Mafiascum.net

Also claiming tracker into 5 unclaimed people as scum with no ninja counters claimed yet is suicide if you aren't a tracker imo

Sorry no roles claimed ninja can counter

bubba wrote:Then what's the chance of 4-5 one of them claims tracker

it was actually 8 people (half the living population at the time) that hadn't claimed - you, pie and varsoon claimed D1, AD, gcbc and kat claimed D2 - everyone else was unclaimed

bubba wrote:Is it difficult to grasp that helllo they still thought that someone else was scum?

that's not how anyone with half a brain plays cop if they have a guilty - that's not how mollie plays cop when she has a guilty - there are so many things wrong with this - and no, wanting to remain hidden isn't an excuse (they were odd night, chances they made it through to D4 were slim anyway with how many people were calling them obvtown, they'd have outed it if they had a guilty or at the very least they wouldn't have been fine with voting AD)

I concede my muffin point. Re-reading enough times and thinking about it, muffin has a point. If he's scum tracker with no town track/watch role and with the flipped ninja then uh.... I get to write the loss off to "lol setup" and move on.

In post 4740, ActionDan wrote:And how would muffin know he wouldn't be cced?

Mod-Provided-Safe-Claim.

Also, you are dismissing all possibilities due to : Role-Spec. I completely disagree that there was a zero percent chance Lush was trying to get across a guilty result.

Let me ask you this - Is it against the rules for a mod to put in a ninja with no utility?

~GC

No but if you look at all the town power I wouldn't be thinking "let's troll the scumteam with a useless role that exists solely for the utility of claim candy for the tracker in case he gets lynched first"

A man would like to know, irt a boy's set up spec, what happened to the other scum strongarm that would explain a boy's role as town?

In post 4634, GoodCop_BadCop wrote:I imagine the scum counter-role to the SK is a roleblocker.

So we're looking at:

Scum Ninja (flipped)
Scum Encyptor-Strongman (flipped)
Scum Roleblocker (probably, could be scum protective instead)
Scum Rolecop/Investigative (probably)

Vs

SK (inv immune or BP)

Vs

Town BP (me)
Inno child (wayne)
Mason rolecop (flipped)
Mason encryptor (confirmed town, pie)
2-shot rolecop (flipped)
odd-night cop (flipped)
Macho Rolestopper (flipped)
Role copy (flipped)
Vanila Towns (some flipped)
Inventor (Now SSK's slot)
Doctor (pseudo confirmed by town macho flipping, notsci)

This set up spec, to be sure.

In post 4747, ActionDan wrote:Please don't tempt me to hammer. Let's lynch the guy that's more certainly scum

do you think it's better to lynch mafia or SK here?

In post 4758, pieguyn wrote:

In post 4747, ActionDan wrote:Please don't tempt me to hammer. Let's lynch the guy that's more certainly scum

do you think it's better to lynch mafia or SK here?

I'm not dan, but SK clearly isn't shooting for scum, so cross-kill %age is super low. Therefore removing a night kill from the game is superior.

In post 4758, pieguyn wrote:

In post 4747, ActionDan wrote:Please don't tempt me to hammer. Let's lynch the guy that's more certainly scum

do you think it's better to lynch mafia or SK here?

Sk

do you think GCBC is the SK? or at least has a better chance than bubba?

this is why I hate naything that's not pure mafia vs. town btw. every single goddamn multiball or SK setup I play it seems there's absolutely no fucking crosskills at all =.=

at least when I was SK I got one mafia
/runs

A man is sure you'd have gotten more if weren't scum which was leas hung you. A man could see either set up wrt who is the SK.

*leashing

wait so you don't actually have a SK result on bubba?

interestingly GIF picked utsuho reiuji in touhou upick (oh god why am I bringing this game up). so it almost makes sense if she'd be a SK? LOL

In post 4763, Jaqen Hghar wrote:A man is sure you'd have gotten more if weren't scum which was leas hung you. A man could see either set up wrt who is the SK.

btw I couldn't shoot all the scum too soon. after I claimed I was entirely fucked. the only chance I had was to leave enough scum alive to prevent town from being able to lynch me

and my reads were off until right before I died and then they weren't actually that bad but by then it was too late ._.

@AD: Defend your buddy more plox.

@Muffin: respond to GCBC

I think the plan of lynching Bubba then lynching Muffin is nice.


If neither of them flip the way they're expected to, we can finally start suspecting.

Is town bubba an idiot? Does anyone know?

Well he from EM

the problem with this is there was some point where I just stopped believing zmuffin is scum

and I don't wanna lynch him if he's town bc I'd like to keep my "can read zmuffin" card even though it kind of got bent out of shape already considering I didn't catch him till after I died in marketplace

on the other hand I could see GCBC + Saki especially with that last vote

@Saki: why zmuffin

I'm reading
and GCBC isn't happening
so zmuffin