Mafiascum.net

In post 49, PhDScar wrote:[quote="I'm scum because I always eat the last cookie in the jar, even though someone else wants it.

How dare you! You knew I called dibs on that cookie. [/quote]
Well... looks like I messed that up. Sorry new here.

In post 48, PhDScar wrote:So it looks like the general opinion for the voting is to only do policy lynches as a last resort and only liars. Do you guys agree with that?

Lies can be helpful, IMO. A good gambit can go a long way, so it really depends on the experience of the player as to whether a lynch is necessary.

And lurkers can be a good lynch if they only come in to prod dodge and barely provide any content without an excuse.

So no, I'm afraid I don't simply agree with only lynching liars. Doesn't mean it's the wrong answer. It just means I'm not cool with it.

Not "only lynching liars" but even last resort, lynching liars isn't the best way for my vote to go.

Okay I actually sort of agree with your opinion. I wasn't saying that was my opinion it was just how it seemed all the players in this were leaning.

In post 31, PhDScar wrote:I think the "Lynching All Liars" could be safest thing to do. So i agree with that. I don't agree with "Lynching All Lurkers" because you never know what the reason is. Maybe they have computer issues or a real life emergency.

I don't agree. Lynch All Liars and Lynch all Lurkers is most debatable topic.
Sometimes town need to like inorder to hide PR's, becuz scum breadcumbs most the times to get the town PR's out, so it is important that town PR's lie to protect themselves and help town. and about lurking. not all lurkers are not scum. Most Scum can easily fade away out of discussion says that they are busy and need time to catch up and all that.. We don't know anything for certain when they say if that was emergeynch or scum lie. there were numerous players who has done that here.. its not always the same.

I'll be .

Just a heads up. I'll try to answer questions when I get back.

1) Lurking is a null-tell! I seriously do not understand how so many people don't get this already
Same with liars, but I'm not as sure on this, because I'm a forum mafia noob (came from real time, online and irl)
2)

patzer wrote:I am town.

0_0 Seconded. I really don't know how to answer this question.
3) Refer to 2

EBWOP:

Also FOS: Sakura Hana

answers seemed scummy to me.

In post 57, TMTOLBTWNTOF wrote:EBWOP:

Also FOS: Sakura Hana

answers seemed scummy to me.

Why?

I fos'd, so I think that Sakura is leaning scum, not is scum.

Sakura Hana wrote:The only reason someone can be scum is because RNG

This really seems to me like an avoidance of the question

Sakura Hana wrote:
You have no reason to not vote me right now because we're just starting and no one knows anyone, so you have as much reason to vote me or not vote me as anyone else.

This as well, it just seems like an attempt to be as "PC" as possible

Well the last 2 questions seemed pretty rethorical to me, so i decided to answer in a way not everyone would answer, since everyone would just answer "I'm town" or "Because I'm town"

also what is being "PC"?

PC = politically correct as in trying to say things in a way that will appease everyone.

Ah, i see, well my apologies in being "PC" or whatever, but what i want to ask you is, would you be happier with an answer like what i said, or me going for the rhetorical question (is that spelled right?) and saying "I'm not scum"/"I'm town" and "Because I'm town" that everyone is giving.

In post 38, Does Bo Know wrote:Hey Majiffy, any particular reason for voting PhDScar?

Cuz he has a scum role PM. Vote him with me.

In post 65, Majiffy wrote:

In post 38, Does Bo Know wrote:Hey Majiffy, any particular reason for voting PhDScar?

Cuz he has a scum role PM. Vote him with me.

... What the hell kind of logic is that?! First of all I don't have a PM saying I'm playing scum. Secondly if I did how the fuck would you know? You can't see my Pm's.

In post 65, Majiffy wrote: Cuz he has a scum role PM. Vote him with me.

Another one of those gut feelings?

TMT, why aren't you voting Sakuna if you have suspicion of her?

Majiffy, fair enough. None of the other wagons have provided any good content, guess we should try another.

UNVOTE: anorway
VOTE: PhDScar

PhDScar, why did you unvote TMT?

I'm kind of iffy about PhD's wagon, is there any reason why you 2 are voting him?

In post 69, Does Bo Know wrote:Majiffy, fair enough.

None of the other wagons have provided any good content, guess we should try another.

UNVOTE: anorway
VOTE: PhDScar

Any reason you're worried about PhD's wagon with only 2 votes on it?

More like wondering why, because i haven't seen any reason as to why it exists in the first place

Or is that still RVS?

You're iffy about it. Why are you iffy about it?

I feel like we're still technically in RVS. I haven't seen anything that warrants a serious vote yet.

Did you think we were out of RVS?