In post 469, bugspray wrote:isn't this long enough to receive a prod and replace? seems like an easy way for noob!scum who had a close call with death's door (aka being properly read) to just hide in a bunker hoping everyone else will burn down the city, not to mention our deadline will be running this entire time
[/quote]
This is not fair from you at all.
I guess i have to apologize for having a real life.
Posted: Fri Nov 29, 2019 3:56 am
by bugspray
In post 474, Karnage wrote:actuallly, maybe the turkey would expand on all his reads?
i'd appreciate if you do this for yours as well, i get dizzy trying to read your chaotic iso
In post 469, bugspray wrote:isn't this long enough to receive a prod and replace? seems like an easy way for noob!scum who had a close call with death's door (aka being properly read) to just hide in a bunker hoping everyone else will burn down the city, not to mention our deadline will be running this entire time
This is not fair from you at all.
I guess i have to apologize for having a real life.
i have one too, and i know that shit happens
peace-ing out on us like that is unfair to town
Naerys -- Has not made a post at all. Like, at all.
GeorgeBailey -- RVS. Null note.
Arkias -- Clearly scum. The scummiest of the bunch.
bugspray -- Town, probably. Also weird.
BigFatDonald -- I think I agree with skitter here that they are town. Just new, even if they're acting weird.
Sera Masumi-- I see them as town. A lot of it comes from the whole lack of agency moment, with nothing to go on at the moment.
PvtUrist (SE) -- Null. Also watch more anime.
skitter30 (SE) -- Probably town, to be honest.
RadiantCowbells (SE) -- I feel like Radiant isn't actually doing the whole progressing thing they're known for, but at the same time, it's fairly early.
The best way to finish the RVS, from the wiki, is to start trying to gather information. Out of all the people, the person I just want more from is Naerys, but I'm against policy votes on principle. So second best applies.
VOTE: PvtUrist.
I think giving a readslist at this point in the game with this many townreads in a game like this where everyone is lurking is extremely, extremely scum indicative
and I think that his vote on bugspray was also tonally very scum indicative
In post 468, gobbledygook wrote:{Skitter, BFD, GeorgeBailey, Naerys} is my working townbloc right now.
I'm with you on skitter and naerys
where does the georgebailey townread come from?
See the spoilered quotes below. I think GeorgeBailey started the game pretty bad, but I think his most recent posts show an attempt to solve the game with original thoughts.
What do you think about the quotes in the spoiler? You seemed to agree with GeorgeBailey's logic earlier in the game when he posted about his BFD read.
Skitter - I think is attempting to solve this game similarly to how I have seen her attempt to solve games in the past. She is probably my weakest town read, but only because reading Skitter is generally pretty difficult.
BFD - I pretty much agree with GeorgeBailey's analysis about BFD. I do not think he would be trying to attract attention to himself like he did earlier in the game. He also appears to be scumhunting.
Naerys - I find the self vote to be town. Maybe I am a sucker for the drama of it all.
No, but I think I have two town reads. You and Skitter. Your entrance feels really Newb!Town. Idk if Scum playing off as Newb would really go through the effort of asking for Profile Pic, asking definitions, etc. Feels like Newb!Scum would stay quiet and ask their partner in the PT. And it seems like Skitter is trying really hard to move the discussion to a more serious one. Scum is probably enjoying the confusion/'apathy'.
Er, could you at least tell me what you were thinking at the time? If you keep calling people scum, then rescinding it, it doesn't really help. What at least made you say that?
In post 281, bugspray wrote:nae - sporadic irregular posting: only really shows up to stir the pot or respond to their own pressure.
Their answer to Teacher's Questions didn't really ring any alarms, but posts like
In post 257, Naerys wrote:As for him turning scum, i really hope he IS scum! Scum must die.
and
In post 244, Naerys wrote:And about Arkias - well, perhaps he was trying to achieve that we will think he´s just being ironic and will not consider him being scum seriously...
Your vote on Arkias seemed opportunistic. And it sounds like you're pointing and calling people scum with no reason behind it. Like in 242.
But i'm confused @Bug, why are you voting your second strongest scum read, instead of you strongest one?
Spoiler:
also, i luv the stirner nickname. Ego and It's Own is bae
In post 446, RadiantCowbells wrote:how do you keep calling me yuck and opportunistic and then I magically end up as a townread
town read is a bit strong. more like null
Judging your reads off the way you ordered them, it appears that you think RC is the third most townie person in the game behind Naerys and Skitter. It is also interesting that you list Skitter as your second strongest townread, yet in your notes you list Skitter as "a lot more townie than anyone else". Why is that?
Posted: Fri Nov 29, 2019 4:49 am
by gobbledygook
In post 482, bugspray wrote:i hope you only meant the pedit part becase i defo did regret including that after the fact n,.n
It is ok, friend. I do not think Karnage meant any ill will when he said what he said. Would you mind explaining what made you initially town read RC? You mentioned that you think your reasoning may be flawed. Do you feel comfortable revealing that reasoning at this time?
Posted: Fri Nov 29, 2019 4:56 am
by gobbledygook
I am having trouble reading Lovebird. I want her to be town so we can be bird sisters together. Lovebird, what is your read on Skitter and RC?
Posted: Fri Nov 29, 2019 4:57 am
by gobbledygook
Mod, I am traveling to a wedding today. After that, I have exams. My activity will be greatly diminished during this time. I will still be able to post sporadically. I have put up a VLA banner to reflect my time of absence from now until December 17, 2019. Thank you.
Posted: Fri Nov 29, 2019 5:02 am
by bugspray
it's one of those tinfoil hat things where i'm not even sure i'm right but i think i really should err on the side of caution and i think the best way to show my respect for the whole thing is to stop bringing more attention to it
pedit: birds are cool yeah but that feels like scum trying to develop rapport with town followed up by trying to develop more rc vs skitter paranoia
double pedit OH. MY. GOD.
Posted: Fri Nov 29, 2019 5:18 am
by skitter30
Going to try to catch up, might have to bounce before i'm done; i'm very vla this weekend
Posted: Fri Nov 29, 2019 5:19 am
by Karnage
In post 483, gobbledygook wrote:
Judging your reads off the way you ordered them, it appears that you think RC is the third most townie person in the game behind Naerys and Skitter. It is also interesting that you list Skitter as your second strongest townread, yet in your notes you list Skitter as "a lot more townie than anyone else". Why is that?
I'll take look at the GB quotes in a bit but I wanted to address this first since its not accurate.
At the time of that post I had skitter and naerys as my top townies followed by lovelybird. the = and > signs show the relative ranking of the order in which I'd lynch.
RC falls in the middle for me (the 4th slot, not the 3rd). not to stroke his ego anymore but I find RC hard to read. his positioning on my list isn't to say he's town, just that I would rather lynch from the other slots before him.
Posted: Fri Nov 29, 2019 5:21 am
by Karnage
In post 474, Karnage wrote:actuallly, maybe the turkey would expand on all his reads?
In post 474, Karnage wrote:actuallly, maybe the turkey would expand on all his reads?
how about taking care of this before you go
sorry, I missed some of the ones you did talk about when I skipped to the GB quotes
Posted: Fri Nov 29, 2019 5:31 am
by Karnage
In post 483, gobbledygook wrote:Skitter - I think is attempting to solve this game similarly to how I have seen her attempt to solve games in the past. She is probably my weakest town read, but only because reading Skitter is generally pretty difficult.
agree about skitter's play this game but it feels very much town to me
BFD - I pretty much agree with GeorgeBailey's analysis about BFD. I do not think he would be trying to attract attention to himself like he did earlier in the game.
He also appears to be scumhunting
.
you're kidding, right?
Naerys - I find the self vote to be town. Maybe I am a sucker for the drama of it all.
214 screams town to me and I agree that the self vote in that situation likely comes from town
Posted: Fri Nov 29, 2019 5:36 am
by Non lmh
morning)
Spoiler: barebones impressions from ISO and cursory read,
bs posts often, targets inactives, tunnels
reads as inexperienced,, nulltown
bg posts sparingly, lackadaisical,, null
ark/gob is defensive/deflective
feels calculating, methodical,, null
sm was proactive, quick to try and move past rvs /kar is critical all around thus far,, town
pvt/lb, passive, analytical,, townlean
nae reads as inexperienced, consistent,,town
null reads on skit and rc for now
Posted: Fri Nov 29, 2019 5:39 am
by bugspray
that readlist gives me so many questions im gonna ask them all when i can sit down and really think about it and im not just grinding runescape (which will be soon, i schedule breaks )
Hes scummy and repeatedly refused to answer followup questions when asked, which kinda makes me feel like he doesnt have answers, and that he is making up bs that he cant explain
Posted: Fri Nov 29, 2019 6:09 am
by skitter30
In post 400, RadiantCowbells wrote:, i think that your play since replacing in is devoid of anything that gives me the slightest townfeels and is filled with stuff designed to look busy
I actually kinda agree with this part
Posted: Fri Nov 29, 2019 6:12 am
by skitter30
In post 417, RadiantCowbells wrote:if you're town gobbledygook it's probably like exactly bugspray/karnage atp
)