SMBM II: Defense of Yoshi's Island (Final! MVPs announced!)

[Hoppster]

This vote doesn't need interrogation. It's very obviously pressure and asking a "why" behind it shows a

little bit

of "Let me try to see if I can undermine this vote". There is plenty of "I really want to know why the vote is there", which could be newbie logic (not getting the pressure behind the vote), but there is that little bit of scum motivation.

Xeras:

July 28, 2011

Vifam:

May 30, 2011

They're obviously relatively new... you didn't consider that both could be newbs (therefore probably a null-tell) before declaring that one of the two is scum?

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Isa

So much scum motivation I can't even see it
UNVOTE:
VOTE: DemonHybrid

This looks like a vote that is deliberately vague so that it could equally be defended in retrospect as either a serious vote or a non-serious vote.

Can't it be...BOTH!? The grey area between an RVS vote and not an RVS vote...how I adore thee.

No, it can't.

I've done it before as scum and I did it very deliberately so that I could test the waters and also give myself an escape route.

I haven't done it as town and I see no motivation to do so.

[DemonHybrid]

Unvote

It's time to quicklynch David Xantos. He is scum.

Vote: David Xantos

This vote doesn't need interrogation. It's very obviously pressure and asking a "why" behind it shows a

little bit

of "Let me try to see if I can undermine this vote". There is plenty of "I really want to know why the vote is there", which could be newbie logic (not getting the pressure behind the vote), but there is that little bit of scum motivation.

It IS anti-town, but one person doing it is fine. Two people doing in a row is weird and shows blatant off motivation.

I covered this, Hoppster.

[Isa]

Sheeping for emphasis etc. Also, why asking that question is scummy is something I'll never understand. Bleh.

PEdit: in reply to DHybrid

[Hoppster]

I covered this, Hoppster.

Not to a satisfactory degree...

With one person, you were happy to write it off as 'ok maybe newb' (you say yourself there is only "that little bit of scum motivation", but with two people (both who have joined within the last 2 months and are thusly new to the site) you weren't? That seems like a jump to me.

[Hoppster]

fuck messed up bracketing >____>

* motivation")

[DemonHybrid]

It's RVS. I'll put pressure on the weird before I can make a conscious 100% decision on where to put my vote. I'm letting Vifam explain himself.

[Isa]

Hoppster, fine then, call it a serious vote, because I wanted the pressure that only comes from a vote to make DHybrid explain himself. I then added a mildly humorous reasoning because that's how I roll...which also made it BOTH sort of an RVS vote and a non-RVS vote. Hence my reply.

[Vifam]

Vifam, did you read Xeras' reply to projectmatt before you asked that question?

Yes, I did, mostly because I thought it would be kind of comical.

Repeating what Xeras said was more of a joke but I was just as curious at Matt's scumread as Xeras was. I don't see what copying what he said is "Anti town" when really all it did was apply some pressure to Matt to explain her "scumread". And I kept up with that as the discussion kept on.

[DemonHybrid]

Unvote

If you were a few years more experienced, I'd want you dead. I'll accept the joke reasoning, however.

[Bowser]

The "We Jump on Goombas" votecount of Day 1

Ranmaru [L-12]
hiplop [L-12]
chkflip [L-12]
Kcdapot [L-12]
Vifam [L-12]
David Xanatos [L-12]
TheJakalope [L-12]
manho [L-12]
Parabollocks [L-12]
projectmatt [L-12]
Riceballtail [L-12]
WeyounsLastClone [L-12]
Sunset [L-11] chkflip
Wrathchild [L-12]
Xeras [L-12]
Bunnylover [L-11] WLC
diddin [L-12]
Isa [L-10] Hoppster, hiplop
stormer [L-12]
DemonHybrid [L-10] Isa, Xeras
Celebloki [L-12]
Hoppster [L-12]

With 22 still kicking, it takes 12 to lynch, and 6 to lynch at deadline.

Deadline is

(expired on 2011-09-08 13:00:00)

or

September 8th, 2011 @ 12:00pm CDT

[DemonHybrid]

Good news is, I was wrong about me finding it weird and Xeras/Vifam are probably town. See how magical RVS is?

I'm trying to process Ira's actions up to this point.

[Hoppster]

Hoppster, fine then, call it a serious vote, because I wanted the pressure that only comes from a vote to make DHybrid explain himself. I then added a mildly humorous reasoning because that's how I roll...which also made it BOTH sort of an RVS vote and a non-RVS vote. Hence my reply.

^^^ looks like scum appeasing his attacker to me.

Still happy with my vote.


DH: I'll save you the trouble. Isa is scum.

[Isa]

Nah, I'm not. I don't see the scumminess in my actions just because you've done so as scum.

[DemonHybrid]

Vote: Isa

.

That last reply was fishy and deflective.

[Hoppster]

Nah, I'm not. I don't see the scumminess in my actions just because you've done so as scum.

In which case why did you change your stance from "it can be both" to "okay fine maybe it's not"?

[Isa]

Because I didn't really care about if it was a serious vote or not?

[Vifam]

Bleh


This wagon kind of fails, I don't think Isa not being straightforward in her initial vote is a scum give away.

[David Xanatos]

I don't think it's that anymore.. to me it's more the deflection and the fact she's apparently loathe to give any detail.. :/

[Vifam]

I don't think it's that anymore.. to me it's more the deflection and the fact she's apparently loathe to give any detail.. :/

I see no deflection, I see a townie trying to extinguish an argument, really.

[Xeras]

Tch. I am going back to my 'people who have not confirmed' vote.

Unvote, Vote: Diddin

I don't thin scum would look so obvious out of the gate.

[projectmatt]

I don't thin scum would look so obvious out of the gate.

This was directed at the Isa wagon, right? You think that a scum would intentionally act obvious? No. A scum can act scummy unintentionally. This logic hurts my head.

Vote: Xeras

[Xeras]

Nah, it was based on my unvote of DH...

[Vifam]

You guys are lame.


VOTE: Sunset

[projectmatt]

My bad. Your logic is still a tad illogical though.

Good news is, I was wrong about me finding it weird and Xeras/Vifam are probably town. See how magical RVS is?

I don't like this post. Did Xeras and Vifam objectively towntell to you, or did they just prove that you were attacking them based off of faulty logic? Why are they now town reads?

[Parabollocks]

Unvote

It's time to quicklynch David Xantos. He is scum.

Vote: David Xantos

Why is David scum?

Why is David Scum?

More to the point..

Who is David Xantos?

People keep referring to him, but I have no idea who he is..

Why was David scum, matt? the world wants to know.

multiposting a go-go baby.

also hi