Mini 1451: A Memory of Light (Game Over)

[Demon]

So you found Matt antitown and found the reasoning of my vote on you to be illegitimate and you still just waltz around in this game chilling in the RVS.

[Demon]

*waltzed, God help me get any idea of whether you're still in RVS now or not.

[Selkies]

So you found Matt antitown and found the reasoning of my vote on you to be illegitimate and you still just waltz around in this game chilling in the RVS.

Are you trying to say something here?

I find Matt antitown, I don't know if he's scum yet or not.

I find the reason for you voting me to be illegitimate, but why should I find that scummy?

I wouldn't call this RVS (which I equate with a waste of time) given I already have a pretty decent town read. I know what I want to achieve with my votes and posts, which fundamentally differs it from "random" voting. But okay, feel free it that.

Who's scum from your POV?

[Demon]

Can you take a fucking stance wow, is your vote on Matt right now random or because what?

You and Matt are my scummiest reads (as I have been stating basically this whole game so far).

[Selkies]

Can you take a fucking stance wow, is your vote on Matt right now random or because what?

You and Matt are my scummiest reads (as I have been stating basically this whole game so far).

Stance on what?

Matt is null but I think I can figure him out.

Why are we a scumread again

[Cephrir]

Vote Count 1.1

Selkies 3

(Demon, MattP, Nero Cain)

MattP 1

(Selkies)

NicCage 1

(Belisarius)

Nero Cain 1

(GoodCop_BadCop)

Belisarius 1

(Iecerint)

Not Voting 6

(sword_of_omens, milkshake, NicCage, Miss Destroyer, ThAdmiral, Ghostlin)

With 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch.

The deadline for Day 1 is Monday, June 3rd, at 1 PM EST. This is in (expired on 2013-06-03 13:00:00).

[Selkies]

Can't remember if I posted these

orcinus - http://forum.mafiascum.net/memberlist.p ... le&u=20360

fferyllt - http://forum.mafiascum.net/memberlist.p ... le&u=20541

Our previous Selkies game - http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=83&t=27165

We should have named ourselves Jekyll Hydra.

[Selkies]

^^ - f

[Selkies]

Wake me up when RVS is over

- f

I'm liking you for town, too.

- f

[Ghostlin]

Do you see how in ANY of those three situations it would be harmful for me to divulge what I'm actually doing?

So my next question is, why did you ask me a stupid question

Let me ask you a question: if someone was doing something you didn't understand for reasons you didn't understand, would you ask them why they were doing it?

[MattP]

No I'm pretty smart and know how to keep my mouth shut when a player is trying to do something even if it means I can't be let in on all of the details immediately but thank you for asking

[Ghostlin]

Oh, so you're doing a bullshit reaction test. Good to know.

[ThAdmiral]

So you found Matt antitown and found the reasoning of my vote on you to be illegitimate and you still just waltz around in this game chilling in the RVS.

@ Matt: Ill ask another question on ghostlins behalf - did you expect no one to question you?

[ThAdmiral]

Um, must have accuseddentakky quoted demon there...

Ill repost the question.

@ Matt: did you expect no one to question you?

[ThAdmiral]

*accuseddentakky=accidentally. Yeah, I'm on my phone.

I tend to agree with ghostlin - it strikes me as disingenuous when people do something for a reaction and then act surprised when they get a reaction.

[ThAdmiral]

All things considered, though, Matt is probably town.

(4 posts in a row!)

[Ghostlin]

*accuseddentakky=accidentally. Yeah, I'm on my phone.

I tend to agree with ghostlin - it strikes me as disingenuous when people do something for a reaction and then act surprised when they get a reaction.

Mmm. I tend to find reaction tests in general bullshit, but I agree with both this, and your last post.

[MattP]

Um, must have accuseddentakky quoted demon there...

Ill repost the question.

@ Matt: did you expect no one to question you?

Oh I expect reactions and ghostlins reaction was antitown and terrible

But thank you for Your input and for defending a player with an apparently unknown alignment to you

[ThAdmiral]

Nah, ghostlin looks more likely town if anything from his posts.

[MattP]

You should let things happen instead of analyzing things five posts in

[ThAdmiral]

Like you did?

[Nero Cain]

You should let things happen instead of analyzing things five posts in

Hypothetically speaking, how long should we have allowed you to argue with Ghost before anyone else chimed in?

[milkshake]

No strong opinions so far from me. I see MattP's VT claim as more of a discussion starter. That's townish in itself, but not the kind of townish that would be difficult for scum to emulate.

[Nero Cain]

eh, Matt's vt claim is prob some sort of gambit as he supposedly does them as either alignment.

[Ghostlin]

eh, Matt's vt claim is prob some sort of gambit as he supposedly does them as either alignment.

I tend to treat such tactics as townish, since attention whoring reaction tests, while can be done by scum, don't usually get done because they attract attention and require an amount of...sticking your neck out and misinterpretation.

That said, could you link me to some scum meta where he's pulled off this gambit?