In post 431, Smudger wrote:Also please point to what in my ISO tells you I am scum?
I will summarize later but for now that would undermine the whole point of my request. So, no, I won't be telling you how to avoid dropping scum tells. I'll give you a hint, though, you just dropped another one with post 431.
Now that Smudger is replacing out, feels like we ought to get the explanation of this one.
@Pere - I love your read list...please justify the Yiley = town read NOW.
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2014 5:12 am
by Yiley
Probably cus I have done nothing that having me as town does make no sense
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2014 5:44 am
by PeregrineV
In post 447, XScorpion wrote:Why do you think Bro is town?
What do the asterisks mean?
Let me know what you think about cxinlee.
Recent game.
Nothing they are from the playerlist.
I think he's not playing to his wincon, but I think as scum he would at least try more to fit in, which you can also read as "try less to piss people off by doing nothing".
Lynching him for playing badly (or not playing) is OK, but a scum lynch is better.
I see an active and involved Yiley who flipped town.
Clearly I'm missing something - what is it?
Same style, same one-sentence posting limit, same feel.
Granted, I haven't explored any Yiley-scum games. Is this something worth the time to do, IYO?
I don't care if you do or don't. I'm still trying to understand the town read.
So basically you expect short one sentence posts to equate to him being town...to the point he doesn't need any further examination?
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2014 6:55 am
by Thor665
I mean, did you even consider whether short, one sentence posts were something he did or didn't do as scum?
This feels like saying 'Well, Thor is being sarcastic in this game, and in one other game I read he was sarcastic and was town - ergo, he's town here. Case closed!'
I see an active and involved Yiley who flipped town.
Clearly I'm missing something - what is it?
Same style, same one-sentence posting limit, same feel.
Granted, I haven't explored any Yiley-scum games. Is this something worth the time to do, IYO?
I don't care if you do or don't. I'm still trying to understand the town read.
So basically you expect short one sentence posts to equate to him being town...to the point he doesn't need any further examination?
18 pages in, no.
At this point, unless given reason, I'm throwing him into the town pile and can "further examine" later.
In post 460, Thor665 wrote:I mean, did you even consider whether short, one sentence posts were something he did or didn't do as scum?
This feels like saying 'Well, Thor is being sarcastic in this game, and in one other game I read he was sarcastic and was town - ergo, he's town here. Case closed!'
Not at this point, no.
But don't beat around the bush. Is Yiley a scumread of yours that you want me to look into, or is something else going on?
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2014 7:08 am
by PeregrineV
@Thor- and read my sig- I would most likely use that as a starting point!
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2014 8:40 am
by Thor665
In post 461, PeregrineV wrote:But don't beat around the bush. Is Yiley a scumread of yours that you want me to look into, or is something else going on?
I thought you said you'd read the game?
No?
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2014 8:48 am
by XScorpion
@Thor: who do you think is the scum pair now? I'm not sure who p5's buddy would be.
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2014 9:02 am
by jasonT1981
Antihero replaces Smudger
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2014 9:17 am
by Thor665
In post 464, XScorpion wrote:@Thor: who do you think is the scum pair now? I'm not sure who p5's buddy would be.
Well, an easy and obvious buddy would be Yiley, though I would tend to suspect this to actually be a buddying move towards town rather than a scumbuddy. But, honestly, I'm not even sure if I'm calling Pere scum yet. His reads are jacked up though, and I want to analyze them and him and see if he read, what he did or didn't read, and his thought process during that period.
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2014 9:19 am
by PeregrineV
In post 464, XScorpion wrote:@Thor: who do you think is the scum pair now? I'm not sure who p5's buddy would be.
And where did your scumread of me come from, considering I replaced in yesterday?
In post 461, PeregrineV wrote:But don't beat around the bush. Is Yiley a scumread of yours that you want me to look into, or is something else going on?
I thought you said you'd read the game?
No?
I did.
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2014 9:26 am
by Thor665
Then why are you unsure of my read on Yiley? I don't think I was subtle.
that having me as town does make no sense
