In post 345, farside22 wrote:
Why does drews post bother you?
How do you get to that conclusion based on tanners comment.
Drew just seems to have accepted their fate. Its just almost sad that they are giving up as a caught scum though there is no real issue with it. Knowing this couldn't mav just be a backup as well for Mafia I believe I has saw it in the Normal list.
Sorry I'm not one for normals a lot of the time and its just something I look at.
Reading back Ill take the comment about tanner comes across as scum hunting with the exception of the push onto Drew but then again Drew is looking like a fish out of water at the moment. Well rather has been for a while in this game.
*Looks to see whom you replaced, feels very happy with scum read*
Mod: Please update player list and could we please have a vote count
@Wake: Do you know when the mod will let people know you are the IC? I thought that happened from the start or day 2. Can't remember because it's been awhile.
The mod posted my IC status at start of game. First post of Day 1.
is a scum claim. It's one of the oldest tricks in the book. I used it in my very first scum game here. It didn't work then, and it's still scummy af now. Tomorrow is when we deal with what we'll do tomorrow. Like the vig discussion, it's just a distraction from what's going on now.
+1
Ill agree with this it's even used as a gambit in newbie games among others.
Also I thought IC's were normally announced at the start unless its some weird role where they can have mod confirmed status later or something but doesn't make sense for this game.
Drew you with your reads there was nothing substantial to gain from it. You see farside as a town read with not much on the rest of the player base.
is a scum claim. It's one of the oldest tricks in the book. I used it in my very first scum game here. It didn't work then, and it's still scummy af now. Tomorrow is when we deal with what we'll do tomorrow. Like the vig discussion, it's just a distraction from what's going on now.
+1
Ill agree with this it's even used as a gambit in newbie games among others.
Also I thought IC's were normally announced at the start unless its some weird role where they can have mod confirmed status later or something but doesn't make sense for this game.
Drew you with your reads there was nothing substantial to gain from it. You see farside as a town read with not much on the rest of the player base.
That’s either a lie by omission, an outright lie or you haven’t read the thread or what I’ve said properly. All three are shit.
Posted: Wed Apr 22, 2020 12:28 am
by farside22
Drew: Just a recap on scum reads would be great please.
Posted: Wed Apr 22, 2020 12:41 am
by Drew-Sta
George buddied me.
Mavs is either outright town or the ballsiest scum player on this site.
Pers is ok, I think.
Panda and Knightmare have questions. I read Knightmare as scum IMHO.
Una might be VI but reads scummy to to me.
Pran and Riabi went mostly quiet after the CC. Riabi’s refusal to talk due to my walls (apparently) was not the reaction I expected.
That’s all I got.
Posted: Wed Apr 22, 2020 12:42 am
by Drew-Sta
Oh, and Tanner reaction seemed normal.
Posted: Wed Apr 22, 2020 12:44 am
by Drew-Sta
Although the fact Tanner knew why Luca was VLA does strike me as odd.
Posted: Wed Apr 22, 2020 12:57 am
by Tanner
I've played with Luca before, for what it's worth.
I still have a bit of hope you're trolling, but that hope is dwindling fast.
Mavs is either outright town or the ballsiest scum player on this site.
Pers is ok, I think.
Panda and Knightmare have questions. I read Knightmare as scum IMHO.
Una might be VI but reads scummy to to me.
Pran and Riabi went mostly quiet after the CC. Riabi’s refusal to talk due to my walls (apparently) was not the reaction I expected.
That’s all I got.
I mean... I've very much not gone "mostly quiet" after the CC. Sure, I've not gone looking through all of the past posts, which I'll aim to do over night, but I've definitely been posting, just because I'm not able to reply constantly doesn't mean I've gone quiet.
Posted: Wed Apr 22, 2020 1:41 am
by Knightmare491
If this game actually has two millers then we all can complain about the setup and not include this game in our history.
Ez
Posted: Wed Apr 22, 2020 1:43 am
by farside22
In post 457, Tanner wrote:I've played with Luca before, for what it's worth.
I still have a bit of hope you're trolling, but that hope is dwindling fast.
Has scum trolled like that in a game?
Posted: Wed Apr 22, 2020 1:45 am
by Tanner
I know some scum like to keep claiming Town even after the hammer falls. And it's more for my own sanity of "there can't be two Millers... right?"
Posted: Wed Apr 22, 2020 1:50 am
by farside22
In post 462, Tanner wrote:I know some scum like to keep claiming Town even after the hammer falls. And it's more for my own sanity of "there can't be two Millers... right?"
1 for 1 isn't something I see right from the start of a game. I'm not going to throw it out the door and say keep manvs, but I think players need to talk more about scum reads and those saying they would just lynch manv after need to explain more the wifom the set up.
Posted: Wed Apr 22, 2020 1:53 am
by Drew-Sta
In post 462, Tanner wrote:I know some scum like to keep claiming Town even after the hammer falls. And it's more for my own sanity of "there can't be two Millers... right?"
Mate, there might not be two millers, but you’ve just lynched one.
Posted: Wed Apr 22, 2020 2:01 am
by Tanner
Technically I haven't lynched anyone, I wasn't on your wagon. c:
The issue remains that double of any role in a game is dubious at best (other than obviously roles like VT or Masons), and especially Millers since it was very very likely at least one of them would claim early. That's almost guaranteed one mislynch + either a possible investigate shot going there or an additional mislynch. None of it makes sense.
But scum counterclaiming a Miller claim Day 1 is also such a ??? play. That's why I'm saying I still have that tiny glimmer of hope Drew is simply trolling. I don't want to deal with the headache afterwards if he's not.
In post 462, Tanner wrote:I know some scum like to keep claiming Town even after the hammer falls. And it's more for my own sanity of "there can't be two Millers... right?"
1 for 1 isn't something I see right from the start of a game. I'm not going to throw it out the door and say keep manvs, but I think players need to talk more about scum reads and those saying they would just lynch manv after need to explain more the wifom the set up.
I think you need to work out who actually debated during the day. I can’t see scum putting effort into the lynch after the CC. They’d have coasted.
Posted: Wed Apr 22, 2020 2:03 am
by Drew-Sta
In post 465, Tanner wrote:Technically I haven't lynched anyone, I wasn't on your wagon. c:
The issue remains that double of any role in a game is dubious at best (other than obviously roles like VT or Masons), and especially Millers since it was very very likely at least one of them would claim early. That's almost guaranteed one mislynch + either a possible investigate shot going there or an additional mislynch. None of it makes sense.
But scum counterclaiming a Miller claim Day 1 is also such a ??? play. That's why I'm saying I still have that tiny glimmer of hope Drew is simply trolling. I don't want to deal with the headache afterwards if he's not.
I’ll bring you a couple of Panadol and a beer, because you’re about to have a migraine.
Posted: Wed Apr 22, 2020 2:05 am
by Tanner
Drew, no matter your flip, you're a fun guy. Sorry we couldn't play together longer.
Posted: Wed Apr 22, 2020 2:07 am
by Drew-Sta
In post 468, Tanner wrote:Drew, no matter your flip, you're a fun guy. Sorry we couldn't play together longer.
I really appreciate that comment
Posted: Wed Apr 22, 2020 2:27 am
by Knightmare491
Yeah yer a fungi
Posted: Wed Apr 22, 2020 2:32 am
by Drew-Sta
Posted: Wed Apr 22, 2020 2:32 am
by Drew-Sta
Booooo my shit posting abilities.
Posted: Wed Apr 22, 2020 4:39 am
by Not Known 15
Drew-Sta
has been lynched Day 1. They were:
Spoiler:
Night 1 begins and ends in (expired on 2020-04-24 10:41:00).
Posted: Fri Apr 24, 2020 4:46 am
by Not Known 15
farside22
has been killed Night 1. They were:
Spoiler:
Day 2 begins and ends in (expired on 2020-05-01 10:50:00).
