Mafiascum.net

Vote Count 1.10

Robert M Hunter

(4)

:

Angel Warriors - Gamma Emerald - T3 - ssbm_Kyouko

mastina

(1)

:

Guillotina

Dwlee99

(1)

:

House

T3

(1)

:

Lukewarm

ssbm_Kyouko

(2)

:

Robert M Hunter - mastina

Guillotina

(1)

:

Roden

Not Voting

(3)

:

Dwlee99 - Marashu - Titus

With 13 players in the game, 7 are required to Yeet unto the Eternal Void .

Deadline for voiding is in (expired on 2021-08-09 08:31:06)

Mod Notes

Marashu is V/LA.
Lukewarm is V/LA

Pronouns

T3- He/Him
Angel Warriors - They/Them
Roden - He/Him
ssbm_Kyouko - She/Her
Marashu - He/Him
Guillotina - He/Him
Lukewarm - He/Him
Robert M Hunter - He/Him
House - He/Him
mastina - She/Her
Titus - She/Her
Gamma Emerald - He/Him
Dwlee99 - They/Them

By the end of P2:
- not liking Rodan's Elim All Liars joke vote. I also superficially am not a fan of T3 being everywhere with joke claims.
P3:
Lukewarm's half-baked defense of T3 after defending him is odd. I want to watch how his reads develop.

P4: No reason to disbelieve the House claim. Nora's reaction is strange, though.

, why is it a bad thing for House to claim?

P5: I can see the scum motivation for T3 wanting to massclaim, but I also think that town T3 is more likely to suggest it, given his entrance.

P6: Momrangal is the other part of Angel Warriors, right? Talking about reactions to the claim is a good idea, I think, but I still think that the other hydra head's kneejerk reaction was kinda scummy.
I'm also so deep in House's pocket right now I can feel the lint.

P7: Dangit, now I need to figure out if ther was Angel/Rodan Scum Theatre happening here. That was a pretty decent defense, but there's a couple situations where I think Rodan's scum play comes out more aggressively, and it won't be visible D1.
Suspicion of Lukewarm grows because of 174. Both because of answering for another player (a bit more common for scum to do), and because I don't see how the SL on Angel developed.

P8: And, 174's read on Angel flips on 175. Hm.
Kyouko's 177 I read as a reaction to catching up, but after it was pointed out, yeah, it does sound like a slip.
Robert sounds like confused town.

P9:Ah, so Guillotina was memeing. I was wondering when he'd start posting.
mastina can be town

P12: Gamma's starting to feel town here.
I'm still not getting any town pings from kyouko after the defense, but where's the resistance?

P13? 14? I started reading and lost count:
Starting to see Titus engage here, which is nice.

P16: Ok, but most of the senior team of Chrono Trigger were from Enix' biggest franchise Dragon Quest, so Chrono Trigger was already a Square Enix game even though that hadn't happened. Agree about Chrono Cross, though (I don't believe the dream team worked on or even signed off on that project).
Starting to feel like Guillotina is town by this point. Roden's feeling a bit more strongly as town at this point.
Am I wrong about Lukewarm? But if not Lukewarm, who can I tunnel?

P18: I don't mind Dwlee's entrance.

P19: All posted since I started catch-up. Wow.
Robert still doesn't feel like a good elim to me. Still sounds like confused town.

VOTE: Kyouko

My super-accurate day 1 solve is currently {Kyouko, Lukewarm, Angel}. Prove me wrong.

I'm still scumreading RMH with the heat of a thousand suns, ftr.

So if RHM, then maybe Lukewarm was being whiteknighted?

But I have to ask @Robert, what about Lukewarm's posts before 209 was genuine?

In post 476, Marashu wrote: Lukewarm's half-baked defense of T3 after defending him is odd. I want to watch how his reads develop.

When did I ever defend T3 this game?

Suspicion of Lukewarm grows because of 174. Both because of answering for another player (a bit more common for scum to do), and because I don't see how the SL on Angel developed.

I don't think that I answered for someone else? Like I purposefully commented vaguely with a it "stood out to me" with no other info about why it stood out to me because I did not want to answer for roden

I also, don't think that answering for someone else is something scum are more likely to do, but ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Am I wrong about Lukewarm? But if not Lukewarm, who can I tunnel?

I am actually not sure why you are suspicious of me atm. Can you explain your read a bit more?

In post 479, Lukewarm wrote:

In post 476, Marashu wrote: Lukewarm's half-baked defense of T3 after defending him is odd. I want to watch how his reads develop.

When did I ever defend T3 this game?

In post 58, Lukewarm wrote: He has made the same fake claim 3 games in a row now (like, same role and everything), so I don't actually think that it is all that AI at this point.

Like scum T3 would 100% make the claim now that he can just point back at the other 2 games.

So, I am not saying it is scummy, but I do not think it is a reason to town read him

This. I guess half-baked isn't the right word? Non-committal is probably more accurate. You voted for him, then said that it's not scummy, but also that it's not towny. It comes off kind of weakly to me.

Suspicion of Lukewarm grows because of 174. Both because of answering for another player (a bit more common for scum to do), and because I don't see how the SL on Angel developed.

I don't think that I answered for someone else? Like I purposefully commented vaguely with a it "stood out to me" with no other info about why it stood out to me because I did not want to answer for roden

I also, don't think that answering for someone else is something scum are more likely to do, but ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

In previous games I, as scum, have been caught for that, with it pointed out as the reason for the SR. But ok, that is a fair point on Roden; I still would like your thoughts on why you were thinking of voting Angel up until that point.

Am I wrong about Lukewarm? But if not Lukewarm, who can I tunnel?

I am actually not sure why you are suspicious of me atm. Can you explain your read a bit more?

Until 392 I didn't really get anything suggesting town, and besides the posts I commented on above, 305 felt superficial.

Why did you only focus on the parts that are about you?

In post 481, T3 wrote:

I want RMH to flavorclaim for reasons I will not say now.

*If he's at e-1.

In post 446, Angel Warriors wrote:

In post 436, T3 wrote:I'm strongly inclined to trust Noraa on this.
The town: T3, House, Angel, Guillo, Roden
The scum: Lukewarm, RMH

<33333 you didnt roll malefactor again right? promise me?

Guillo is LOCKTOWN. like 100% certainty.

roden i am still processing atm.

-bearbearnor

I didn't roll malefactor ever.

In post 480, Marashu wrote:This. I guess half-baked isn't the right word? Non-committal is probably more accurate. You voted for him, then said that it's not scummy, but also that it's not towny. It comes off kind of weakly to me.

I think that you misunderstood the point I was making there. I was not trying to defend him there, and was actually trying to dismantle what appeared to be someone starting to town read him for a bad reason.

In post 55, Roden wrote:I'm pretty sure everyone should be able to read him based off of his fake claim by now.

I took this to mean that Roden thought those fake claims were more likely to come from town!T3, and I was disagreeing

In post 480, Marashu wrote:In previous games I, as scum, have been caught for that, with it pointed out as the reason for the SR. But ok, that is a fair point on Roden;

I feel like I see townies fussed at for this a lot, but I have no statistics lol

In post 480, Marashu wrote:I still would like your thoughts on why you were thinking of voting Angel up until that point.

As for Angel, it was partly to do with my meta history with Noraa. This marks the 5th game in a row together that she said that she thought I am scummy early on, and each time it keeps happening it makes it harder and harder to believe that she is not adjusting the way that she reads me, so post 71 pinged me for that reason.

Then, the way she was asking me for reads felt stilted. Specifically top of post 97. The way she was asking me repeatedly about reads when we were on page 4 of the thread, and half of the players had not even posted yet.

And then, I found this line hard to believe was a genuine thought that they were having:

In post 102, Angel Warriors wrote:quite a few slots are already towning themselves up

The moment I saw it, my gut reaction was "this is a manufactured thought," because I had read the entire thread up to that point, and I have no idea who she could have been genuinely referring to.

I did not do a hard look back at it at the time and it was more just that gut reaction, but I am compiled it all to try and show you what I mean. Look at everyone who had posted at that point, and and can you tell me who were the multiple people Angel seemed to think were "towning themselves up"?



Looking back at that more closely, I think I kinda reconvinced myself

VOTE: Angel Warriors

In post 426, Noraa wrote:Guillo is town. everyone back the fuck off. last time I saw guillo scum, I caught him on page 10 or something. trust me on this one. Guillo is town. Period. this isn't what scum him looks like. I would swear it on my life legitimately.

-bera bear bear

You hard defending me is weird as fuck because you never do.

In post 432, Roden wrote:Oh interesting, we got Dwlee now.

Dwlee99 wrote:Also we have any claims or anything yet?

Yes. You'll see it early on actually.

Noraa wrote:Guillo is town. everyone back the fuck off. last time I saw guillo scum, I caught him on page 10 or something. trust me on this one. Guillo is town. Period. this isn't what scum him looks like. I would swear it on my life legitimately.

-bera bear bear

This is a very hard defend on Guillo. I didn't expect that but since I'm town reading you and I don't think scum blatantly defends each other like this, I'll back off. Are you confident enough on this that we should basically consider him conftown?

Do you hardcore townread the Angels to consider their townreads as Confitown?

In post 442, Titus wrote:

In post 438, T3 wrote:

In post 437, Titus wrote:

In post 427, Dwlee99 wrote:Hi folks. Who are the baddies?

Angel but that's something my gut screams. I don't have hard evidence. It doesn't help I thought Noraa was in a hydra she wasn't in.

I found their hard defense of Roden and Guillo to be strongly ++++++++++town.

Why? I find it whiteknighty myself.

Yah this thought crossed my mind too. Noraa never ever hard defends me like that. Noraa always tunnels me, she always reads me wrong, I don't believe they got better at reading me in a couple of months.

In post 444, Angel Warriors wrote:

In post 426, Noraa wrote:Guillo is town. everyone back the fuck off. last time I saw guillo scum, I caught him on page 10 or something. trust me on this one. Guillo is town. Period. this isn't what scum him looks like. I would swear it on my life legitimately.

-bera bear bear

I stand firmly by this statement btw. guillo is town here and if anyone tries to touch them, they are getting the Noraa paw of doom.

-norbearbearbear

Ok, explain. Because if you flip scum, I'll look bad from this.

VOTE: Angel Warriors

In post 454, Angel Warriors wrote:

In post 404, Guillotina wrote:

In post 401, House wrote:

In post 395, Guillotina wrote:It's ridiculous to think ssmb and I are teamed

I have no clue why people even try that silly line, considering scum are huge fans of things like, "distancing" & "bussing".

Then ssbm and i should get oscars then because it this is theater, we are the best goddamn actors.

You know full damn well that scum you would pull this type of shit rofl

But, you're still town. Wheres your head at?

You are making me paranoid. I feel like you either are pocketing me or developed a God read on me in a few months, which I don't think it's possible, I've been told I'm very hard to read.

Noraa hard townreading people is... weird.

In post 418, Roden wrote:I don't think the interaction between you and Guillotina is genuine, but idk if it's both of you or just one of you. It's not guaranteed either of you are scum either even if I'm right, since I believe third party is a possibility.

What seems fake about it?

@Roden, Skip Noraa's ISO in Pooky v Flavor Leaf and get back to me.

In post 468, Dwlee99 wrote:If we get a claim I wouldn't mind hammering it even though there is time left. People can catch up at night : shrug:

Are you caught up?

I think I'm missing something that both Angel and House saw in Dwlee.

In post 494, ssbm_Kyouko wrote:

In post 468, Dwlee99 wrote:If we get a claim I wouldn't mind hammering it even though there is time left. People can catch up at night : shrug:

Are you caught up?

No and I haven't read anything.

In post 493, Titus wrote:@Roden, Skip Noraa's ISO in Pooky v Flavor Leaf and get back to me.

Emphasis on skimming but, yeah I see what you mean now. This is not the Nora I recognize. Granted I only played one game with her before so I didn't feel confident trying to meta her, and I don't think it's fair to scum read someone when they're trying to improve their town game, but this looks incredibly condemning. Gonna read more before I come to a decision but even the scum PT seems revealing.

In post 46, Spiffeh wrote:Noraa should try to spam it up in an obv town way anyway and then everyone'll think she's town!

This was an oof but also an eye opener.

In post 492, ssbm_Kyouko wrote:

In post 418, Roden wrote:I don't think the interaction between you and Guillotina is genuine, but idk if it's both of you or just one of you. It's not guaranteed either of you are scum either even if I'm right, since I believe third party is a possibility.

What seems fake about it?

Guillo seemed ready to death tunnel you, and I wasn't vibing with your response. But I think it makes more sense that he was just super sensitive to getting scum read for the wrong reasons, not necessarily because he's actually scum but because he didn't think your reasoning was good. He claimed to be certain you were scum but backed down when questioned more on it, which made me think it was an emotional/pride thing. Basically I do think it's possible to be a fake response but for you both to be town anyway.

In post 487, Guillotina wrote:

In post 432, Roden wrote:Oh interesting, we got Dwlee now.

Dwlee99 wrote:Also we have any claims or anything yet?

Yes. You'll see it early on actually.

Noraa wrote:Guillo is town. everyone back the fuck off. last time I saw guillo scum, I caught him on page 10 or something. trust me on this one. Guillo is town. Period. this isn't what scum him looks like. I would swear it on my life legitimately.

-bera bear bear

This is a very hard defend on Guillo. I didn't expect that but since I'm town reading you and I don't think scum blatantly defends each other like this, I'll back off. Are you confident enough on this that we should basically consider him conftown?

Do you hardcore townread the Angels to consider their townreads as Confitown?

No, I wanted to see how confident they were in the read. They never answered though, which isn't a good look tbh.

In post 456, Roden wrote:If multiple people are confident on Luke being town then I think his read on T3 has merit.

What is the purpose of this post? As far as I can tell it's unrelated to any conversation thread and the last time Luke mentioned a T3 scum read was kind of far back.

I cant figure out what you're thinking here. For as much interaction as you have with quite a few people, and for as much as it looks like you're possibly trying to find scum, I was surprised to see you haven't interacted with or commented on RMH, except once in 439, where you softly defend his slot for a really bad reason. It doesn't occur to you that RMH is scum waiting out the pressure and laying low? It occurs to me that this is what's happening and it's your job to redirect the heat.

Why shouldn't he be a wagon?

The only thing 456 correlates to is derailing the RMH wagon imo