Mini 2230: Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night: Game Over

[Snarky Fishes]

woo

[ManateeGal]

64 I dont get why asking for another player's scumreads is scummy

It's the "there's no case" thing

i feel like you are purposely misunderstanding my posts even now

[Snarky Fishes]

Why do you think they're trying to misunderstand your posts when you're just going to end up correcting them to whatever version you want anyway?

-bell.

[ManateeGal]

???????? thats like asking why someone would state a scumread when someone can debunk it

[Snarky Fishes]

it's true, why bother accusing people when if they're any good they'll deny it in a way that's hard to refute.

Also, hi.

-Bell.

[Annie Edison]

Hey bell I got you and ffery a present

[Snarky Fishes]

I like presents

[Annie Edison]

Spoiler: Big pretty readslist on page 20

Town

Dunn

- Dunn's been proactively solving and piecing things together, plus the earlier bits about scum Dunn not taking a "naivete over the setup" angle.

fferyBell

- both have hit tonal markers for me. In particular, ffery's push back on Cabd about pocketing (I believe ceph used the term feisty?) was a big one, and Bell's 458 is the snark we know and love.

Sleez

- I liked the early interaction with manatee that I've already weighed in on. I like the analysis on Lukewarm in 421 and 427. When I've been working on this, that actually helped make it make a bit more sense than I originally expected.

Leantown

Pooky

- He reminds me of Tarot pooky, particularly day 1. I can kinda see what Bell said about being a bit performative, but I'm not super concerned about it at this point. This is subject to move after I chat with bulge.

CephTD

- I liked his weigh in around ffery that I mentioned higher up on the readslist. I also liked 200 and the paranoia around LLD in 222. Also I'd wager the focus around the shard mechanic is >rand town as thats the kinda random shit town chases. I do want to see more solving out of them at some point though.

LLD

- I liked her response to ffery over the shards, I liked her callout of Titus's weird mindmeld post in 417, and I liked the vote on Medea.

Just north of null

manatee

- I just get this distinct newbtown out of their depth feeling whenever I read a manatee post. I do see Dunn's point about 90 and ffery's about 209, so that's why they are closer to null. Need more info there, I suppose its not totally out of the realm of suspicion about newbie scum not knowing how to get a foothold in this game? Particularly if they got a heads up that we townbloc.

Null

spiffy

- awful voting record. burn with fire

Lukewarm

- I had him as town originally. I originally liked 339 but don't like it again upon review. I have this really weird tinfoil that could be a bus vote and panicked a bit at the thought of my hammer? Sleez's comments kinda made some sense. I didn't like the awkwardness around Morph's reads. I don't know his full history, and maybe im just used to it by now but it just feels like artificial busywork looking back. And yeah I commented on it being tricky to understand them and like, I get it, but multiple people said to leave it.

Titus

- Titus's comments about me not sharing reads was weird given I was like the first to actually do it. Will probably be easier to read over time.

Scum

Medea

- I'm on the fence. Cabd's intro felt off as most of us have already said, particularly the "I have reads but PA said I cant." Like normally there's this race to see who can gather the most townreads early and it just wasnt really there from him? 245 felt weird to me before ffery confirmed they hadn't played together post-2181. LLD read feels a bit weird, and it's weird he hasn't really elaborated on any of the other townreads he supposedly had by this point. (And no, he cant claim ffery's one becasue of 245). PA's felt alright but doesnt outweigh my misgivings about Cabd, I liked 270 a bit but could also see it as a distance. 369 feels weird to see in a post, instead of like a private comment. This one is also subject to move after I talk with Bulge.

AA9

- I've talked about her in my ISO already. But the short version is her line of questioning of me feels weird given everything about her line of questioning was something I've discussed both before and after the line of questioning.

This post was brought to you by the letter "W", for WEIRD.

VOTE: AA9

For now. Might move over to Medea.

Earlier editions had Lukewarm in the Leantown tier.

[ManateeGal]

it's true, why bother accusing people when if they're any good they'll deny it in a way that's hard to refute.

Also, hi.

-Bell.

glad we're on the same page!! hiiiii :D

[Annie Edison]

for the record thats entirely me bulge said hed probably be around tomorrow(tm)

[Dunnstral]

People are being scummy already but I only have one vote.

interesting

What's interesting about it?

your phrasing

Not the fact people are being scummy?

no...? considering theres been like 3 pages and you havent outlined who youre talking about

So 64 isn't explicitly asking for reads which is your argument, but it's certainly leading the conversation towards that

If not, then your posts really have no weight behind them here

[Titus]

@Annie, What would you like me to focus on during my read through?

Also, I suck day 1 and I'd rather be lim bait so I'm not going to be forceful.

[ManateeGal]

-snip-

Just north of null

manatee

- I just get this distinct newbtown out of their depth feeling whenever I read a manatee post. I do see Dunn's point about 90 and ffery's about 209, so that's why they are closer to null. Need more info there, I suppose its not totally out of the realm of suspicion about newbie scum not knowing how to get a foothold in this game? Particularly if they got a heads up that we townbloc.

oh my goodness do i get to go back to being a clueless little noob girl? thats so exciting!!!!

[Annie Edison]

i mean like I know about you and know youve done stuff thats just the vibe ive gotten from your posts

[Annie Edison]

@titus- I'd like your thoughts on what's going on outside of the medea wagon- why theres no other counter push. Its weird its all vanity votes and I understand im a hypocrite but still

[Dunnstral]

PA's felt alright but doesnt outweigh my misgivings about Cabd, I liked 270 a bit but could also see it as a distance. 369 feels weird to see in a post, instead of like a private comment. This one is also subject to move after I talk with Bulge.

287

369 feels weird to see in a post, instead of like a private comment. This one is also subject to move after I talk with Bulge.

You're right

[ManateeGal]

People are being scummy already but I only have one vote.

interesting

What's interesting about it?

your phrasing

Not the fact people are being scummy?

no...? considering theres been like 3 pages and you havent outlined who youre talking about

So 64 isn't explicitly asking for reads which is your argument, but it's certainly leading the conversation towards that
If not, then your posts really have no weight behind them here

i mean i was just responding to conversation happening at the time? idky there would be expectation of depth atp

[Dunnstral]

AA9

- I've talked about her in my ISO already. But the short version is her line of questioning of me feels weird given everything about her line of questioning was something I've discussed both before and after the line of questioning.

This is not very convincing

[Annie Edison]

If anything it’s a placeholder while I wait for bulge

It boils down to her faking scumhunting. It’s a lack of awareness of what’s going on in the game that’s strange for anyone trying to parse and digest what’s going on.

[ManateeGal]

i mean like I know about you and know youve done stuff thats just the vibe ive gotten from your posts

hmmmm its just interesting cos i've gotten in shit recently for underplaying myself

[Sleez]

Manatee has been absolved in my mind.

[ManateeGal]

VOTE: Lukewarm

i dont wanna be voting pooky anymore

[ManateeGal]

Manatee has been absolved in my mind.

thats good to know

[Dunnstral]

What made you vote for Luke?

[Snarky Fishes]

Spoiler: Big pretty readslist on page 20

Town

Dunn

- Dunn's been proactively solving and piecing things together, plus the earlier bits about scum Dunn not taking a "naivete over the setup" angle.

fferyBell

- both have hit tonal markers for me. In particular, ffery's push back on Cabd about pocketing (I believe ceph used the term feisty?) was a big one, and Bell's 458 is the snark we know and love.

Sleez

- I liked the early interaction with manatee that I've already weighed in on. I like the analysis on Lukewarm in 421 and 427. When I've been working on this, that actually helped make it make a bit more sense than I originally expected.

Leantown

Pooky

- He reminds me of Tarot pooky, particularly day 1. I can kinda see what Bell said about being a bit performative, but I'm not super concerned about it at this point. This is subject to move after I chat with bulge.

CephTD

- I liked his weigh in around ffery that I mentioned higher up on the readslist. I also liked 200 and the paranoia around LLD in 222. Also I'd wager the focus around the shard mechanic is >rand town as thats the kinda random shit town chases. I do want to see more solving out of them at some point though.

LLD

- I liked her response to ffery over the shards, I liked her callout of Titus's weird mindmeld post in 417, and I liked the vote on Medea.

Just north of null

manatee

- I just get this distinct newbtown out of their depth feeling whenever I read a manatee post. I do see Dunn's point about 90 and ffery's about 209, so that's why they are closer to null. Need more info there, I suppose its not totally out of the realm of suspicion about newbie scum not knowing how to get a foothold in this game? Particularly if they got a heads up that we townbloc.

Null

spiffy

- awful voting record. burn with fire

Lukewarm

- I had him as town originally. I originally liked 339 but don't like it again upon review. I have this really weird tinfoil that could be a bus vote and panicked a bit at the thought of my hammer? Sleez's comments kinda made some sense. I didn't like the awkwardness around Morph's reads. I don't know his full history, and maybe im just used to it by now but it just feels like artificial busywork looking back. And yeah I commented on it being tricky to understand them and like, I get it, but multiple people said to leave it.

Titus

- Titus's comments about me not sharing reads was weird given I was like the first to actually do it. Will probably be easier to read over time.

Scum

Medea

- I'm on the fence. Cabd's intro felt off as most of us have already said, particularly the "I have reads but PA said I cant." Like normally there's this race to see who can gather the most townreads early and it just wasnt really there from him? 245 felt weird to me before ffery confirmed they hadn't played together post-2181. LLD read feels a bit weird, and it's weird he hasn't really elaborated on any of the other townreads he supposedly had by this point. (And no, he cant claim ffery's one becasue of 245). PA's felt alright but doesnt outweigh my misgivings about Cabd, I liked 270 a bit but could also see it as a distance. 369 feels weird to see in a post, instead of like a private comment. This one is also subject to move after I talk with Bulge.

AA9

- I've talked about her in my ISO already. But the short version is her line of questioning of me feels weird given everything about her line of questioning was something I've discussed both before and after the line of questioning.

This post was brought to you by the letter "W", for WEIRD.

VOTE: AA9

For now. Might move over to Medea.

Earlier editions had Lukewarm in the Leantown tier.

The performative comment about pooky is a fferyppost.

A manatee scum iso

I'm thinking about her reaction to my/Cabd's push in that game compared to her reaction to sleez's push here. her reaction to Dunn feels too muted to really make sense of atm.

Luke has played a couple games with town-me, a game with town-Cabd, and a game with town-morph (the same one Manatee played). I don't think he's the sort of player who takes others' opinions under advisement until/unless he's established a read/some trust there.

You say you're on the fence about Medea but you have them as a scumread you might move over to. This doesn't feel all that on-the-fence to me.