Oil looks worse. I can see a world where Flea is misguided tunnel-visioned but admirably enthusiastic town. I struggle a bit with the disingenuous stuff, but maybe we'll come back to that later. I can't give the OMGUS excuse for Oil's tunnel. I won't pick it to pieces...but yeah, for a hydra-slot, not good at all. I feel a bit for Syryana who never had much chance.
There is something quite beautiful about pitting 2 scummy players who don't scumread each other in a head-to-head-to-head battle. Suggest it will prove instructive for reads on both of them.
Guillotina is going in my townreads too, with Noraa and Bell.
Oil looks worse. I can see a world where Flea is misguided tunnel-visioned but admirably enthusiastic town. I struggle a bit with the disingenuous stuff, but maybe we'll come back to that later. I can't give the OMGUS excuse for Oil's tunnel. I won't pick it to pieces...but yeah, for a hydra-slot, not good at all. I feel a bit for Syryana who never had much chance.
There is something quite beautiful about pitting 2 scummy players who don't scumread each other in a head-to-head-to-head battle. Suggest it will prove instructive for reads on both of them.
Guillotina is going in my townreads too, with Noraa and Bell.
Hey say the word and I'll do my thingtm on someone. I have my TODO list ready, pick a name and lets see what happens
At least it'll get my attention away from you :twitsted:
Last time superb was run up day 1 he was town. we are not going to have a repeat of that here.
-nornorsaysNONONO
this is a fallacy
He's lying when he says that I have no reads or content. Why would town lie like that?
also in a game that punishes us for posting more should he really be asking for more posts?
I didn't say you had no reads. Can you tell me what content you have? And wdym punishing us for more posts?
reads
ARE
content. My job is to find the scum and I don't need to comment on things that seem useless to me to do that. And it's not like the first 5-9 pages were super important. I'm not that kind of player that needs to be prodded for content and a guy with experience with me should know that. The only thing I could have maybe done a better job on is my gut Bell scum read.
Flea comes off to me in this interaction as sucm trying to brush off BM by taking the "high ground" if that makes sense? It's mostly tonal but also they seem to be trying to take BM's stuff and kill points/simplify whereas BM is trying to pry things open
Posted: Mon Jan 04, 2021 12:06 pm
by Guillotina
These
leans
are based partly on meta and partly on things that have happened in this game so far.
Town
Flea
: Based on Meta from a game that just ended, they are behaving exactly like their town game there. Confrontational, mocking, satirical, totally careless about what other people may say about them, just carefree, too scummy to be scum once again.
Cookies
: Purely meta read, I think she town based on her behavior in the Yellowstone game that is kind of similar to her style in this one. Would love to read more from the other head though.
Titus
: I could be wrong but it felt like he was trying to communicate with me on a deeper level when he pushed me, sort of like here I am, I'm the kind of player that don't give easy townreads early game.
Null
BattleMage
: I agree with titus that these two could be town/town specially because I played a game with Flea where I tunneled them and our feud lasted until I got eliminated and this looks exactly the same, but I've seen BattleMage playing tunneler as scum in another game too, so I'm keeping an eye on BM for now (I still remember that epic thunderdome with DoubtingThomas where you convinced me you were town).
Oil
: I haven't looked into him deep yet.
Dunnstral
: Strikes me for the kind of player that has a defined blueprint of how an alignment should act. I didn't like it that he tried to discredit me and paint me as scum for asking players why they townread me as if pocketing didn't exist.
Firebringer
: This dude is just unreadable so far. He is too weird. Will keep an eye on.
Scum
Gamma
: Based on past games, Gamma is the kind of player that is very vocal about his thoughts and reads. In essence, Gamma is like Flea minus the satirical side when he is town. When he's randed scum he tends to shy down and avoid me as much as possible. In this game he is doing that and he also added an early game townread as a bonus.
Bell
: He seemed like he was looking for a reason to buddy up/pocket kookiemonster. When I question him about it and I asked him why he townread Noraa (which he didn't, it was a trap), he didn't deny the townread and confirmed he was townreading the hydra based on a hunch, a hunch caused by something that can be easily fabricated such as exasperation "with how much they rolled scum and that they didn't roll scum here". Maybe he knows their alignment.
Superbowl
: I think I already explained it in previous posts. This SB feels like he's been trying to be appeasing to me. Maybe he learnt the lesson and he is trying a different approach but there is something that tell me he is scum.
Sugar Cain
: Nero Cain is a scum hunter by nature, I haven't seen that here. I've yet to see his scum game but I have seen his town game and so far that town!Nero is not here.
ManWithNoName slot
: He used DK videos in Xenoblade to look carefree and meme-ing. I still remember "oh hell yah, I get to use my DK vids and not get sus for using them" in our discord scum chat from that game.
are based partly on meta and partly on things that have happened in this game so far.
Town
Flea
: Based on Meta from a game that just ended, they are behaving exactly like their town game there. Confrontational, mocking, satirical, totally careless about what other people may say about them, just carefree, too scummy to be scum once again.
Cookies
: Purely meta read, I think she town based on her behavior in the Yellowstone game that is kind of similar to her style in this one. Would love to read more from the other head though.
Titus
: I could be wrong but it felt like he was trying to communicate with me on a deeper level when he pushed me, sort of like here I am, I'm the kind of player that don't give easy townreads early game.
Null
BattleMage
: I agree with titus that these two could be town/town specially because I played a game with Flea where I tunneled them and our feud lasted until I got eliminated and this looks exactly the same, but I've seen BattleMage playing tunneler as scum in another game too, so I'm keeping an eye on BM for now (I still remember that epic thunderdome with DoubtingThomas where you convinced me you were town).
Oil
: I haven't looked into him deep yet.
Dunnstral
: Strikes me for the kind of player that has a defined blueprint of how an alignment should act. I didn't like it that he tried to discredit me and paint me as scum for asking players why they townread me as if pocketing didn't exist.
Firebringer
: This dude is just unreadable so far. He is too weird. Will keep an eye on.
Scum
Gamma
: Based on past games, Gamma is the kind of player that is very vocal about his thoughts and reads. In essence, Gamma is like Flea minus the satirical side when he is town. When he's randed scum he tends to shy down and avoid me as much as possible. In this game he is doing that and he also added an early game townread as a bonus.
Bell
: He seemed like he was looking for a reason to buddy up/pocket kookiemonster. When I question him about it and I asked him why he townread Noraa (which he didn't, it was a trap), he didn't deny the townread and confirmed he was townreading the hydra based on a hunch, a hunch caused by something that can be easily fabricated such as exasperation "with how much they rolled scum and that they didn't roll scum here". Maybe he knows their alignment.
Superbowl
: I think I already explained it in previous posts. This SB feels like he's been trying to be appeasing to me. Maybe he learnt the lesson and he is trying a different approach but there is something that tell me he is scum.
Sugar Cain
: Nero Cain is a scum hunter by nature, I haven't seen that here. I've yet to see his scum game but I have seen his town game and so far that town!Nero is not here.
ManWithNoName slot
: He used DK videos in Xenoblade to look carefree and meme-ing. I still remember "oh hell yah, I get to use my DK vids and not get sus for using them" in our discord scum chat from that game.
Yeah ok I haven't even read the reasons. one look at the names and the categories and im like "EEEWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW"
are based partly on meta and partly on things that have happened in this game so far.
Town
Flea
: Based on Meta from a game that just ended, they are behaving exactly like their town game there. Confrontational, mocking, satirical, totally careless about what other people may say about them, just carefree, too scummy to be scum once again.
Cookies
: Purely meta read, I think she town based on her behavior in the Yellowstone game that is kind of similar to her style in this one. Would love to read more from the other head though.
Titus
: I could be wrong but it felt like he was trying to communicate with me on a deeper level when he pushed me, sort of like here I am, I'm the kind of player that don't give easy townreads early game.
Null
BattleMage
: I agree with titus that these two could be town/town specially because I played a game with Flea where I tunneled them and our feud lasted until I got eliminated and this looks exactly the same, but I've seen BattleMage playing tunneler as scum in another game too, so I'm keeping an eye on BM for now (I still remember that epic thunderdome with DoubtingThomas where you convinced me you were town).
Oil
: I haven't looked into him deep yet.
Dunnstral
: Strikes me for the kind of player that has a defined blueprint of how an alignment should act. I didn't like it that he tried to discredit me and paint me as scum for asking players why they townread me as if pocketing didn't exist.
Firebringer
: This dude is just unreadable so far. He is too weird. Will keep an eye on.
Scum
Gamma
: Based on past games, Gamma is the kind of player that is very vocal about his thoughts and reads. In essence, Gamma is like Flea minus the satirical side when he is town. When he's randed scum he tends to shy down and avoid me as much as possible. In this game he is doing that and he also added an early game townread as a bonus.
Bell
: He seemed like he was looking for a reason to buddy up/pocket kookiemonster. When I question him about it and I asked him why he townread Noraa (which he didn't, it was a trap), he didn't deny the townread and confirmed he was townreading the hydra based on a hunch, a hunch caused by something that can be easily fabricated such as exasperation "with how much they rolled scum and that they didn't roll scum here". Maybe he knows their alignment.
Superbowl
: I think I already explained it in previous posts. This SB feels like he's been trying to be appeasing to me. Maybe he learnt the lesson and he is trying a different approach but there is something that tell me he is scum.
Sugar Cain
: Nero Cain is a scum hunter by nature, I haven't seen that here. I've yet to see his scum game but I have seen his town game and so far that town!Nero is not here.
ManWithNoName slot
: He used DK videos in Xenoblade to look carefree and meme-ing. I still remember "oh hell yah, I get to use my DK vids and not get sus for using them" in our discord scum chat from that game.
Yeah ok I haven't even read the reasons. one look at the names and the categories and im like "EEEWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW"
Ok. Why do you think Bell is not scum? Why do you think Flea is not town?
Posted: Mon Jan 04, 2021 12:28 pm
by kookiemonster
I mean the problem is you put all of the people with really good town games in ur scum pile and that's kinda ... dumb.
-nornorbearber
Posted: Mon Jan 04, 2021 12:29 pm
by kookiemonster
I will never allow you to kill off either Superb or Momrangal on day 1. Uh I would've said the same for Nacho but nacho is being really scummy so I'm fine with him going.
-nornorbearbear
Posted: Mon Jan 04, 2021 12:33 pm
by Guillotina
In post 497, kookiemonster wrote:I mean the problem is you put all of the people with really good town games in ur scum pile and that's kinda ... dumb.
-nornorbearber
I've seen their really good town games and so far this is not it. Well, im talking about Nero, Superbowl and Gamma specifically.
