Seems to me like two or three of you are trying to get Dourgrim quicklynched. Meanwhile we have no meaningful data to go on for day 2 yet... I didn't even realize Nonny hadn't posted yet.
I'll shut up now and let somebody else contribute.
First it's mindless, then it's fishing? Fishing for what?Mr. Flay wrote:When he followed it up with a cute little "because I know he's evil" it made me pretty certain that it was a fishing expedition
What would you expect me to do when the person I am voting for gives me more justification for my vote? Remove it?Mr. Flay wrote:You voted for me long before Assasin told us his vote was random, now you say you're voting for me because I seemed to know something about his vote when none of us knew it was random.
IS always gets a free ride, otherwise we'd be lynching him on Day 1 every game.Mr. Flay wrote:Yet IS gets a free ride for saying Dourgrim is evil as well. How many investigative roles do you think there *are* in this game, Talitha?
Well, if your going to pick someone random, why pick someone who has played mafia a lot, and is very experienced with the game, when you have newbies in this game that have never played before. I mean the chances of being scum are the same guessing at Dourgrim and a newbie, but if Dourgrim were town, that would be a bigger loss than if a newbie were town.. That is my way of looking at it.. But then there is always the possibility of Dourgrim being scum, so if you really think that's the case then forget everything I just said.Internet Stranger said:
So you pick someone at random, lynch them, and hope for the best. This time around, Dourgrim is the one I picked and hence, the winner of the Day 1 bandwagon. So lets hop to it, pile on the votes and show him how popular he really is.
Mindless, fishing, weird.... it flipped my triggers. If it doesn't yours, and it seems to not be anyone else's, then so be it. I'm just throwing out what I've got so far.Talitha wrote:First it's mindless, then it's fishing? Fishing for what?Mr. Flay wrote:When he followed it up with a cute little "because I know he's evil" it made me pretty certain that it was a fishing expedition
Of course not, provided you feel I've continued to justify it. I don't see quite what you think I'm doing so differently, besides continuing to debate this with you.Talitha wrote:What would you expect me to do when the person I am voting for gives me more justification for my vote? Remove it?Mr. Flay wrote:You voted for me long before Assasin told us his vote was random, now you say you're voting for me because I seemed to know something about his vote when none of us knew it was random.
That's why I said I wasn't voting him...despite his behavior, nobody ever seem to lynch him for it.Talitha wrote:IS always gets a free ride, otherwise we'd be lynching him on Day 1 every game.Mr. Flay wrote:Yet IS gets a free ride for saying Dourgrim is evil as well. How many investigative roles do you think there *are* in this game, Talitha?
Because the point of the random Day One bandwagon theory is to obtain information for the Town... and, since I'm pro-Town, I'm willing to give said information if everyone thinks it'll be beneficial. You will note that I didTalitha wrote:OK, why is Dourgrim offering to claim his role name when only 2 people are voting for him?
This is inconsistent with your questioning of why I was willing to give my role name with only two votes on me, don't you think? I'mTalitha wrote:He seems a littletoounconcerned about being bandwagoned. And this seems better to me than stalling the game and getting a deadline.
What makes offering a role name odd after two votes? I did specifically say that I would only give the name if/whenTalitha wrote:Your offer to give a name after only 2 votes was odd. So was your assertion that a random bandwagon on you was quite justified. I'm not sure how that adds up to me being inconsistent.
... which, again, I have. You seem to be pointedly ignoring the fact that I didTalitha wrote:With regards to roleclaiming, I'm not sure how you giving us a guitarist name is going to help much. We don't have any information as to scum roles yet. If you were town, I'd expect that you would want to keep that kind of info to yourself for as long as possible, though..