Not always. I almost lost a game because someone gave out too much information early.
How many games have you played?
↑ Dechs Kaison wrote:
My games are mostly off site. I don't know if yours are.
Getting flippant isn't cute. You know there's a difference between in game information and meta information like how many games you've played. Just answer the question, please.
↑ Dechs Kaison wrote:Ok, nevermind. This site is easy enough to find all your games played here.
VOTE: House
You should know better than to pressure for information because "more information helps town."
↑ Dechs Kaison wrote:I recently played a game where someone came forward with a day one claim similar to that. I was suspicious of him from the very start, but somebody called his bluff and revealed that he was telling the truth. Doesn't mean you are.
I don't like your claim. It's awfully creative and I'm sure there's some truth to it. There doesn't appear to be any way to verify it. You could be scum making the claim, which is why you throw in the BP part. Day two and three could come by and you're not dying, but that's because scum thinks your bulletproof. You could reveal their raffle prizes if you were scum as well, helping us to trust you. Then we get to the mylo day and you claim they tried to kill you and point to a townie.
Come up with a way to prove your alignment.
Alternatively, I'm willing to give you my points in exchange for your lynch. Scratch my back and I'll scratch yours. You say you've got powers beyond the grave? You can continue to help us and all you need are two more townies who agree with me and offer the same.
↑ eyestott wrote:↑ Dechs Kaison wrote:I recently played a game where someone came forward with a day one claim similar to that. I was suspicious of him from the very start, but somebody called his bluff and revealed that he was telling the truth. Doesn't mean you are.
I don't like your claim. It's awfully creative and I'm sure there's some truth to it. There doesn't appear to be any way to verify it. You could be scum making the claim, which is why you throw in the BP part. Day two and three could come by and you're not dying, but that's because scum thinks your bulletproof. You could reveal their raffle prizes if you were scum as well, helping us to trust you. Then we get to the mylo day and you claim they tried to kill you and point to a townie.
Come up with a way to prove your alignment.
Alternatively, I'm willing to give you my points in exchange for your lynch. Scratch my back and I'll scratch yours. You say you've got powers beyond the grave? You can continue to help us and all you need are two more townies who agree with me and offer the same.
Okay, lets see.
A way I can prove my alignment.
A cop?
A Vigilante could target me, if i knew i was being targeted that night.
Mod: can a living player give points to another player?
↑ House wrote:↑ eyestott wrote:↑ Dechs Kaison wrote:I recently played a game where someone came forward with a day one claim similar to that. I was suspicious of him from the very start, but somebody called his bluff and revealed that he was telling the truth. Doesn't mean you are.
I don't like your claim. It's awfully creative and I'm sure there's some truth to it. There doesn't appear to be any way to verify it. You could be scum making the claim, which is why you throw in the BP part. Day two and three could come by and you're not dying, but that's because scum thinks your bulletproof. You could reveal their raffle prizes if you were scum as well, helping us to trust you. Then we get to the mylo day and you claim they tried to kill you and point to a townie.
Come up with a way to prove your alignment.
Alternatively, I'm willing to give you my points in exchange for your lynch. Scratch my back and I'll scratch yours. You say you've got powers beyond the grave? You can continue to help us and all you need are two more townies who agree with me and offer the same.
Okay, lets see.
A way I can prove my alignment.
A cop?
A Vigilante could target me, if i knew i was being targeted that night.
Mod: can a living player give points to another player?
3P can be investigative immune. It's common, actually.
3P can be bulletproof. It's common, actually.
I'm not questioning the 3P part of your claim so much as all the other stuff you piled on top of it.
↑ eyestott wrote:↑ House wrote:↑ eyestott wrote:↑ Dechs Kaison wrote:I recently played a game where someone came forward with a day one claim similar to that. I was suspicious of him from the very start, but somebody called his bluff and revealed that he was telling the truth. Doesn't mean you are.
I don't like your claim. It's awfully creative and I'm sure there's some truth to it. There doesn't appear to be any way to verify it. You could be scum making the claim, which is why you throw in the BP part. Day two and three could come by and you're not dying, but that's because scum thinks your bulletproof. You could reveal their raffle prizes if you were scum as well, helping us to trust you. Then we get to the mylo day and you claim they tried to kill you and point to a townie.
Come up with a way to prove your alignment.
Alternatively, I'm willing to give you my points in exchange for your lynch. Scratch my back and I'll scratch yours. You say you've got powers beyond the grave? You can continue to help us and all you need are two more townies who agree with me and offer the same.
Okay, lets see.
A way I can prove my alignment.
A cop?
A Vigilante could target me, if i knew i was being targeted that night.
Mod: can a living player give points to another player?
3P can be investigative immune. It's common, actually.
3P can be bulletproof. It's common, actually.
I'm not questioning the 3P part of your claim so much as all the other stuff you piled on top of it.
So, you think i'm more malignant than I have said?
↑ Dechs Kaison wrote:That you didn't also vote is actually another point for you being scum.
You're prodding him to reveal the information because "more information helps town." Not only are you proposing something that could help the scum team when you should know better, you're doing it without committing to anything. Your post is only there to make you look more like a town player. You don't want to vote him because a third party isn't someone you have to get rid of to win the game.
↑ House wrote:↑ Dechs Kaison wrote:That you didn't also vote is actually another point for you being scum.
You're prodding him to reveal the information because "more information helps town." Not only are you proposing something that could help the scum team when you should know better, you're doing it without committing to anything. Your post is only there to make you look more like a town player. You don't want to vote him because a third party isn't someone you have to get rid of to win the game.
You're stupid or scum, because putting a vote on eyestott when I haven't even made my mind up on him would be idiotic.
Let me know which one so I can decide on whether I should move my vote or not.
↑ eyestott wrote:Also, if, upon investigation by a cop who gets results in the form of town/mafia/3P, i show as 3P, thatll mean I am telling the truth about my alignment..
Now, as for who ill neighborise: Probably my strongest townread. Town are less likely to lie than mafia.
Also, as a way to prove that I can "rig" a raffle, the winning ticket for neighboriser is 15.
↑ Dechs Kaison wrote:↑ House wrote:↑ Dechs Kaison wrote:That you didn't also vote is actually another point for you being scum.
You're prodding him to reveal the information because "more information helps town." Not only are you proposing something that could help the scum team when you should know better, you're doing it without committing to anything. Your post is only there to make you look more like a town player. You don't want to vote him because a third party isn't someone you have to get rid of to win the game.
You're stupid or scum, because putting a vote on eyestott when I haven't even made my mind up on him would be idiotic.
Let me know which one so I can decide on whether I should move my vote or not.
"House, your posts read scum to me."
"You're stupid or scum."
I can't believe you're making it this easy.
↑ House wrote:↑ Dechs Kaison wrote:↑ House wrote:↑ Dechs Kaison wrote:That you didn't also vote is actually another point for you being scum.
You're prodding him to reveal the information because "more information helps town." Not only are you proposing something that could help the scum team when you should know better, you're doing it without committing to anything. Your post is only there to make you look more like a town player. You don't want to vote him because a third party isn't someone you have to get rid of to win the game.
You're stupid or scum, because putting a vote on eyestott when I haven't even made my mind up on him would be idiotic.
Let me know which one so I can decide on whether I should move my vote or not.
"House, your posts read scum to me."
"You're stupid or scum."
I can't believe you're making it this easy.
I'll make it easier.
VOTE: Dechs Kaison
Have some OMGUS, since you want to twist my post andcompletely leave out the part where I invalidate your reasoninginstead of do the rational thing and /unvote.
↑ Dechs Kaison wrote:↑ House wrote:↑ Dechs Kaison wrote:↑ House wrote:↑ Dechs Kaison wrote:That you didn't also vote is actually another point for you being scum.
You're prodding him to reveal the information because "more information helps town." Not only are you proposing something that could help the scum team when you should know better, you're doing it without committing to anything. Your post is only there to make you look more like a town player. You don't want to vote him because a third party isn't someone you have to get rid of to win the game.
You're stupid or scum, because putting a vote on eyestott when I haven't even made my mind up on him would be idiotic.
Let me know which one so I can decide on whether I should move my vote or not.
"House, your posts read scum to me."
"You're stupid or scum."
I can't believe you're making it this easy.
I'll make it easier.
VOTE: Dechs Kaison
Have some OMGUS, since you want to twist my post andcompletely leave out the part where I invalidate your reasoninginstead of do the rational thing and /unvote.
I didn't leave anything out, I clearly quoted you in your entirety. Let's add flat out lies to your repertoire.
You also didn't invalidate anything. You posted no reasons for anything. "I wouldn't do this because it's idiotic." That's not reason. That's flippant. That's weak.
↑ Dechs Kaison wrote:↑ House wrote:↑ Dechs Kaison wrote:↑ House wrote:↑ Dechs Kaison wrote:That you didn't also vote is actually another point for you being scum.
You're prodding him to reveal the information because "more information helps town." Not only are you proposing something that could help the scum team when you should know better, you're doing it without committing to anything. Your post is only there to make you look more like a town player. You don't want to vote him because a third party isn't someone you have to get rid of to win the game.
You're stupid or scum, because putting a vote on eyestott when I haven't even made my mind up on him would be idiotic.
Let me know which one so I can decide on whether I should move my vote or not.
"House, your posts read scum to me."
"You're stupid or scum."
I can't believe you're making it this easy.
I'll make it easier.
VOTE: Dechs Kaison
Have some OMGUS, since you want to twist my post andcompletely leave out the part where I invalidate your reasoninginstead of do the rational thing and /unvote.
I didn't leave anything out, I clearly quoted you in your entirety.