Mafiascum.net

northsidegal, profii
Aronis
Shoshin
stungun0404
GirlInFreezer

NicoRobin, Kokichi Oma, Creature

• please see the rules in the main thread if you haven't already.
  
• deadline for the decision to swap is in (expired on 2018-08-02 02:00:00)
  
• i got a kirlia thanks for asking
  
• prodding nicorobin

[/area]

In post 389, Kokichi Oma wrote:Um? We got both? And I said it didn't matter which game so he chose

Didn't you say you thought you were in the same game?

GirlInFreezer wrote:Like that whole one of 3 people are scum lynchpool doesn't really feel likely to come from scum
His 180 on you due to the meta stuff doesn't really feel like scum even if it's objectively -bad-

I think he's just a scummy dude and my experience has shown that

In post 446, GirlInFreezer wrote:you were a fuckton more substantive in lynchpin.

rc, check my scum games —> apart from transformers, you can check newbie 1875 where i actually made it to lylo after bussing my partner on d1 because i had literally no other option but to bus her d1. my partner there would not follow through with any of the plans i suggested in the scum pt, and it was frustrating me that the focus that day phase would not stay on a townplayer for very long before circling back to her, so i just decided to bus her.

as a result of looking at that, you’ll see that is nai for me to produce wallposts.

there’s really not a lot that’s pinged me so far, ASIDE from profii’s posts still have a relative lack of substance. i mean, sure he feels 1/3 players are scum. aronis likeliest, but that still isn’t really a hard stance.

nsg also just seems generally scummy, so nothing has changed for me

if i had to make a compromise option, there’s one thing that bothers me about aronis and that was his early advocating (even joking) of a quicklynch of kokichi, and there’s one of thing that bothers me regarding you rc, and that’s that i feel your content is reproducible by scum so far, but i have no idea how you play as scum and will have to meta scum you to draw some conclusions

In post 448, GirlInFreezer wrote:Like that whole one of 3 people are scum lynchpool doesn't really feel likely to come from scum

That's townish, yeah.

substantive has nothing to do with wall posts. you're more concerned with arguing about people's scumreads on you than actually producing content, you feel like you're taking scum positions rather than reacting genuinely to the thread, and I just generally dislike the way you're posting in a way that I think is alignment indicative.

In post 453, Shoshin wrote:

In post 448, GirlInFreezer wrote:Like that whole one of 3 people are scum lynchpool doesn't really feel likely to come from scum

That's townish, yeah.

explain why please @gif, and not shoshin.

like, i can see how it can be interpreted as that, but want to see if your explanation to see if you have the same idea that i have here

In post 455, stungun0404 wrote:

In post 453, Shoshin wrote:

In post 448, GirlInFreezer wrote:Like that whole one of 3 people are scum lynchpool doesn't really feel likely to come from scum

That's townish, yeah.

explain why please @gif, and not shoshin.

like, i can see how it can be interpreted as that, but want to see if your explanation to see if you have the same idea that i have here

How can you have the same idea if you're just saying that he's scum?

(the case made me smile, rc)

because it just popped in my head.

do you ever have a lightbulb go off that suggests “hey there’s a chance this person might be town and not scum” after you think about something. i still think he’s scummier overall, though, as his overall body of work pings me as scummy and not quite towny overall

but i’m sorting you right here because your answer is important, so focus

and i’m about to ask the mod if a comment i can make here is acceptable regarding my partner/the gamestate

by partner i mean friemd

In post 443, GirlInFreezer wrote:RC/NSG/Shoshin
Profii
Aronis/Kokichi
NR, Stungun (null)
Creature

is where I'm at rn

anyways i guess i mostly agree with this? well, maybe not entirely specifically, but if you were to squint hard enough i guess

i think creature is just honestly first and foremost, but beyond that i would put stungun above aronis and kokichi who i both think have a pretty decent shot of being scum

on nicorobin i honestly have no idea but if i had to just take a guess i would say she might not pick scum so i guess that's a minor reason to townread her

what i'm getting out of all of these are that aronis and kokichi both seem like people i'd be fine lynching at the moment

@nicorobin, what do you think of profii so far?

Wait what's your creature read?

I mostly agree with NSG's reads.

shoshin, you think nsg is top tier town so far.

ok wtf is going on here

lol @ Stun

In post 460, northsidegal wrote:i think creature is just honestly first and foremost, but beyond that i would put stungun above aronis and kokichi who i both think have a pretty decent shot of being scum

i think the word "town" somehow got omitted from here, so in case it wasn't clear

i think creature is just honestly town first and foremost

then we don't actually agree on any reads

shoshin you think profii is townier than me? you townread me in an earlier post on like page 14 or 15 and never explained your reason why. but why is it?


my reads are still consistent, and if anything similar reads are super duper strange this early in the game in a nine player game that supposedly has a bunch of players that are hard to sort



stungun, shoshin
nicorobin (go meta her replace out games and scum games and you’ll see why i think this)
kokichi
aronis
creature
nsg
profii


your case shoshin had me convinced on profii-scum. if i have not changed at all, i don’t understand what has made you do so, but it’s strange

i’m going to bed tho here shortly, cuz i have to get up early. be back tomorrow

and also will reevaluate things and try to make some more substantive posts either tomorrow or the following day

oh i forgot gif, put gif in between nico and kokichi

In post 467, GirlInFreezer wrote:

then we don't actually agree on any reads

-shrug-

if i'm wrong i expect that it'll be obvious as time goes on, so i guess it's not really something that i'm all that concerned about either way

I was kinda joking about agreeing with NSG, Stun. Like, my reads agreed with hers about as much as hers agreed with GiF.

In post 471, Shoshin wrote:I was kinda joking about agreeing with NSG, Stun. Like, my reads agreed with hers about as much as hers agreed with GiF.

what do you disagree with?

rc, why do you townread aronis?

In post 472, northsidegal wrote:

In post 471, Shoshin wrote:I was kinda joking about agreeing with NSG, Stun. Like, my reads agreed with hers about as much as hers agreed with GiF.

what do you disagree with?

I disagree on Kokichi, Profii, and Creature. I'd also list Stun as townier than either you or GiF.

Kokichi said a couple really townish things earlier in the game but his mason thing bothers the shit out of me, so I'm sort of null there, waiting on his answers to my questions plus more content. I think once I settle my read here I'll have a strong idea about who the scum are.

Creature isn't as town as you seem to think. I agree that he's likely to pick town but there's a chance they got two scum PMs, so it's not that telling by itself.

If I had to guess, I'd pick Aronis/Profii as scum right now. The amount of suspicion that Aronis has shown towards Profii is really unnatural, in a way that makes me think he's distancing, and both have been playing independently scummy. GiF's right that Profii's dropped some hints of town but I don't think they really outweigh how closely his play resembles his play as scum and how different it looks from his play as town, especially in terms of how non-commital he's been and how he's focusing much more on what's scummy rather than what's towny.