↑The Acting Method wrote:Okay RedPanda, explain this. Besides me, only 4 people have posted anything. Yet you expect me to start scumhunting this early?
good you're a smart cookie.
unvote
But why do you think shotgun venmar and bork are town?
Right now their posts seem townie... Though I would like Shotgun to explain his easy acceptance of your idea of claiming early and basically trying to flush out the town for scum to kill... HOW IS THIS PRO TOWN?
↑The Acting Method wrote:@RedPanda: Why the early claim for no reason? If you are telling the truth all you are doing is narrowing down who the Masons are so the scum can kill. And if you are lying... See above.
you answered your own question.[/quote]
So are you confessing yourself to be scum? Because I don't see how this claim is benefiting town at all. Mafia can easily claim vanilla, trick the town into lynching town, kill off the Masons at night under that idea. Unless you are presuming that Mafia will take the obvious route of fakeclaiming Mason, which can quickly be outed after one death.
↑drmyshotgun wrote:I claim Vanilla Townie VOTE: TAM
once we catch those 5 other VT's
this games going to be as easy as eating cake.
Let the townhunting begin.
UNVOTE: Venmar
@Potack-ruv
Why is RP obvtown?
Especially after the above post? (As in the one quoted)
How so Potack?
Posted: Sat Jun 23, 2012 5:34 pm
by RedPanda
hehe
this is fun.
Let the drama skyrocket.
I will be back later to clean up the mess and catch scum.
Posted: Sat Jun 23, 2012 5:35 pm
by Potack-ruv
RP is just super special obvtown. I don't see scum claiming that early for no apparent reason. He's also probably sparked the most amount of discussion, and I feel like he's trying to find new things by going against the flow.
tl;dr Gut reads
Posted: Sat Jun 23, 2012 5:36 pm
by RedPanda
you answered your question - Scum don't know if I'm lying or telling the truth.
trying to push me to reveal whether I'm telling the truth or lying is what is scummy and antitown.
Posted: Sat Jun 23, 2012 5:36 pm
by drmyshotgun
I don't actually know if it's Pro-Town. I just did it.
Part of the reason was to see if anyone joins up in a scummy way.
Yeah, Potack's entering post was pretty scummy.
Posted: Sat Jun 23, 2012 5:37 pm
by Potack-ruv
Why is RP scum?
Also Gunny of all people should know how I play as town. That scumread on me is so horribly fake that I'm almost tempted to vote him over bork. He obviously has a guilty conscience when his first reaction to me calling him scum is that I must be scum, not something like "Why am I scum?"
PEDIT: Lol Gunny, stop being obvscum. I wanted a challenge.
Posted: Sat Jun 23, 2012 5:39 pm
by drmyshotgun
Umm, yeah, then the challenge must be on convincing others that I'm scum, right?
Or another challenge is to see me as Town in my obvscum position to you right now. Which I am.
↑The Acting Method wrote:@RedPanda: Why the early claim for no reason? If you are telling the truth all you are doing is narrowing down who the Masons are so the scum can kill. And if you are lying... See above.
you answered your own question.
So are you confessing yourself to be scum? Because I don't see how this claim is benefiting town at all. Mafia can easily claim vanilla, trick the town into lynching town, kill off the Masons at night under that idea. Unless you are presuming that Mafia will take the obvious route of fakeclaiming Mason, which can quickly be outed after one death.
@Red: Still, I don't like the logic behind it. It feels off.
And explain how I'm trying to push you? I'm pushing at your motivation. I don't see how it helps town. Weren't you just complaining about moves that don't help Town?
Posted: Sat Jun 23, 2012 5:40 pm
by Potack-ruv
I'm convincing others by explaining why you're scum.
Why are you town?
Posted: Sat Jun 23, 2012 5:41 pm
by Potack-ruv
I still have yet to see you explain properly why we are scum.
Posted: Sat Jun 23, 2012 5:43 pm
by RedPanda
↑The Acting Method wrote:And explain how I'm trying to push you? I'm pushing at your motivation. I don't see how it helps town. Weren't you just complaining about moves that don't help Town?
I'm not saying you are pushing me to reveal it.
I'm just saying pushing me to reveal it is wrong.
It helped me. Maybe you don't understand it.
but I know What I'm doing.
Posted: Sat Jun 23, 2012 5:44 pm
by Potack-ruv
RP, vote Gunny and I will switch. Otherwise, vote bork if you aren't already.
Posted: Sat Jun 23, 2012 5:44 pm
by drmyshotgun
Why Potack is scummy
1. Giving off reads like free candies.
2. Entering the game following the trend without really giving it a thought. (has AcRv agreed on your claiming btw?)
Posted: Sat Jun 23, 2012 5:45 pm
by drmyshotgun
VOTE: Potack
Posted: Sat Jun 23, 2012 5:45 pm
by The Acting Method
@Potack, your explanation makes sense. However, I don't see the advantage to town that that move holds.
I think I have all my questions answered at present, I'll have to read through to see if I gain anything new from a re read.
kk RP
Posted: Sat Jun 23, 2012 5:47 pm
by RedPanda
↑Potack-ruv wrote:RP, vote Gunny and I will switch. Otherwise, vote bork if you aren't already.
actually I have early town reads on the both of them based on certain things.
Posted: Sat Jun 23, 2012 5:48 pm
by Potack-ruv
Why are either of those things scummy? Explain the motivations behind them. Entering the game and claiming is totally towny, at least I didn't have to ask for approval to make sure what I did wasn't scummy. AcRv wasn't even here lol.
@TAM: Who said it had to hold an advantage to town? It disadvantages scum more like it.