We have to assume worst case scenario and they can double kill because Titus and Mastina said so.
Which means we are screwed.
Posted: Sat Oct 24, 2020 2:26 am
by MathBlade
The fact Morning Mage outed themselves instead of the hood telling you to lie and be the third was also incredibly incredibly bad. If you can read between by lines here EE.
In post 2925, MathBlade wrote:I am leaning towards not multiball just the wagons don’t make sense.
For the record, to weigh in:
I am pretty sure this wouldn't be the first MBOS game to feature a scum doublekill mechanic, so it's possible scum killed
both
Menalque and Ban Hydras.
If scum did not kill both Menalque and Ban Hydras, then it'd necessarily need to be either a town role misfiring (where some effect of their role accidentally killed them), or a town vig who took a bad shot.
I do not believe the game to be multiball; I don't even think the game has a serial killer.
The two kills are either both from scum, or one from scum and the other from town. (And if the latter, again, 75-25 it being Mena as the scum kill, but with the admitted possibility of it having been Ban Hydras. We'll presumably not find out for quite some time.)
There’s one for starters.
There’s one from Titus too yesterday and I think another today.
Posted: Sat Oct 24, 2020 2:40 am
by MathBlade
If we don’t have a vig like Titus implies and we don’t have a serial killer like Mastina implies, what else is left?
Like help me out here. I have to go to the doctor now but I am very scared.
We're also responsible for the A50 being king today. I only mention it because our ability blocks all kills on the target and we're missing a kill.
Yes please...continue to tell scum how protectives work.
When we absolutely do not have the numbers to spare to scum double kills.
Titus you are either brain dead,scum siding, or just not planning ahead.
Wtf is going on in that hood?
I swear y’all are attempting to remove more pants unprompted because “we have 6 masons nothing can go wrong”
It doesn’t matter how many people are townfirm to you if the tanks on E, credit cards maxed, and no damn money in the bank.
Please fucking stop.
The protection is in the past.
I don't buy this readwall helps scum crap.
Posted: Sat Oct 24, 2020 2:53 am
by Titus
In post 4550, MathBlade wrote:But your hood says we don’t have a vig or at least implied it. I am hoping we have a vig. If we don’t have a vig then every scumread has to go.
On the contrary, we think the second kill must be a vig. No serial killers allowed.
In post 4550, MathBlade wrote:Town players become demotivated because what they say doesn’t matter
Not true. Yellibg falsehoods while not hunting scum gets you ignored.
Posted: Sat Oct 24, 2020 2:58 am
by Titus
In post 4556, Bell wrote:I would like to just state that for whatever reason my worthless gut says Titus is scum.
Someone said she was confirmed masons with another player or two. could you guys reiterate there that this is the case and that Titus is confirmed town so I don't have to brain space case myself.
Yes. mastina, Nero and I are confirmed aligned together.
Almost50 superbowl9 and ? are confirmed aligned together.
Our information makes it nigh on impossible for them to be scum. (There is a moonlogic chance but it's not worth discussing it's that bad.)
They've seen our wincon because we trust them.
Same with Norway who is conftown to us.
Posted: Sat Oct 24, 2020 3:02 am
by Titus
Tbh, I figured you were the vig. I am supposing A50 ate the second shot.
Posted: Sat Oct 24, 2020 3:02 am
by Titus
It could just be a one shot vig though.
Posted: Sat Oct 24, 2020 3:05 am
by Titus
Math, talk to me about DDL, jjh, and Pete? Why is DDL the scummiest?
Posted: Sat Oct 24, 2020 3:39 am
by MathBlade
DDL vs Pete is just a case of who seems to be playing. Ddl only memorable post for me is about the BTS army. Pete I remember a post here or there.
Jjh is SK or scum because of play and ascetic claim. I disagree with Mastina’s setup spec again. Shocking I know. I lean SK simply because town Vig is too much power and being able to track JJH to a kill would then be either such a boon/bust to be ridiculous.
If I had a three way nuke I wouldn’t cry about them dying. I just don’t think wagoning any of them gives anything since their entire play is lurker hell.
Posted: Sat Oct 24, 2020 3:49 am
by MathBlade
In post 4587, Titus wrote:Tbh, I figured you were the vig. I am supposing A50 ate the second shot.
I will neither confirm nor deny this.
Posted: Sat Oct 24, 2020 3:51 am
by MathBlade
Although I will ask that you quit hunting for a Vig/PR openly.
1- I underestimated the "shallowness" of the Scum team, obviously. I thought you don't kill an ODD-Night Investigative on an EVEN night.
But what does that hint to you?? Anyone? I'll keep my answer to myself for the meantime and let you all respond first. I want to see who thinks what, please.
2- Is that supposed to help me? Cuz 2 of those were already in my suspects pool, yet none of them was in my proposed execution pool of today. (We will most probably convene and decide between us all 7. ("Someone" has been added to the hood overnight, and -since I'm not AT ALL- caught up in here I am not saying whom)
I will catch up in a bit
Posted: Sat Oct 24, 2020 3:54 am
by Titus
There is no SK Math.
If you don't think wagoning any of them is useful, who would you wagon outside the council of 6? Why?
How do you feel about the consensus largely being on DDL?
If you don't think wagoning any of them is useful, who would you wagon outside the council of 6? Why?
How do you feel about the consensus largely being on DDL?
Last question first. It’s mostly meh. These three players are all “gotta go”s for me and we can learn from it based on DDLs flip not before. It’s what Mastina and you did with April.
I would probably wagon TGP based off a certain question he asked at the end of the day ish (mobile sorry) that seems to be waaaay too focused more so than other players.
Third one. Again, with the setup as presented there is something wrong. So I am ignoring your setup spec (no matter how “mod” confirmed it is.) If you’re townsiding and are 100% sure let me deceive the scum. “Correcting” me is antitown.
Posted: Sat Oct 24, 2020 4:08 am
by TheGoldenParadox
In post 4593, Almost50 wrote:But what does that hint to you?? Anyone? I'll keep my answer to myself for the meantime and let you all respond first. I want to see who thinks what, please.
i'd think it means that they have some reliable way to figure out PRs and believe they can know the identity of another PR by tomorrow night.
In post 4593, Almost50 wrote:But what does that hint to you?? Anyone? I'll keep my answer to myself for the meantime and let you all respond first. I want to see who thinks what, please.
i'd think it means that they have some reliable way to figure out PRs and believe they can know the identity of another PR by tomorrow night.
Yeah it’s shit like this I would want to wagon.
It seems “TMI”.
What this normally would be IMO is a struggling newbie scum team that doesn’t understand NAR.
today, Almost50 will choose the execution singlehandedly.
You all hear this?? You all had better start sucking up to me. BOW to your KING
Kneel, I say!
Posted: Sat Oct 24, 2020 4:17 am
by DiamondSentinel
Alright. Allow me to play devil's advocate (although to an extent I believe this).
Why are we giving norway the 1 shot BP? No offense to them, but they aren't exactly doing a lot. I suspect they aren't the first pick by scum to be killed. It'll be a shame to go to El-Lo with a 50/50 for them, but like, that's what it usually is anyways.
