Mafiascum.net

Why did you vote Ali, Ydrasse?

On a unrelated note, i think ydrasse is town and i have mistakenly poed her based on wrong assumptions. Lucy still town, i believe she has sincere doubts about me vs skitter in this context and was towny for the entirety of d1

Btw the kill doesn't incriminate skitter at all, the kill matters literally nothing imo. It's how people are positioning around the kill that worries me

Pedit: YDRASSE ACTUALLY READS MY MIND <3 I LOVE YOU SO MUCH! I DIDN'T EXPECT THAT! I wrote this post BEFORE ydrasse posted

I won't fail you, i promise

In post 4797, Luca Blight wrote:From an objective standpoint, isn’t it *safer* and more logical to assume scum!Skitter (along with her team who also have a say) *might* have killed Pooky in this situation?

Like I’m not even arguing the kill incriminates her, I’m just saying it certainly doesn’t clear her as it was objectively the obvious kill

If there’s other compelling reasons for Town!skit then I’m open to hearing them, but I’m never going to buy this line of reasoning

And I’m suspicious of the number of players who have so willingly accepted and peddled this line. I believe Menalque is genuine in what he’s saying, but I’m not so sure from players like Lucy and SS

I completely agree, and i'm almost tempted to say that it could just be bad and lazy solving from scum in Alisae and maybe also Mena. (And also SS/Lucy apparently? I didn't pay much attention to them, but if they did do push that line of reasoning then i agree it would be sus)
I think Mena could just be town hard defending Skitter in all ways because Skitter defended his slot when E-1 though.

I had a look at Mene's new scumwin and the contrast to his play here makes me feel better about that townread. He tries to ~solve~ and ~look towny~ with his time there when he just wasn't doing that for the first half of this game (credit goes to skitter22).

I liked Chara's recent thoughts and they echo what I don't like about Alisae.

Lucy, any reason for the reduced WIM this day phase?

Alisae, can you explain how familiarity with you would quench the suspicions I have?

Yeah so Mena/Skitter right now is either T+T or T+S. Where Mena would always be town, and Skitter is either town or scum because i could see scum!Skitter trying to pocket Mena too.

Agree with the above, leaving both town right now though.

Lucy said (I think) she reconsidered her Skitter SR based on NKA

SS originally agreed with my argument, but later decided to trust Menalque that Skitter wouldn’t kill Pooky, which didn’t sit well with me

*leaning

In post 4801, Farkran wrote:On a unrelated note, i think ydrasse is town and i have mistakenly poed her based on wrong assumptions. Lucy still town, i believe she has sincere doubts about me vs skitter in this context and was towny for the entirety of d1

Btw the kill doesn't incriminate skitter at all, the kill matters literally nothing imo. It's how people are positioning around the kill that worries me

Pedit: YDRASSE ACTUALLY READS MY MIND <3 I LOVE YOU SO MUCH! I DIDN'T EXPECT THAT! I wrote this post BEFORE ydrasse posted

I won't fail you, i promise

<3 we got this

@luca am at work but, beginning of day stance + some other things

In post 4745, Luca Blight wrote:Congrats on the new job

I was just about to make a post saying I think the gamestate (as I understand it) implies you’re Town

Luca, Day, Chara, Farkran, Norwee, Menalque Town. Maybe Lucy? But not so confident rn

Scum in Skitter, SS, Ydrasse, Lucy, Ali

Day, Norwee, Farkran, do you agree with these reads?

Would be good if we could create some unity

In post 4809, Ydrasse wrote:

In post 4801, Farkran wrote:On a unrelated note, i think ydrasse is town and i have mistakenly poed her based on wrong assumptions. Lucy still town, i believe she has sincere doubts about me vs skitter in this context and was towny for the entirety of d1

Btw the kill doesn't incriminate skitter at all, the kill matters literally nothing imo. It's how people are positioning around the kill that worries me

Pedit: YDRASSE ACTUALLY READS MY MIND <3 I LOVE YOU SO MUCH! I DIDN'T EXPECT THAT! I wrote this post BEFORE ydrasse posted

I won't fail you, i promise

:D <3 we got this

@luca am at work but, beginning of day stance + some other things

What about my stance?

Oh yeah, CONGRATS on the job, Norwee! Happy for you.

In post 4810, Luca Blight wrote:

In post 4745, Luca Blight wrote:Congrats on the new job

I was just about to make a post saying I think the gamestate (as I understand it) implies you’re Town

Luca, Day, Chara, Farkran, Norwee, Menalque Town. Maybe Lucy? But not so confident rn

Scum in Skitter, SS, Ydrasse, Lucy, Ali

Day, Norwee, Farkran, do you agree with these reads?

Would be good if we could create some unity

Hmm, 'll make another readslist.

In post 4780, Luca Blight wrote:I don’t like SS’s vote and think he could easily be scum

For what it's worth, I'm not sure that I would be making a push like that as scum if I didn't have to.

Why not?

In post 4746, Menalque wrote:Luca could u do me a solid and stop voting town ty

Why would you post this concurrent with me trying to shift to a humbler approach to the game and voting with you?

Ya this is a really interesting day

Aww, thanks.

In post 4810, Luca Blight wrote:

In post 4745, Luca Blight wrote:Congrats on the new job

I was just about to make a post saying I think the gamestate (as I understand it) implies you’re Town

Luca, Day, Chara, Farkran, Norwee, Menalque Town. Maybe Lucy? But not so confident rn

Scum in Skitter, SS, Ydrasse, Lucy, Ali

Day, Norwee, Farkran, do you agree with these reads?

Would be good if we could create some unity

Not entirely convinced about menalque, but i can postpone my doubts for later and look for the other 2 scum if this is the case

Lucy i think is town, her take on me is on the wrong side but not scummy side of wrong - if she wanted to push me because she sees me as lhf she would have sided w/ skit yesterday not the other way around

Ydrasse i mean maybe, but she's never gone below the null line tbh, the only reason i had her as potential scum is because of a potential poe that i'm revisiting significantly

SS i wanna hear from him again

Do you townread Chara enough to place it outside of the list? I'd place it alongside ydrasse rn, its posts about alisae are solid but also somewhat convenient if ali is town and skitter is scum + d1 behavior wasn't pristine especially around Day

In post 4807, Luca Blight wrote:SS originally agreed with my argument, but later decided to trust Menalque that Skitter wouldn’t kill Pooky, which didn’t sit well with me

Like I said... I don't understand his reasoning, but that doesn't make it wrong, and he knows her very well. It's a team game, and so I'm going to trust the opinion of someone who's better-informed than I am. What part of that doesn't sit right with you?

Skitter, Mena, Lucy, SS
Day, Fark, Norwee, Ydrasse, Chara, Luca

I can solve this

In post 4810, Luca Blight wrote:

In post 4745, Luca Blight wrote:Congrats on the new job

I was just about to make a post saying I think the gamestate (as I understand it) implies you’re Town

Luca, Day, Chara, Farkran, Norwee, Menalque Town. Maybe Lucy? But not so confident rn

Scum in Skitter, SS, Ydrasse, Lucy, Ali

Day, Norwee, Farkran, do you agree with these reads?

Would be good if we could create some unity

Making a readslist is hard right now, I have too many conflicting thoughts.

'll just say I agree with: Luca, Day, Norwee, Menalque town.

and Ydrasse are towny but not on the same tier as the above.

Chara, Farkran, Something_Smart, Lucy conflicted?

Alisae scum.

I struck out Lucy and moved her down because thinking on it, I have a few reasons to be paranoid now, even though I targeted her last night...

In post 4459, LegoLucy wrote:

In post 4398, Day wrote:Lucy, what's your read on skitter and Farkran now?

Scumlean townlean? There's a smidge, if only a smidge, of nka clearing skitter. And my feeling that Fark is town is outpacing my ability to articulate why Fark is town and that can be a bad sign.
I hate not having skitter scumlocked because it makes me sadderer when she scumreads me X.X

In post 4669, LegoLucy wrote:I was offering to Ali.

I can move it until Ali's turn.

VOTE: Farkran

Why are you voting for Farkran right now and not skitter22?