In post 4555, catboi wrote:the idea that scum have an ability that essentially townfirms its target would have to be wildly, game-alteringly strong. And there's still no reason scum wouldn't be able to bluff by claiming they were molded. Although I don't really support voting any molded claim today.
It could be a permanent Roleblock or an alternative wincon. "Confirming" someone as town isn't really true though because we can only theorize that as the truth. Pretty sure we're meant to be paranoid about it, but the fact that scum keeps killing town read players and Molding controversial players just implies that scum is spewing Mold victims as town.
theres no wincon alteration since game is non-bastard.
doesn't really make sense as scum pr.
personally i think it's cult, exept the culted don't change wincon/know they are culted. s why i said leave it 4 scum to hunt.
The game is confirmed to not have Cults.
Alternative scum wincons are entirely possible, SCP UPick had one for instance. Looking up the lore I'm not even sure if it could have a PR analogue that wouldn't be bastard-y, so if it isn't a Roleblock then alt wincon is the only thing that makes sense to me.
In post 4555, catboi wrote:the idea that scum have an ability that essentially townfirms its target would have to be wildly, game-alteringly strong. And there's still no reason scum wouldn't be able to bluff by claiming they were molded. Although I don't really support voting any molded claim today.
It could be a permanent Roleblock or an alternative wincon. "Confirming" someone as town isn't really true though because we can only theorize that as the truth. Pretty sure we're meant to be paranoid about it, but the fact that scum keeps killing town read players and Molding controversial players just implies that scum is spewing Mold victims as town.
I don’t really get why scum would mold controversial slots when those are primary limbait?
That's kind of my point though? If they Molded an obvtown slot then we'd 100% know that it's a scum ability with little reason to question it. But by Molding controversial slots, now town is going to question it and doubt if all the Mold claims are real or come from scum trying to get a free pass. If Mold victims get mis-elim'd it still pushes the scum wincon forward because townies are dying and scum lives one more day.
In post 4532, Toogeloo wrote:**Holds game hostage to find replacement**
**Replacement dies**
yea i thought the way the replace went donwn was pr-indic, perhaps the scum agreed.
either that or it's meant to preserve gamestate.
assuming nero was the scum-kill here.
Um no? Don’t you know it’s standard procedure for game mods to extend deadline after replacement. Doesn’t matter what their role is. And that is precisely so people won’t speculate on the role of the replacement.
Out of the three wagons, I would vote here. I feel like Ircher has been talked about enough that I don't really think the reasons they're being wolfread are enough for me to join and quite frankly, having our vote be on them would feel rather stale so let's spice it up a little. lol Mastina
tictac shows up and visibly has no interest in finding scum and is engaging in baseless spec on the mold instead
Posted: Thu Feb 03, 2022 3:58 am
by Malakittens
VOTE: tictac
Posted: Thu Feb 03, 2022 5:16 am
by Galron
wrt the mail and to the mold, no one is taking responsibility for either. And we don't know their use. And they're going to different people. Has anyone received both?
Posted: Thu Feb 03, 2022 5:18 am
by Galron
I'm voting for tictac btw, just want to make sure I'm not hammering.
Posted: Thu Feb 03, 2022 5:21 am
by The Three Bears
lets not end the day early. titus still wants to do her VCA.
I agree with tictac scum because those first posts today look so damn TMI but also like this is going waaaay too fast for me to feel good about it.
Give the wagon a pause button rq I'm going to go get titus
-noraa
Posted: Thu Feb 03, 2022 5:23 am
by The Three Bears
the other reason im hesitant is because i called tictac scum on like day 1 and thats uh, thats scary lmao. my day 1 reads arent typically good oml.
also, unless everyone is convinced cephrir is town, we should at least look at that today. he's been slipping by eveyr single day now.
so this goes into a little self meta but for the most part, this specific type of analysis tends to work. this is by no means a mathblade level read. I was 100% that dude was scum and that isn't the case here with tictac. but here's the thing. theres a lot of different kind of players out there but almost every single one that has not given me a chance in a TvT situation does it again after the first time. So like if they were town and i was town and they just fully believed i was scum and would not reconsider. Tictac did that in our last game.
Now there are exceptions. Occasionally I play really really towny town games but this isn't one of them so tictac should at least have a SL on me. Most of my posts are not an insane length so reading them shouldn't be an issue. Tictac already gave reads on like seven different people and there is no scum read on me. theres an issue here. another thing is that their posts are VERY tonally different here. I'm lazy so i haven't gone back and looked to be able to pick out the differences but it is definitely pretty different. i dont think the bunny is town here.
In post 946, The Three Bears wrote:its sort of like certain players strike me as insanely scummy and their posts stick out an insane amount to me when im town. pretty sure that is tictac with me.
In post 945, The Three Bears wrote:someone who finds my play style very scummy isn't gonna suddenly not after 1 game. not how it works.
And what if they just used the information they gained from the previous game. And thus conclude that when you play in a way that they considered scum indicative previously, that it is NAI?
I’m null on Tictac atm, but i find your logic faulty.
nope. not how it works. tictac scum read me in all my games so far. people dont change like that.
In post 959, The Three Bears wrote:its a playstyle clash. it takes more than 2 games to resolve.
the fact that no one here SRs me should be even more of an issue to tictac
In post 1067, The Three Bears wrote:Ircher - I don't like I don't have a solid read here. Would be willing to lim for info but don't feel good about it.
MUSH - Tone feels weird. Would eliminate but I'm struggling with a lot of tone.
Lady Lambdadelta - Withholding read until certain.
Bell - Town.
Cephrir - Town
Andante Dwlee99 - Town
NorwegianboyEE - Moderate Town
The Three Bears (Titus, Flea the Magician, Noraa) - Town
Galron - Lean town
Roden - Town
Malakittens - Null
Mastina - Lean Town
Arcade Pals (Dunnstral, MariaR) - Scum
Princess Elodie* - Weak Town
Tet - Moderate to Weak town
MegAzumarill - Would lim but worried
tictac - Moderate town
Toogeloo - Lean scum
T3 - gtmh scum
Save The Dragons - Lean Town
Greeting - gtmh town
~Mama
THE BUNNY IS SCUMMMMMMMMMMM
Posted: Thu Feb 03, 2022 5:27 am
by catboi
tictac is at E-2
not opposed to voting ceph at some point
Posted: Thu Feb 03, 2022 5:38 am
by The Three Bears
tictac is probably scum. ceph can live another day.
-noraa
Posted: Thu Feb 03, 2022 5:44 am
by The Three Bears
ok yeah reading tictacs posts today, YIKES YIKES YIKES. red flags all over the place.
i still have too many srs though. like mastina, cephrir, toog?, andante?, fenrir? for scum
andante and norwee for 3p
by my calculations, we have 4 scum left. 3 scum and 1 3p. thinking about 3p hunting has like broken my brain
-noraa
Posted: Thu Feb 03, 2022 5:44 am
by The Three Bears
(reading them again that is)
Posted: Thu Feb 03, 2022 5:45 am
by catboi
andante was going after arcade hard on day 1 and isn't typically a busser
Posted: Thu Feb 03, 2022 5:46 am
by The Three Bears
12 people.
3 scum
1 3p
8 town
i have far too many srs and we dont agree on some reads in the hydra. flea thinks massy is town. titus' early read there was scum i believe?
toog has had me pretty paranoid for many days now and i dont know how to feel about it.
idk.
-noraa
Posted: Thu Feb 03, 2022 5:48 am
by The Three Bears
In post 4596, catboi wrote:andante was going after arcade hard on day 1 and isn't typically a busser
idk if i consider whatever they did day 1 "going hard" because as far as im concerned, andante has cased like five different people who arent dunn but never cased dunn ever. mvoed off the dunn wagon like seven times yesterday and dropped two wall cases yesterday in attempts to save dunn.
-noraa
Posted: Thu Feb 03, 2022 5:50 am
by catboi
having a short attention span is well within her townrange
