Mafiascum.net

In post 3378, Dwlee99 wrote:skitter30 and Toogeloo voted peta

I voted ydrasse

Infinity 324 voted gammagooey

ulyana voted for Gypyx

Taly wasn't voting

Pink votes

In post 4617, Gamma Emerald wrote:That’s about what I expected from you, Dwlee.

Glad I met expectations lol

In post 4619, SirCakez wrote:

In post 4614, petapan wrote:cakez why are you so insistent on rushing everything when it's clear that making hasty decisions led us down a bad path last event and you yourself have expressed difficulty with your reads this game

I want to get the process moving is all because we have to do like ~8 of these? and we're giving more time for scum to manipulate things

then we vote on a PoE and get "the process" completed . i wrote an entire wall about how doing this piecemeal is going to fuck things up and the event design is meant to mess with people's thinking in that fashion

In post 4620, SirCakez wrote:and I don't think last phase was rushed anyways - I don't really see a world where Infinity was not the elim there

well obviously that was the wrong decision and i am not satisfied with the thinking that went into it and feel there is a need for re-evaluation. i am confused why you seem content to mostly barrel ahead

Ulyana
SirCakez
Toogeloo
Peta
Taly
Ydrasse
Dwlee99
Gamma Emerald



Y'all ready to just plow through this?
VOTE: Ulyana

i like harley :/

More than ulya? Y/N

Here's my reasoning: If Gypyx is town, Harley has a good chance of being scum. If Harley is town then the other way around. Makes sense to put both in then

In post 4631, Dwlee99 wrote:Here's my reasoning: If Gypyx is town, Harley has a good chance of being scum. If Harley is town then the other way around. Makes sense to put both in then

I agree to some extent but I have other irons in the fire that p much prevent that from happening

she feels sincere even if the content isn’t hard hitting and my readeste on her isn’t perfect but it’s pretty good

also her predecessor was... fine to me? we aligned in reads esp on infinity even if it was wrong it felt /sincere/ and in depth when there wasn’t a necessity for it at all when the rest of the room wanted it sans gamma

(also i have thoughts on their exit but i can’t say them bc rep out but it’s +town in the motivation)

i feel more sure on harley bc ulyana is saying things that feel unfamiliar and i’m prone to scumreading her but i think both could be town

i take gypyx as scum over harley scum...

my spiciest thought is if you want to do pairs put in skitter/peta to hit scum bc they don’t feel aligned

I mean I could swap Ulta/Harley or peta and one of them. We can discuss it more but do we agree that we just need to pick 2 of Ulta/Harley/Peta and agree on everything else?

It's possible all three are town and my list is still right ftr

I might re-read Gypyx and Ydrasse a bit tonight/tomorrow (Toog I disagree with being on the survive list for now but I could maybe deal with it for a skitter+harley death)

Ulyana I'd be fine with voting across first, Cakez I'm pretty fine w/ too atm

In post 4636, Dwlee99 wrote:I mean I could swap Ulta/Harley or peta and one of them. We can discuss it more but do we agree that we just need to pick 2 of Ulta/Harley/Peta and agree on everything else?

Pick for leaving behind? Because we’re not leaving peta behind here, nuh uh.

In post 4615, Dwlee99 wrote:<insert one person from the bottom>
SirCakez
Toogeloo
Peta
Taly
Ydrasse
Dwlee99
Gamma Emerald

ulyana
Harley Quinn
skitter30
Gypyx
Gammagooey

I started rereading from event start and then town binned people occasionally and got to this point at page 179. Thoughts?

I also ordered the top list in terms of order I think we should cross with. So feel free to discuss that

UNVOTE:

Why is Gammagoodey at the bottom of your list? Why is he scum? He should be much higher on your list.

In post 4639, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 4636, Dwlee99 wrote:I mean I could swap Ulta/Harley or peta and one of them. We can discuss it more but do we agree that we just need to pick 2 of Ulta/Harley/Peta and agree on everything else?

Pick for leaving behind? Because we’re not leaving peta behind here, nuh uh.

2 to keep

In post 4616, Dwlee99 wrote:I'm really torn between including Harley or ulyana in the top list. I feel good about letting skitter / Gypyx/ gammagooey dying

I don’t understand this. I would put gammagooey above Ulanya.

In post 4624, petapan wrote:

In post 4603, Harley Quinn wrote:Also Gypyx should not cross, he’s currently my strongest sr.

based on what

Gut.

nunununu i cant really post because occupied and phone but dwlee now using “reevaluating” to possibly exclude me after treating me as definitely town for pink pt is !!!!! like something is definitely afoot

like how would this happen with multiple people most of whom dwlee included haven’t given reasoning and when they have it was literally the posts of a flipped mafia

In post 4638, Gammagooey wrote:I might re-read Gypyx and Ydrasse a bit tonight/tomorrow (Toog I disagree with being on the survive list for now but I could maybe deal with it for a skitter+harley death)

Ulyana I'd be fine with voting across first, Cakez I'm pretty fine w/ too atm

my first impulse is that i continue to not think toogeloo plays this way as scum and would not put them in my PoE, the advocacy for getting rid of them is a little puzzling

In post 4631, Dwlee99 wrote:Here's my reasoning: If Gypyx is town, Harley has a good chance of being scum. If Harley is town then the other way around. Makes sense to put both in then

Very simple, you flip me first because I will flip town and then my reads will get taken seriously. It seems that few people are willing to listen to me while I’m alive, so my reads will get the respect they didn’t once I’m dead and I’m good with that.

I feel like even when Toog’s been town in a bad spot there’s a certain degree of give-a-shit he’s not displaying here

In post 4646, Harley Quinn wrote:

In post 4631, Dwlee99 wrote:Here's my reasoning: If Gypyx is town, Harley has a good chance of being scum. If Harley is town then the other way around. Makes sense to put both in then

Very simple, you flip me first because I will flip town and then my reads will get taken seriously. It seems that few people are willing to listen to me while I’m alive, so my reads will get the respect they didn’t once I’m dead and I’m good with that.

???
Dwlee is literally trying to flip both you and your strongest SR
Why this attitude?

In post 4627, petapan wrote:

In post 4619, SirCakez wrote:

In post 4614, petapan wrote:cakez why are you so insistent on rushing everything when it's clear that making hasty decisions led us down a bad path last event and you yourself have expressed difficulty with your reads this game

I want to get the process moving is all because we have to do like ~8 of these? and we're giving more time for scum to manipulate things

then we vote on a PoE and get "the process" completed

all at once

. i wrote an entire wall about how doing this piecemeal is going to fuck things up and the event design is meant to mess with people's thinking in that fashion

In post 4620, SirCakez wrote:and I don't think last phase was rushed anyways - I don't really see a world where Infinity was not the elim there

well obviously that was the wrong decision and i am not satisfied with the thinking that went into it and feel there is a need for re-evaluation. i am confused why you seem content to mostly barrel ahead

ok I see re the first thing you said
but are you saying you would have rather died than Infinity??