Newbie 2012 - Game Over

[DoctorPepper]

Spoiler alert: they aren't

Give me the town motivation for the blatant misreps of 72

[TheThirteenthJT]

Walter is low hanging fruit at this point, there is more to be gained from 72 or GL today

Also what do you mean by low hanging fruit?

[DoctorPepper]

Low hanging fruit because while his vote hopping seems scummy from the onset, I don't necessarily see it as scum driven

I'm more likely to make empty ass votes as town on a wagon. Scum would want to justify why they were there when the wagon inevitably flips town

[DoctorPepper]

I must note that in all likelihood, scum wouldn't be both on my wagon. I mean the optimal play of how I would do it is I would have talked to this in my Private Topic with my scum buddy and say one of us stays off the wagon.

But idk, this is too blatant

[TheThirteenthJT]

Spoiler alert: they aren't

Give me the town motivation for the blatant misreps of 72

Give me a good case here because I've literally said 72 is the hardest for me to read. I'm about to go to bed here soon so I will check on this tomorrow. We are coming to crunch time and I doubt GL or 72 would get lynched today unless you pull off an almost full proof case. Even so it will be helpful for Day 2 to look back at all of this.

[TheThirteenthJT]

I don't know, he was obviously paying enough attention to the thread to vote and say a few things and left again. I don't believe in the too scummy to be scum theory, especially not in newbie games. Sometimes the simplest solution could be the answer.

[DoctorPepper]

Check their votes on me:

This whole point of my why is TTJT scummy post is completely overblown. I asked it because I wasn't reading and I was wondering why you were scum read because I generally liked your posting.

It's being misconstrued as my meta by comparing it to Newbie 2000.

Plus, he threw this whole discredit on me voting Walter when I claimed my wagon was scummy when it was kinda clear I was still re reading the game at that point.

It's in bad faith. It's not scum hunting, it's purposefully painting someone as scum

[DoctorPepper]

GL: I think GL hopped off his wagons too quickly and started to vote me because I softed? Softed what?

[DoctorPepper]

I don't think Walter is playing in bad faith. Hence why I think Ydrasse is also town. I actually believe Ydrasse's attempt to scum hunt


I do what Walter does as town. As scum, I'd manufacture a reason to vote for someone or blatantly defend the scummy townie.

But I wouldn't make an empty vote to hop on a wagon.


Anyway, catch-up status is at page 10 but so far I am good lynching 72 or GL for just the past few pages. I think they haven't been given a lot of suspicion because they seem to give that aura of leading town but the intentions are honestly in bad faith. So far those are the only comfortable lynches for me

In my absolutely do not lynch pile, I'll have Ydrasse and IVD.

[DoctorPepper]

I'm more comfortable here

VOTE: 72

[WaltertheDunce10]

VOTE: unvote[
Having done a quick reread of 72 odd attempt to read, I am not sure doctor pepper is scum and quite frankly do not wish to cause a quick lynch that would not allow for information.
To the person who would like a readlist.
Yes, but I have to eat and it will be tonight or tomorrow.

[ItalianoVD]

Wow 3 whole new pages. Gimme a moment to catch up.

[ItalianoVD]

It’s a lot more I want to get to, but as of right now, I don’t like the DoctorPepper wagon and I feel DoctorPepper is telling the truth about someone. Like I said I’ll go more in depth later.

[WaltertheDunce10]

Some quick reads, am going to bed so any questions and elaboration feel free to ask away. I know there is not much explanation but I need to sleep.
probably Town
Lion
Italiano
Ydrasse
Uncertain/neutral
doctorpepper First, I thought the disengagement was scummy, but his recent posts have me put him back into the neutral category.
Mini need to see more from after initial posts.
Unowen
Possible scum
72
jt13
To me doctor pepper and jt are on two different sides where one is town vs one being scum.

[72offsuit]

It’s a lot more I want to get to, but as of right now, I don’t like the DoctorPepper wagon and I feel DoctorPepper is telling the truth about someone. Like I said I’ll go more in depth later.

There isnt much time left in the day.
If you propose lynching someone other than DP then u need to be fast.

[72offsuit]

GL 72 Ydrasse and aaltee. How much are you willing to bet DP is scum? Like how sure are you from a 1-10. I won't be intenting to hammer until DP makes it clear he has caught up. Or we are under 24 hours.

You are considering hammering DP?
Are you scumreading him right now?

[72offsuit]

I'd like to hear the why behind DP's thought processes rather than just seeing little pop-ups of "this is weird."

TBH I was generally disinterested so this game is a crap shoot. Town DP though is more unsure and less prone to tunneling because I really dislike playing as town.

Thought process in general is "is the post in question made with an intention to hunt scum or to seem active"

The things I look for in scum are if the posts just there to blend in the background or if the post has malicious intentions (i.em I hate misrepping and I dislike discrediting). I believe townies are more than likely to make bad pushes, but sometimes bad pushes are in good faith.

For my own posting? Admittedly this game I wanted people to summarize it for me because I was lazy and not motivated. Do I see that as a reason to scum read me? No. But I can see how it can easily be used to feign scum reads on me

You say your disinterested in this game and yet insist that lynching you is a mistake. Yeah sure.

[72offsuit]

you're*

[72offsuit]

And then advocate for lynching myself or GL who have actually been playing the game.

[72offsuit]

And your defensce is AtE and self meta-ing.

[DoctorPepper]

You're fucking scum

[DoctorPepper]

These are all horrible discredits and you're laziness is showing.

[DoctorPepper]

Your*

Oops

[DoctorPepper]

And then advocate for lynching myself or GL who have actually been playing the game.

I'm sorry, but since when has "playing the game" automatically equate to town?

[DoctorPepper]

And your defensce is AtE and self meta-ing.

1. Where is the AtE?
2. Why is AtE a bad thing? That's such an old "hurr durr AtE is bad mmmmKAY" mentality
3. Why are you allowed to use meta but not me?