Mafiascum.net

@Midway - what are your thoughts on my POE'd 5?

In post 4798, midwaybear wrote:I think we to focus again. What makes 420's claim town to you morph? I don't remember any explanation really, and I'm probably leaning towards revoting there today. I know muffin said something about it not making sense as a role to claim from a scum perspective, but I'm not sure why that is either.

Sentimentality. The white mage in NY165 got miselimed the day that claim was made. the scum team went all out to remove her. (they thought she was the SK and that the claim was impossible - too overpowered to be an actual role. Half the town went along with that.

I didn't. And a debt to all white mages everywhere was incurred. I didn't fight the elim hard enough (maybe there was no amount of fight that would have been enough? I was arguing against scum-Angry Pidgeon).

Yeah, sentimentality, but even so, I want to think deep thoughts about this a while.

In post 4800, Flavor Leaf wrote:@Midway - what are your thoughts on my POE'd 5?

Why are you townreading Maid? That whole piece of the equation sorta affects everything. I think this silence was just to stall for them and then they try to claim"shenanigans".

In post 4801, morph the cat wrote:Yeah, sentimentality, but even so, I want to think deep thoughts about this a while.

Alright. This sorta makes me want to go outside the claims today, but I'm not sure how viable that is.

In post 4803, midwaybear wrote:

In post 4800, Flavor Leaf wrote:@Midway - what are your thoughts on my POE'd 5?

Why are you townreading Maid? That whole piece of the equation sorta affects everything. I think this silence was just to stall for them and then they try to claim"shenanigans".

Maria doesn't do stuff like that, I don't feel.

I've been scum with Maria multiple times, and I've caught scum Maria multiple times, I just don't think that's a play they do here, alongside they could have claimed literally anything else and been fine.

Similar to Remelia, like, why even claim that at all if you're just scum? I guess Remelia could be using it to survive in a lylo situation, but still, weird setup if scum.

In post 4804, midwaybear wrote:

In post 4801, morph the cat wrote:Yeah, sentimentality, but even so, I want to think deep thoughts about this a while.

Alright. This sorta makes me want to go outside the claims today, but I'm not sure how viable that is.

Regardless, at least 2 scum if Morph is town, is in that 5. I really don't see why we would ever go outside of that group of 5 today. That's a rather large POE too, I'm lightweight super annoyed people just pass it by. They're purely fact related too, so it's not even just my analysis. (there's some, I guess, like trusting Bell as town, and in turn trusting midway) but yeah, that shouldn't be an issue for you at all then, Midwaybear.

@Midway what are your reads on Morph and Bell?

In post 4803, midwaybear wrote:

In post 4800, Flavor Leaf wrote:@Midway - what are your thoughts on my POE'd 5?

Why are you townreading Maid? That whole piece of the equation sorta affects everything. I think this silence was just to stall for them and then they try to claim"shenanigans".

if we really want to, we can add them to the 5, making it a 6, that still leaves a 50% of all scum being in there bar Morphscum.

difference between Morph and Zmuffin for me right now, is I feel Morph is just being surface level town, and Zmuffin is acting like surface level town because it defends their position as scum.

note to self: claim white mage in next fferycabd game

In post 4810, zMuffinMan wrote:note to self: claim white mage in next fferycabd game

<3

Cabd was on that scumteam. Pretty sure he's not feeling sentimental at all!

In post 4789, zMuffinMan wrote:i am half expecting april reaches lylo, "solves" the game, votes town, but the only thing april remembers about this game is that at one point he called the scum team and that makes him good at solving

i fully expect to find a similar pattern in past games from april if i could be bothered looking into them

to be fair, this will be true no matter what. I set out just a far superior net than you lot, so while I did catch scum, i still have townies in there, and I have to filter the townies out.

Surface level thinking just can't comprehend it.

"i did catch scum"

and yet...

oh you just mean of the 12 people you've called scum at some point, you've been right about someone somewhere along the line

i see

well, hard to argue youre wrong about that

kudos. i concede the point

Exactly. Finally, you're taking a step on the staircase of getting out of that surface level mindset.

and day 2 has all been about facts.

I went looking for the role I was thinking about and took a trip down memory lane and forgot why I was there

BRB

need to learn how to separate day phases, zmuffin

my prediction for the first thing april says in lylo: "look, im sure 3 of you 6 are scum... you may as well give up now"

In post 4819, zMuffinMan wrote:my prediction for the first thing april says in lylo: "look, im sure 3 of you 6 are scum... you may as well give up now"

surface level :shrug:

"it's surface level thinking to not know you dont stand a chance now that ive POEd you. unlucky you rolled scum against someone whos so good at solving games"

it's more likely I die, nobody listens to me, and scum win, if anything

8 seconds late to call the 'surface level' remark

damn

I'm a late game town hyper carry. Early game is eh, I can get a solve here and there, but it's really about the late game.