The Dark Wanderer, skitter30, probs a robot, TesXX, northsidegal
coalition:
Raya36
: skitter30, The Dark Wanderer, northsidegal, Raya36
Gamma Emerald
: The Dark Wanderer, northsidegal, Gamma Emerald, probs a robot
probs a robot
: northsidegal, Raya36, probs a robot, The Dark Wanderer
skitter30
: skitter30, The Dark Wanderer, northsidegal, Raya36
northsidegal
: northsidegal, Raya36, probs a robot
YurikoJasmine
: YurikoJasmine, The Dark Wanderer, TesXX
DVa
: The Dark Wanderer, DVa, Gamma Emerald
TesXX
: none proposed
with 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch. day 1 ends november 28th at 23:00 central US time; in (expired on 2018-11-28 23:00:00)
seeking replacement for TesXX
skitter is VLA on fridays and saturdays
micro 833: a coalition
[/area]
Posted: Thu Nov 15, 2018 10:53 pm
by Gamma Emerald
Ok I’ve gone through 100 posts (pages 1-4) so I’m going to organize the data and write out the questions I want to ask
Expect this every 4 pages
Posted: Thu Nov 15, 2018 11:17 pm
by Gamma Emerald
btw schadd try r/sbubby for flavor images
literally just found that last night
Posted: Thu Nov 15, 2018 11:46 pm
by Gamma Emerald
Spoiler: Explanation of the system
I’m allocating 1 or 2 town or scum points, or a null/query point, to every post. Null and query points are both worth 0 either direction, but query points mark posts I find interesting enough to press further on, and posts with a query point may receive a new point value after they are addressed. I’ll likely not be asking about posts that don’t have query points, as there should be a reason I think how I do so I’m less likely to seek background or whatever.
The raw numbers will be in the next spoiler, along with the key to reading the numbers.
Spoiler: Lots of numbers
Key: Name(# of total posts): # of 2/1 townpoint posts, # of null(query)point posts, # of 2/1 scumpoint posts; final score expressed as townpoints minus scumpoints. Note null and query points are counted exclusively, so a person with 2 null points and one query point would show 2(1) in the null(query)point section.
DVa(10): 0/1, 6(2), 0/1; 0
Tes(9): 0/1, 7(0), 1/0; -1
Yuriko(7): 1/2, 6(0), 0/0; 4
skitter(12): 1/4, 3(0), 0/4; 2
robot*(12): 0/0, 9(0), 1/2; -4**
TDW(12): 2/2, 6(4), 0/0; 6
NSG(15): 0/6, 7(1), 0/1; 5
Raya(2): 0/1, 1(0), 0/0; 1
*replacements are listed as the current holder of the slot
**Because musicjax was replaced, any potential query points have been adjusted to other types of points. This may cause a discrepancy between how I feel and what the numbers say. This won’t go for anyone else hopefully.
Query points: 28: This feels a little needlessly defensive. Why take that tone in the first sentence of the post? 31: That seems like something you could put into words if you tried, so could you try? 33: Reads list doesn’t seem of note now but is definitely something to come back to later. 38: What triggered this? 82: I don’t see why you feel less confident about me being Town at this point in this post? 85: How is that being chummy? 87: Okay I went along with earlier, but why ask that at that point?
HURT: probs a robot HEAL: YurikoJasmine
Despite me feeling robot’s current contributions are alright I want to press my reads I’m forming with this over existing reads.
And now just for fun, superlatives!
DVa: Most Friendly
Tes: Most Likely to Have an Agenda
Yuriko: Most Trustworthy
Skitter: Most Hit-or-Miss
robot(actually musicjax): Most Likely to Multipost
TDW: Most Thought-Provoking
NSG: Most Frequent Poster
Raya: Mr-Not-Posting-In-This-Thread
Ok so I’m trying something based on a past re-reading method I did, where I scanned every post and formed an opinion on each one. Before I just did it for suspects because the game was farther along, but here I’m doing it for everyone.
My current thoughts as of reading page 1:
Yuriko kinda towny
TDW towny
Skitter back and forth
NSG kinda scummy
Null on all others
link to where you did this before?
Posted: Fri Nov 16, 2018 8:41 am
by Gamma Emerald
Offsite game, linking will take a little bit and I might not be able to do anything for ~7 hours
Posted: Fri Nov 16, 2018 8:46 am
by skitter30
ok when you have a chance can you talk to me about why you think doing this will help you here?
Posted: Fri Nov 16, 2018 11:40 am
by Gamma Emerald
In post 481, skitter30 wrote:ok when you have a chance can you talk to me about why you think doing this will help you here?
Posting during a bathroom break on the road
I think it will give me a very solid foundation to play the rest of the game on.
Posted: Fri Nov 16, 2018 4:23 pm
by Raya36
(Sorry about the inactivity. Things got busy. Will be here at some point tomorrow to post)
In post 481, skitter30 wrote:ok when you have a chance can you talk to me about why you think doing this will help you here?
Posting during a bathroom break on the road
I think it will give me a very solid foundation to play the rest of the game on.
ok i guess what i'm getting at is why you're treating this game differently from like every other game i've seen you play?
Because I actually want to do my best here? Btw I’ll prolly do the next four pages tonight
Posted: Sat Nov 17, 2018 3:32 pm
by skitter30
you're being kinda weird but i don't think it's scummy-weird
Posted: Sat Nov 17, 2018 3:35 pm
by Gamma Emerald
I mean this is just me invoking the level of WIM I used to have
So people who know me and have known me for a while prolly wouldn’t find this weird
Posted: Sat Nov 17, 2018 3:40 pm
by skitter30
ok you're being weird in the context of games i've played with you before; i don't think i've ever seen you approach a game this way
and the apathy is what i mislynched you for in stack-the-deck and kinda what you got mislynched for in presdients
i don't really gut-townread you here at all (which is basically how i read you in presidents and a little bit in taz), which i'm finding slightly worrying
Posted: Sat Nov 17, 2018 3:46 pm
by probs a robot
How are you reading Gamma at the moment? Given you are slightly worried?
Posted: Sat Nov 17, 2018 3:52 pm
by skitter30
i mean i'm not townreading him; i have in the past gut-townread him when he was town in 2/3 games i've played with town!him (i don't remember if i did in the third offhand). in the one scumgame i played with him (the last coalition) i liked one post and that's it from him and never really formed a read on him otherwise
i think he's acting strangely in comparison to games i've played with him
i don't know if 'going back to intensely analyzie all previous pages' is inhrently a reason to scumread him, especially in the current gamestate when not much is happening. i do feel like it's giving him a little bit of an excuse not to interact with the present, but then, since nothing is happening in the present i'm not sure if this is actually a problem
idk that's as well as i can explain how i'm reading him
i'm not explicitly scumreading him but i'm not really townreading him either
