort to try to read me or convince me I’m wrong on Vecna, because she doesn’t care which one of us gets lynched. Because as soon as there’s a hammer outside of her scumteam she wins.

[Bingle]

Theoretically PP could still be scum with you

He really can’t. There is a 0% chance that town wins if me and penguin are scum together. I wouldn’t waste this much effort on a game I’ve already won, especially when no one has listened to me in the thread for 4 day phases already.

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

Nobody wants to lynch Vecna. Not Croag and not me. We want you and only you because you are the scum here, and not Vecna.

Again, you're misrepping just to try to find a way to switch to Vecna if your crusade on me fails. Vecna is the only uncaggeinated Townie left here. Lynching him would be handing you the win on a silver plate.

PP won't be lynched (and neither will Croag) I agree. Why? Because they can only be solo scum. Either that or they've already won regardless (the scum of the two + their p in your hood). So lynching either of them changes nothing. You're absolutely correct her (at least in theory).

As a solo scumster neither wins today either. They would need to shoot BOTH you and Vecna. But here's the trick: NEITHER could have planned it this way. Neither even knew you were killable (if either ia a lone scumster now). So it follows neither can be solo scum here.

Only you (or Vecna) can be the last standing scum here. and given a choice between the two of you I'd say it's you 11 times out of 10.

[Bingle]

Oh, and for anyone who is exceptionally paranoid, if scum me was worried about ambiguous caffeine results, the other lynch for the day that isn’t gamethrowing levels of misplay is Vecna. Which also resolves the whole “what if jjd didn’t act” dilemma because I’d still have a nightkill.

I’m noticeably not okay with lynching Vecna.

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

Theoretically PP could still be scum with you

He really can’t. There is a 0% chance that town wins if me and penguin are scum together. I wouldn’t waste this much effort on a game I’ve already won, especially when no one has listened to me in the thread for 4 day phases already.

tell me something.. let's say I am scum, and let's say I am lynched.. now my p has to be between Croag/PP, right? They shoot you (say). Tomorrow it's still MyLo (actually LyLo as No Lynch still loses the game for town). Now how are you going to decide which of the two to lynch?? WAIT.. did I say they shoot you? I take it back. Let's say they shoot Vecna, so YOU can decide.

Yeah, I know... they can check each other.. but then they either both get a clear on each other (my p bluffs), or they both get guilties on each other (my p fakes a guilty to counter the guilty on them), or one gets a guilty and the other gets an inno (and you still can't tell if my p is the sane one faking or if the townie legit got a guilty).

So... tell me HOW you're going to decide on THAT.

You see, Town!Bingle is NOT short-sighted. He would have thought about this already. Scum!you though doesn't care and it didn't occur to him even because he knows the game ends today (or rather tonight) if he manages to mislynch me.

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

I’m noticeably not okay with lynching Vecna.

yet you wanted Croag to case him for you.

[Bingle]

VOTE: bingle[/unvote]

It’s him or vecna

Really now? What about this says “wouldn’t lynch Vecna”?

I wash my hands of this game.

v/la until endgame, shoot jingle a pm if there’s another dayphase.

Oh, and it’s actually lylo. If we no lynch jjd shoots me and croag shoots Vecna after jjd is lynched.

[Marquis]

I'm useless and you all are scaring me

[Marquis]

I'll read by Monday

[Marquis]

v/la until endgame, shoot jingle a pm if there’s another dayphase.

can you really not. if you're town this helps nobody

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

v/la until endgame, shoot jingle a pm if there’s another dayphase.

can you really not. if you're town this helps nobody

That's a hypothetical IF. He's NOT TOWN, I promise. He sees his chances dimming fast and he is trying to "pull out of the scene" so that the town may implode as we turn on each other.

@Bingle: I also say it's either you or Vecna, but I am voting you. Croag did the exact same. In her mind it could theoretically be Vecna, but who does she

want

to lynch? I guess her vote is clearer than anything I would say.

[Bingle]

v/la until endgame, shoot jingle a pm if there’s another dayphase.

can you really not. if you're town this helps nobody

All the answers are in my ISO, which you won't read anyway.

I'm fucking done. If town loses, we deserve the loss for some spectacularly shitty play.

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

Did anybody notice how Bingle ignored my main question in 4336?? He didn't give us his insight on which of the Cops to lynch after me. Instead he declared VLA!!

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

I'm fucking done. If town loses, we deserve the loss for some spectacularly shitty play.

1- Fake AtE
2- Notice how it's "If town loses" and not "If

we

lose"?

[Marquis]

jjd #2 is bs and u know it

[Vecna]

im so fucking annoyed with myself for not lynching jjd yesterday.

cause i wanna side with bingle here, but it feels like croag and pp are such major wildcards that convincing them both, and then takibg the proper 50/50 tomorrow is gonna be such a longshot

[Croag]

but i've been ignoring penguinpower all game and it shows

Penguin, just like croag, doesn’t get lynched today. Penguin, just like croag, can only be scum with JJD or solo. Penguin, just like croag, if solo scum doesn’t win if we lynch jjd. Which is why croag was willing to put her own lynch on the line to save JJD. Because she is never the lynch today, even if she outright scumclaims.

Take a good look at her vote on me. Not “Bingle is scum” but “I’ll lynch literally anyone but jjd.” There’s been no effort to try to read me or convince me I’m wrong on Vecna, because she doesn’t care which one of us gets lynched. Because as soon as there’s a hammer outside of her scumteam she wins.

I townread PP more than I scumread vecna. So JJD is town to me. Which means to me the best thing to do is vote you. Because of my townread on PP i cannot vote JJD

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

jjd #2 is bs and u know it

Check his 4323 and you'll get the meme