Newbie 1700 - GAME OVER

[tojam2]

If I hadn't claimed town on Hoppic, when we lynched him I would be confscum D4.

[Ghostwheel]

No but killing karnos in the night as opposed to Hoppic. I didn't understand that especially after Hoppic made a post saying these are the people who could be scum and Ghostwheel and Tojam aren't on that list.

[Rob14]

Vote Count #3.1 (FINAL):

tojam2:

Hoppic, tojam2, BTD6_maker (3)

Not Voting:

cytheflyguy, Ghostwheel

With 5 players alive, it takes 3 to lynch.

V/LA:

None.

Deadline:

(expired on 2016-05-20 04:30:00)

[Rob14]

tojam2,

Mafia Goon

, was lynched Day 3.

Town wins!

[Rob14]

Mod/Dead PT: http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=90&t=66171
Mafia PT: http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=90&t=66172

JohnLockeisKobeBryant - VT
BTD6_maker - VT
Hoppic - Town Cop
thatguy - VT
Ghostwheel - VT
karnos - VT
Workdawg (SE) - Mafia Roleblocker
tojam2 (SE) - Mafia Goon
Huntress (IC) - Town Doctor

Night 1 Actions:
RadiantCowbells kills thatguy.
No roleblock.
Hoppic investigates ghostwheel.

Night 2 Actions:
tojam2 kills karnos.
Hoppic investigates cytheflyguy.

[Ghostwheel]

K so I really should have just trusted my instincts with my town read on BTD and Hoppic and rolled with that.

Even so I guess I tried about as I could to throw the game for us.

I think I'm going to really hang back in future games and stop hurting towns more than I'm helping them.

Really sorry Huntress that I scumread you for what was essentially sketchy logic.

karnos' midgame initiative was nice and was really was I wanted to be seeing this whole game.

tojam is the first sketchy as shit player I've seen that rolled scum this time, and RC was the first overly confident little explanation player I've seen roll scum. Really difficult for me to tell the difference between town and scum that play like either of these which is why it pisses me off that I consistently see town play like this.

I felt like thatguy was just not really here which is a shame because he seemed like a good player.

BTD was fine and I guess even now I still don't understand where the initial scumread came from in day 1, but hey I got convinced in day 2 so whatever.

Hoppic was cool, laid low, got comfortable asking questions.

Cy I hope you had fun even though it was a longer and crazier game than you might be used to. When you had an opinion to share it was actually pretty good. Best of luck in future games and good job in this one.

[BTD6_maker]

To be honest, I got pretty frustrated when RC strong armed me but I guess that's what the aim was. Question is whether strong arming is a reliable scumtell.

Also, for some strange reason, both scum were on their own wagon. Is self-voting generally exclusive to scum trying to stop their partner from being detected?

Overall, this was a great first game and gave me a good impression of MS.net. I feel that these games are much more balanced than "draw Dayvig, feel Godfather's arm, get NKed Night 0".

By the way, Ghostwheel, what was your colour test answer and what would you have said for the other wrong answers?

[RadiantCowbells]

I didn't have time to push your lynch and I didn't want to make time.
I had cop pinned and Tojam looked really town from my flip so I figured I'd give him the cop and let him play the last two days.
For some reason he killed someone who had claimed VT instead of cop ??? but whatever.

[Ghostwheel]

The color test was something I was trying out because I got bored and a friend of mine on another site actually got a mafia both times he tried it here. It's just a straight reaction test. If people act like they've got something to hide or give a fakey as shit response like "how could someone's favorite color determine whether they're mafia" it makes them look slightly worse in my mind. Neither of the scum bit this time. I don't put really any stock in it, but it was going to be so much better for me to deal with than "Why are you trying to get our most helpful player lynched?" and all of the extremely silly wagoning that was going to follow. Like I can't stand pages and pages of people being completely artificial because there's no way they don't know what he means there.

[cytheflyguy]

Hey Tojam, qq before your killed and this is locked. I just want to know how you feel about RC doing...that yesterday.

[cytheflyguy]

Oh shit lol this never loaded until now xD

[cytheflyguy]

But anyway, gg guys! This was fun and I'm deffo am gonna sign up for my next one!

(Oh lol I forgot, do I sign up for another noob one or can I do something harder?)

[BTD6_maker]

As far as I know, after your first game you can do either. If you think you're ready, you can even do both.

[Rob14]

But anyway, gg guys! This was fun and I'm deffo am gonna sign up for my next one!

(Oh lol I forgot, do I sign up for another noob one or can I do something harder?)

You can sign up for whatever you want, although some moderators in other queues may have some form of experience requirements. They'll post those if they exist; assume there are no experience requirements unless told otherwise.

IIRC my first game here was a large normal. I think I played that concurrently with my first newbie.

[cytheflyguy]

Ok cool! Thanks guys~

See y'all around!

[Huntress]

Well done town! And thanks for your modding Rob.

I'll be around tomorrow if anyone has any questions, and I may have a couple of comments then too.

[tojam2]

Karnos claimed VT!

[Hoppic]

I forgot to ask. Radiantcowbells, how did you know I was cop?

[RadiantCowbells]

Trade secret.

I'll explain it when I'm ready to quit the game.

[Mina]

Goodbye.