Says the player voteparked on a vanity wagon that no one but you is currently interested in flipping. I still don’t see the so-called “tmi” that Titus was alluding to. I just thought having us, furtive and Enchant as possible Ircher buddies seemed kind’ve whack because neither are anywhere near my PoE.
I will take another look at Scerrredbear and confer with Auro but I’m still not trusting Titus. She just sounds too certain about things and she usually doesn’t d1 without flips. @furtive, you remember how she seemed to not be extremely certain on pretty much anything in Chromavalon d1?
Says the player voteparked on a vanity wagon that no one but you is currently interested in flipping. I still don’t see the so-called “tmi” that Titus was alluding to. I just thought having us, furtive and Enchant as possible Ircher buddies seemed kind’ve whack because neither are anywhere near my PoE.
I will take another look at Scerrredbear and confer with Auro but I’m still not trusting Titus. She just sounds too certain about things and she usually doesn’t d1 without flips. @furtive, you remember how she seemed to not be extremely certain on pretty much anything in Chromavalon d1?
~Nancy
I look back and see a more considered Titus, but I wouldn't characterise her as unsure. As for the change in tone, Chromavalon is a kind of setup where you want to be more considered as town. Also, they seem angry in this game for some reason. I don't really like it. But I don't know why someone would blow up early game as mafia, in a 2 mafia game.
My follow up was here. Basically I'm not sure on Titus. They aren't really towny, but not the most sus either.
As for townreads, I'd go for Don Draper x Mistress and Scrrdbear, maybe you. Enchant is doing a bit more nothing than before. Which can be sus.
Posted: Mon Oct 10, 2022 6:48 am
by Porkens
Yeah, when I run my brain over sccrdbr something sticks up. It’s a—-reaching? Maybe that’s the right word. Feels like they are reaching out to see what vote will stick. Not sure that’s scum driven though
In post 459, Ircher wrote:It doesn't even have to be earth-shattering. You really couldn't find a single thing that stood out to you? A single oddity?
I think I’m taking Ircher completely off the table.
@Titus, why is Porkens town?
Because the wagon is shit and I like their content.
I'd compromise on Bear.
Posted: Mon Oct 10, 2022 8:35 am
by Titus
I'm getting real apathetic. Can't get a good wagon going. Wouldn't mind being flipped to get good wagons but I'd rather not.
Posted: Mon Oct 10, 2022 10:11 am
by Aisa
Prodding Vanderscamp.
Posted: Mon Oct 10, 2022 10:28 am
by Aisa
Posted: Mon Oct 10, 2022 12:01 pm
by Vanderscamp
One day to go?
We should kill someone soon, I don't particularly think it should be Titus
Posted: Mon Oct 10, 2022 12:03 pm
by Vanderscamp
In post 441, Don Draper x Mistress wrote:Well I really can’t tell rn if Porkens is scum or checked out town. In my experience, they are usually more obvious as scum but I haven’t played with them in quite awhile. I would expect scum in this game to be trying a bit harder because there’s only two of them.
It concerns me that Porkens isn’t really too worried about the possibility of being run up. Auro hasn’t expressed any concern about them.
It’s obviously not good that they aren’t giving reads but my theory is if Porkens is actually scum their buddy would most likely be bussing them but I think with only two scum, it’s hard to believe that scum would bus on d1 unless they absolutely had too.
I still want that readslist from them but I still am the most suspicious of Titus.
In post 461, Porkens wrote:Actually that’s wrong. I wouldn’t be happy to eliminate anyone. I have preferences of who I’d like to eliminate but they aren’t based on town/scum reads.
Like: Don Draper x Mistress (hydra of Nancy Drew 39 and Auro)
Love: Porkens
Wary: furtiveglance
Impatient: Herta
Enchanted: Vanderscamp
Wary: Ircher
Like: Titus
Wary: Enchant
Tempted: SCRRRDBEAR
I don't really get this, but it shows I guess genuine thoughtfulness rather than the manipulation vibes I'm getting from Titus.
In post 461, Porkens wrote:Actually that’s wrong. I wouldn’t be happy to eliminate anyone. I have preferences of who I’d like to eliminate but they aren’t based on town/scum reads.
Like: Don Draper x Mistress (hydra of Nancy Drew 39 and Auro)
Love: Porkens
Wary: furtiveglance
Impatient: Herta
Enchanted: Vanderscamp
Wary: Ircher
Like: Titus
Wary: Enchant
Tempted: SCRRRDBEAR
This is part of it. The timing of these posts show Porkens is thinking about the game. Could be scum, but I think it's enough for Day 1.
VOTE: Herta
This is absurd
The TMI reads continue
Posted: Mon Oct 10, 2022 12:11 pm
by Vanderscamp
I don't think Titus is super town or anything but at least he's actively engaging in conflict in a game where relatively very few people are doing so.
I think scum are people like Ircher/Herta/Porkens who are just sitting back and chilling and letting Don/Titus waste time with a tunnel on each other.
I think Herta has given multiple really suspect reads and I would love to kill that slot today.
In post 461, Porkens wrote:Actually that’s wrong. I wouldn’t be happy to eliminate anyone. I have preferences of who I’d like to eliminate but they aren’t based on town/scum reads.
Like: Don Draper x Mistress (hydra of Nancy Drew 39 and Auro)
Love: Porkens
Wary: furtiveglance
Impatient: Herta
Enchanted: Vanderscamp
Wary: Ircher
Like: Titus
Wary: Enchant
Tempted: SCRRRDBEAR
This is part of it. The timing of these posts show Porkens is thinking about the game. Could be scum, but I think it's enough for Day 1.
VOTE: Herta
This is absurd
The TMI reads continue
Explain the tmi here.
Posted: Mon Oct 10, 2022 12:39 pm
by Herta
In post 486, Vanderscamp wrote:I don't think Titus is super town or anything but at least he's actively engaging in conflict in a game where relatively very few people are doing so.
I think scum are people like Ircher/Herta/Porkens who are just sitting back and chilling and letting Don/Titus waste time with a tunnel on each other.
I think Herta has given multiple really suspect reads and I would love to kill that slot today.
Suspect reads as in what you think are wrong reads or suspect reads as in fake reads. If they're wrong reads, so? and if they're fake reads, explain what clues you in to them being fake.
Posted: Mon Oct 10, 2022 12:43 pm
by Herta
What happened to your enchant scum read, Vanderscamp?
Posted: Mon Oct 10, 2022 12:44 pm
by Herta
In post 476, furtiveglance wrote:As for townreads, I'd go for Don Draper x Mistress and Scrrdbear, maybe you. Enchant is doing a bit more nothing than before. Which can be sus.
In post 461, Porkens wrote:Actually that’s wrong. I wouldn’t be happy to eliminate anyone. I have preferences of who I’d like to eliminate but they aren’t based on town/scum reads.
Like: Don Draper x Mistress (hydra of Nancy Drew 39 and Auro)
Love: Porkens
Wary: furtiveglance
Impatient: Herta
Enchanted: Vanderscamp
Wary: Ircher
Like: Titus
Wary: Enchant
Tempted: SCRRRDBEAR
This is part of it. The timing of these posts show Porkens is thinking about the game. Could be scum, but I think it's enough for Day 1.
VOTE: Herta
This is absurd
The TMI reads continue
Explain the tmi here.
There's nothing at all in porkens' post that shows he's thinking about the game.
In post 486, Vanderscamp wrote:I don't think Titus is super town or anything but at least he's actively engaging in conflict in a game where relatively very few people are doing so.
I think scum are people like Ircher/Herta/Porkens who are just sitting back and chilling and letting Don/Titus waste time with a tunnel on each other.
I think Herta has given multiple really suspect reads and I would love to kill that slot today.
Suspect reads as in what you think are wrong reads or suspect reads as in fake reads. If they're wrong reads, so? and if they're fake reads, explain what clues you in to them being fake.
I've talked about this earlier, your post where you say that someone only has three specific scum partners and you townread all three of them, therefore that person is towny, is just way too confident a read that anyone could be making at this point in the game. You have to be confident in so many different things for that read to apply, and it's not like you've been confident enough to be able to push hard against anyone in particular.
I think you're giving out fake good reads.
Posted: Mon Oct 10, 2022 12:55 pm
by Vanderscamp
In post 489, Herta wrote:What happened to your enchant scum read, Vanderscamp?
I don't remember having much of a read on enchant, it's possible I included them in a list somewhere but ultimately I don't remember much of what they've said.
Posted: Mon Oct 10, 2022 1:06 pm
by Porkens
Excuse you that’s insulting
Posted: Mon Oct 10, 2022 2:32 pm
by Enchant
VOTE: Herta
JOIN
Posted: Mon Oct 10, 2022 2:41 pm
by Don Draper x Mistress
UNVOTE:
I will reread later. Please don’t hammer anything before I get back, thanks.
In post 461, Porkens wrote:Actually that’s wrong. I wouldn’t be happy to eliminate anyone. I have preferences of who I’d like to eliminate but they aren’t based on town/scum reads.
Like: Don Draper x Mistress (hydra of Nancy Drew 39 and Auro)
Love: Porkens
Wary: furtiveglance
Impatient: Herta
Enchanted: Vanderscamp
Wary: Ircher
Like: Titus
Wary: Enchant
Tempted: SCRRRDBEAR
I don't really get this, but it shows I guess genuine thoughtfulness rather than the manipulation vibes I'm getting from Titus.