In post 370, Churros wrote:Gobble from 0 to 10, how much you enjoy playing scum and again from 0 to 10 how much effort do you usually put in your scum games?
Don't lie because I might find out if you do.
Last town game I played with him he definitely put way less effort in and way less posts
I switch up my general activity and posting style to prevent people from being able to get activity reads on me. The game in question was running concurrently with TM2020 Whiteflag where I was scum and purposefully lurked. That then lead to real life getting in the way so I lurked disproportionately across the site.
To answer the question if I like scum... well, I am curious, Churros, how would “might be able to find out” what my preference is?
I prefer playing town. I don’t like playing scum because it takes the detective/solvey part out of the game.
On a scale 1-10, probably a 6 for enjoyment in playing scum. On a scale 1-10, probably a 10 on the effort I put into playing scum. I put 10 into effort playing as town too.
Do you think effort can be easily seen through just posts in the main thread?
Can you point out how this summary is a mischaracterization of your posting?
Reasons below. In addition to this, she's been painting my early Chronos vote as an excuse to move off my BP vote. A short glimpse of my ISO should make it clear that my vote on Chronos was sparked by (1) her interactions with STRQ at the time, and (2) her intent to lurk. I dislike lurkers and I frequently advocate for their lynch if town can't come to a consensus (note - @Gobble... I'm
sure
of this one. Lurkers came.up in MM2, CoaLITion, and I'm sure some others)
Back to Titus' most recent post. She said:
In post 449, Titus wrote:
If anyone doubts this is scum, just read these interactions.
EP: I townread Adorable.
Also EP: Claim, then I'll vote you.
Also Also EP: Mastina's regurgitated case is suddenly compelling after the hydra (now Gobble) leaves the game.
As you can see in the reads list, I townread Alimdia and Mastina. I have a townlean on the others.
While it is true that a townlean is effectively a light townread, Titus is painting it as though I suddenly dropped Adorable from the top of my list to the bottom.
Also EP: Claim, then I'll vote you.
Also Also Also EP: My mind isn't made up.
In post 408, EspressoPatronum wrote:I'm willing to swap to the Adorable wagon. I'll wait until after her claim before making it official.
In post 446, EspressoPatronum wrote:@Adorable
[...]
If your wagon continues to grow, I highly suggest you ignore Titus' advice and claim. Egix has rightfully pointed out that claiming loses some of its usefulness in a role madness game, but I'm willing to wait for your claim until I make up my mind.
408 and 446 should make it clear that my vote on Adorable depends on what her claim is. If I didn't care about Adorable's claim, I would have just voted her at 408.
Titus' post makes it out like I was going to vote Adorable regardless of her claim but then I suddenly became unsure.
EP just wants Adorable's claim
I care about Adorable's claim insofar as it relates to the size of her wagon. At the time of posting 446, I believe Adorable was at L-3, with my vote as a possible L-2. That's why advised Adorable to claim "if [her] wagon continues to grow...."
If Titus was right and I just wanted Adorable's claim, it would have been easier for me to vote her to increase the pressure.
While the VCA doesn't perfectly capture it, Egix joined the Adorable wagon to put it at L-2 (at 402). Gobble left the wagon shortly after.
Posted: Tue Mar 31, 2020 7:26 am
by gobbledygook
Egix doesn’t really remind me of that one newbie where he was scum and yeeted me D1. At least I think he was scum then.
Posted: Tue Mar 31, 2020 8:12 am
by Egix96
In post 488, gobbledygook wrote:Egix doesn’t really remind me of that one newbie where he was scum and yeeted me D1. At least I think he was scum then.
1975 you mean? I was town there though.
Posted: Tue Mar 31, 2020 8:26 am
by gobbledygook
Is that the one with Ircher scum? I get you guys confused
@EP, That's pointless unless you are suggesting that Gobble and Egix are partners.
Voting Adorable to increase the pressure does nothing if she buys me not telling her to claim and her wagon has peaked. It also diverts from you. 408 strongly indicates you're willing to vote Adorable whatever the claim. 446 is another threat towards claiming. It's dressed up but it might as well be claim or I'll vote you. Claiming is less useful in role madness so I'm going to keep my vote there.
It's plain as day. Just read the ISO and people can determine what's real and what isn't.
Posted: Tue Mar 31, 2020 11:03 am
by EspressoPatronum
In post 492, Titus wrote:@EP, That's pointless unless you are suggesting that Gobble and Egix are partners.[...]
I don't think the VCA suggests that at all. Why do you think it does?
I'm not surprised to be honest. I was actually afraid of it. I knew pushing her that hard might cause her to do that, which fucking sucks because I DO think that she's scum and because I'm pretty sure the slot's scum I need to lynch it to win. Ah well.
The replacement will probably make her alignment more apparent.
On that note--Sujimichi is much better and is at the VERY least not below the nullline right now, miiiiiight be above it but will need to think about it some more.
Posted: Tue Mar 31, 2020 12:12 pm
by Churros
In post 394, Titus wrote:That's literally impossible to not have a read on EP though. It's so baffling. To not even take a position on EP is so baffling that it's either scum faking it or town so not reading the game as to not be taken seriously at all. The nonsensical and incomprehensible waffling on Suji despite him being a townread doesn't help either.
You aren't misconveying anything as much as you legitimately say nothing and are proud of it because it's not a "gamestate" read.
I'll give this an detailed explanation to get some things out of the way.
The sole reason for this alt is to play this game casually, only doing what I feel comfortable doing. I only replaced in this game because I've a objective of always being in 2 to 3 games during the year so that I always have something to read when I feel like playing, but not too many or large for me to get overwhelmed.
That said, it's nothing personal, but I find this game somewhat distasteful at least currently. There's a lot of unnecesary walls and everyone playstyle here seems to write lenghty/wordy overanalysis that I often don't feel like reading. 10 pages of this game might as well have as many words as 20 or even 25 of some other games because of those walls, that sometimes don't go anywhere interesting by the end.
I didn't feel like reading them so I skipped a lot of posts and focused on some posts/ISOs that I felt were sticking out. As a personal philosophy I often find those analytical posts meaningless, when I play scum those are the easiest to fake.
I don't feel like going back and reading this game in particular therefore I'm mostly only reading the game after I replaced in, and even then if I sense you post is going nowhere like some discussion on mafia theory that happened in the last pages, I'm skipping it and calling it NAI.
