https://forum.mafiascum-staging.net/
Cheers - I like this solve too when binning Gamma as townIn post 4349, Andresvmb wrote:Yeah I think the last Scum is between the two. I don’t see Chaos as Scum and everybody else is ruled out in my mind due to mechanics or play.In post 4347, DkKoba wrote:So you figure Dwlee/Kyouko is likely then?
The remaining scum would still have a PT for results purposes though? How is that result useless?In post 4339, DkKoba wrote:plus PT cop prob useless at this stage as we are prob dealing with 1 group scum 1 traitor or just 1 groupscum. so yep
1 scum PT returns green on a PT copIn post 4352, Dragon of the West wrote:The remaining scum would still have a PT for results purposes though? How is that result useless?In post 4339, DkKoba wrote:plus PT cop prob useless at this stage as we are prob dealing with 1 group scum 1 traitor or just 1 groupscum. so yep
Not according to the wiki. A player in a PT by themselves will show up as “having access” to the PT Cop.In post 4355, DkKoba wrote:1 scum PT returns green on a PT copIn post 4352, Dragon of the West wrote:The remaining scum would still have a PT for results purposes though? How is that result useless?In post 4339, DkKoba wrote:plus PT cop prob useless at this stage as we are prob dealing with 1 group scum 1 traitor or just 1 groupscum. so yep
MafiaWiki wrote:Note that merely having access to a private topic is not necessarily enough to be able to communicate; there will have to be a second living player in the private topic in question to communicate with...
I think Andres is town if Gamma flips green. No way Titus and Andres are both scum while sitting in town!Gamma's check pool. But I don't think we should be assuming gamma is cleared at all and they 100% need to be flipped tomorrow. Their claim is convenient based on where the game state was when they claimed and I could easily see them being traitorIn post 4349, Andresvmb wrote:Yeah I think the last Scum is between the two. I don’t see Chaos as Scum and everybody else is ruled out in my mind due to mechanics or play.In post 4347, DkKoba wrote:So you figure Dwlee/Kyouko is likely then?
What I want you to think about and maybe not for this game is whether I would vote park my Partner all of D1, and then make a mechanical argument against my Partner while also suspecting them for other reasons (Titus). You already know that Town make mistakes obviously, but during those times that I’ve been focused, I think I’ve made decent points. I just don’t think you need to wait for Gamma to flip ever which way for me to be cleared. Based on what you’re saying, in the (remote) universe Gamma flips Traitor, I’m Scum. If Gamma flips main Scum, we’ve probably won, and if they flip Town PT Cop, then you’re saying I’m Town. So, what’s stopping you from just calling me Town?In post 4360, Dragon of the West wrote:I think Andres is town if Gamma flips green. No way Titus and Andres are both scum while sitting in town!Gamma's check pool. But I don't think we should be assuming gamma is cleared at all and they 100% need to be flipped tomorrow. Their claim is convenient based on where the game state was when they claimed and I could easily see them being traitorIn post 4349, Andresvmb wrote:Yeah I think the last Scum is between the two. I don’t see Chaos as Scum and everybody else is ruled out in my mind due to mechanics or play.In post 4347, DkKoba wrote:So you figure Dwlee/Kyouko is likely then?
Not on the day Titus was executed, no. They defended Rathe and concluded Titus or Chaos made sense as the execution, and voted Titus (while making a slight joke). DW just has a weird progression around Titus that day. It doesn’t read like solving, but instead just a player that can’t get caught away from the Titus wagon that’s relentlessly building. DW even voted Gamma before landing on Titus that day.In post 4370, Dragon of the West wrote:I'll reread Kyo's ISO in the morning. I feel like last time I read it the Titus vote and Kyo's surrounding ISO it didn't seem like town catching scum. Did they hop off the wagon or something?
But yeah no I was wrong here. They didn’t end up on Titus the first time around (when Anya was executed), but they did end up on Titus the day after Anya flipped.In post 4300, Andresvmb wrote:I was trying to see how Kyouko’s thinking had progressed, and they have some good posts and at one point they attack nom3 and leave a vote there for some ~400 posts. But they’ve clearly never ended on Scum that I can tell and have consistently voted for Town funny enough. I mean there’s votes for T3, Anya… were not on the final wagons on Titus or osuka as far as I can tell. It’s not a great history.