Mafiascum.net

Mr. flay, for clarification, I didn't want a break down of mine and tip's posts, though thanks for doing that. I wanted a progression of your reads on both of us. For example, what made you think I was town, and when, and then what changed your mind, and why, and the same for tip. I don't understand your progressions on either of these players, while for example your read on spicer is pretty straight forward.

Whooptybatfuck

TiP, if you try really hard, you could be even more useless and inspire people to policy lynch you!

We aren't PLing TIP.

Stop saying that. It's a broken record and has never been productive.

There are people pushing others to find scum. Why the fuck would they lower themselves to a PL.

There are many people who believe that a policy lynch is not a lowering at all.

Why wouldn't it be? It's not a lynch for finding them scummy. It's a waste of a lynch that could be used towards actually lynching scum. What use does PLing have?

There are many people that believe in policy lynching when it is a net benefit to the town and has a chance of hitting scum anyway. All instances of policy lynching discussed in this thread have been like this. I don't really think TiP qualifies, really, but it's certainly arguable.

Flay is Town, don't touch him

I wish Darox would just shoot TIP and we can move on. Cause if darox is lying he is getting lynched so it's really a win/win situation

Didn't you say you had a townread on me?
Anyway, more attention on Ingrid and Kid A please.

In post 486, TheIrishPope wrote:Didn't you say you had a townread on me?
Anyway, more attention on Ingrid and Kid A please.

I don't think I did, and if I did it was because by poe I don't think the scum team is Amrun/Kid/you, but I really don't remember calling you town

That's fine, anyway. Can we get a read list off of you, or just three top scumreads, please?

I have named the 2 scum and since this game most likely has only 2 scum I don't see why I need to throw a 3rd name into the mix


how about you stop being a useless turd and scumhunt or something...

Just in case someone gets vigged and they flip Town, I do need a third name, kthx. And ouch, that hurts my feelings.

Why? There's 2 scum so a 3rd is pointless.

But ok I just rolled the dice and it says gorgat is 3rd name. Better?

It's interesting that you the existence of two scum. Thanks for providing a third name, though.

This game only has 9 players, I've never seen a 3 scum game with 10 players before.

10 players, not 9

It's certainly a possibility, don't you think? With everyone having a power role, I wouldn't be surprised.

Do games need to be balanced in mini-themes? If yes than no it's not possible. If no, then I guess it's possible.

They may have "significant changes to game mechanics and rules".

so now your turn, list of 3 scum reads and I am going to take an extra step and ask you to explain why.

Ingrid: My super case still stands, especially with her latest posts. I don't care if she's a Newbie; she's scum.
Kid A: Refuses to respond, lurks, only surfaces when someone talks about him, and that is textbook scum.
Third Scum: TBD