Mafiascum.net

She wouldn’t have killed pooky? And also I think she’s right when she says that while she prob would have TR me, I don’t think there was a lot of incentive for her to put that much effort into saving me yesterday as scum instead of just letting me be limmed and being on the right side of it

Like think about it

If I die yesterday while calling (norwee, fark, day) scum, then skitter is perfectly positioned to push them on following days

If I live then we end up in this confused state where there’s 2 “blocs” kinda, and it’s unclear, and skitter herself is a target

Given that she’s particularly good at predicting future days’ conflicts in advance, why does she knowingly choose world 2 there?

It’s like you have to choose that skitter has been playing suboptimally all game in multiple ways to think she’s scum, for very little compensation

That’s not a theory that makes sense

The attempts to wagon her haven’t been easier? I’m the only one voting her, same as yesterday

+ Skitter looks bad if she NK’s me. Pooky wonders why tf he is alive and reassesses. He might have even had some important info to solve the game for all scum knew

Menalque did you read my case on Skitter?

The moment I call you obvtown she suddenly wants to compromise lim you. She wk’d you originally as she knew you’d likely be limmed either D1 or down the line

Pooky was comvinced Farkran was scum. If Pooky had a cop check or gunsmith or something on Farkran and decided on Farkran town. Maybe they would even conclude their townread on Skitter was mistaken. Scum!Skitter would absolutely not be any less likely to kill Pooky and that is really starting to become an tired argument.

No, pooky doesnt. Luca i'll get to the other things you've said/wrote after work

Pedit i honestly dont remember you saying that and it wasnf a factor in how i was approaching mena

If anything its silly as scum to propose a compromise lim on somebody that fhe most townread slot in the game just announced they were townreading

Pedit2 i wouldnt have killed him laat night. I'm not telling you to townread me off of it, i'm merely stating a fact

Whether or not you guys would have made the kill doesn't change how likely it would have been for *me* to make it

And again i'm not telling you to townrwad me off of it, i'm pointing out that if i were scum who wanted to push fark today killing pooky would have, to some extent, negated my ability to do so

It’s not a fact

If you kill me do you really think that would reflect well on you? Come on

In post 4754, NorwegianboyEE wrote:Scum!Skitter would absolutely not be any less likely to kill Pooky and that is really starting to become an tired argument.

Yes, i would have

Farkran is on four votes already, yeah it’s really negated your ability to push him lol

In post 4757, Luca Blight wrote:It’s not a fact

If you kill me do you really think that would reflect well on you? Come on

Not bad enuf that i coulsnt talk my way out of it, i'm sure. Or i would have killed day, if i were going for pr's it would have been day over pooky 3000% of the time

In post 4759, Luca Blight wrote:Farkran is on four votes already, yeah it’s really negated your ability to push him lol

And it could have been five and he would have done most of the heavy lifting sooooooo

Talk about trying to avoid getting my hands dirty

I’ve shown a game where Skitter killed me N1, despite me locktowning her, because I claimed a pr

Skitter can you provide an example of where you kept alive a pr early in the game because they TR you?

In post 4761, skitter30 wrote:

In post 4759, Luca Blight wrote:Farkran is on four votes already, yeah it’s really negated your ability to push him lol

And it could have been five and he would have done most of the heavy lifting sooooooo

Talk about trying to avoid getting my hands dirty

Yeah cos Pooky wouldn’t have reassessed at all after inexplicably being kept alive and me being dead instead

Yes i'm sure i can but you'll have to hold off till later today when i have time to look

@skitt who do u think you’d have killed

In post 4763, Luca Blight wrote:

In post 4761, skitter30 wrote:

In post 4759, Luca Blight wrote:Farkran is on four votes already, yeah it’s really negated your ability to push him lol

And it could have been five and he would have done most of the heavy lifting sooooooo

Talk about trying to avoid getting my hands dirty

Yeah cos Pooky wouldn’t have reassessed at all after inexplicably being kept alive and me being dead instead

I'm p confident he woulsnt have - nothint would have changed overnight to change his worldview

In post 4765, Menalque wrote:@skitt who do u think you’d have killed

Luca or day

This is just a really dumb order to do things in Luca

Let’s just flip fark and if he’s town then we can talk more about skitter

But if we go skitter!town -> fark!scum that’s just like... so dumb

In post 4767, skitter30 wrote:

In post 4765, Menalque wrote:@skitt who do u think you’d have killed

Luca or day

y

In post 4760, skitter30 wrote:

In post 4757, Luca Blight wrote:It’s not a fact

If you kill me do you really think that would reflect well on you? Come on

Not bad enuf that i coulsnt talk my way out of it, i'm sure. Or i would have killed day, if i were going for pr's it would have been day over pooky 3000% of the time

Day’s Pr kind of sucks though

Whereas Pooky could have been anything, and was more Tr than Pooky. Day could have been a future mislim depending on Pooky’s role, but Pooky wasn’t limmable

Don’t pretend that you’re this surface level in you’re thinking as scum

In post 4755, skitter30 wrote:Pedit2 i wouldnt have killed him laat night. I'm not telling you to townread me off of it, i'm merely stating a fact

It’s not a fact. You can’t prove it whatsoever. I’m not saying it is 100% the world we live in that you’re scum and killed Pooky. But to say it’s not possible when Pooky was:
A: Very active and solvey.
B: Very town and townread.
C: Had a power role that might clear their primary scumread or cause trouble for any mafia players.
D: Would become a big threat to town assuming they started to townread Farkran and they are both town power solving the game from D2.

It’s just such a stupid argument for you to repeat when it is not provable whatsoever. And even if it’s an unlikely kill. Scum make unlikely kills all the time, either for WIFOM or maybe it’s even just an suboptimal kill that later turns out to be an mistake.

In post 4768, Menalque wrote:This is just a really dumb order to do things in Luca

Let’s just flip fark and if he’s town then we can talk more about skitter

But if we go skitter!town -> fark!scum that’s just like... so dumb

I don’t think Farkran is scum though

In post 4771, NorwegianboyEE wrote:Would become a big threat to town assuming they started to townread Farkr

The odds of this happening were... not good

In post 4766, skitter30 wrote:

In post 4763, Luca Blight wrote:

In post 4761, skitter30 wrote:

In post 4759, Luca Blight wrote:Farkran is on four votes already, yeah it’s really negated your ability to push him lol

And it could have been five and he would have done most of the heavy lifting sooooooo

Talk about trying to avoid getting my hands dirty

Yeah cos Pooky wouldn’t have reassessed at all after inexplicably being kept alive and me being dead instead

I'm p confident he woulsnt have - nothint would have changed overnight to change his worldview

Erm, yes - Him being alive and me being dead would have made him reassess big time, unless he’s a really low level player (which clearly he isn’t)

And for all you knew he could have been an investigative