Micro 596: Longnight Mafia [GAME OVER]

[Postie]

I messed up, it isn't anti-Town but it wouldn't come from a Town mindset IMO. Town would want to try and be productive, whether that means ED1 casing or asking questions. Panther did the latter but it has no relevance on the game so I can't really credit him with it. Meanwhile, Mafia would to look productive without really doing much. Like what PantherPunt did.

Town would want to try and be as productive as possible, but it doesn't always work that way in practice. If you were excited to start a game, and nothing was happening even though people had checked the game thread, wouldn't you be a little bit frustrated with them too? Can you see why that might have caused PantherPunt to ask about them?

[Postie]

suspicion and vote on me forced

What do you make of the fact that this was very early on in the game, and partly an RVS vote?

then flipflopping on whether it was a playstyle clash that he was just commenting on to "get discussion going" or he felt I was actually anti-town/scummy for it. (still don't know where he stands atm)

What do you think makes this scummy?

made a potential perspective-slip

I didn't catch this. Can you point it out to me?

worried about my read on him vs my read on trollie; it's a self-concious mindset that I more typically see come from scum. (or newbs, but N/A here)

I mean I know he's not a

complete

newb, but do you not think the rest of his content feels newbish too? What makes you think he wouldn't be self-conscious as town?

[TheTrollie]

you three are bonkers

[Postie]

Probably. I'm just trying to figure out if this is TvT or not. If one of those two is scum, it's probably PP. I'm getting newbtown vibes from TiMU and PP seems to be blowing a lot of TiMU's stuff out of proportion and making the kind of arguments I can only see coming from town if they're confbiased, which he might be, but idk, seems a bit early.

I know you're V/LA, but do you have anything to contribute? It'd be good to get some more content from you seeing as everyone else hasn't shown up yet.

[TheTrollie]

yes,

you and TiMU are town
PP is scum

That is what I have to contribute. no one else has posted yet....

[Postie]

Oh. I was hoping you'd be able to go into more detail on reasoning and stuff.

[Postie]

Tell me how you got a probtown read on either of them, please, trollie

townvibes bro

TIMU for voting

which at first seemed stupid but he's right

Postie for her inquisition

So you think my post asking why those other two didn't post is alignment indicative too? I'm assuming so since you called TIMU "right"? TIMU has since doubled back and softy implied it's not scummy but just a playstyle difference. You sticking with calling it scummy or do you want to sheep him back to null like you sheeped the scum read?

And Postie for the inquisition. Are you referring to the hypothetical RVS inquisition or the two questions to TIMU that were a essentially identical to my questions?

Wanna answer PP's questions while you're here?

[TheTrollie]

TIMU is being too reckless for scum

PP is calculated but says some off things

You are town-mediating their argument

p-edit: my scumread of PP has nothing to do with the post about lurking

[Postie]

TIMU is being too reckless for scum

Can you tell me more about this? Have you played with scum-TiMU before?

[TheTrollie]

no i havent

[Killthestory]

ego

[Postie]

no i havent

Then what makes you think he's "too reckless for scum"?

[This is my username]

Scum in general needs to be careful. He doesn't need to base his case just on my scumplay.

[Ranger]

Yo.

I don't think I need to announce it since this is gonna be pretty universal, but just in case, should say:

V/LA over this weekend

, due to Easter.

[Ranger]

{This is my username}
{Postie, TheTrollie}
{PantherPunt}

This is the part where I'd vote PantherPunt if I were in his group, but I'm not.

[Ranger]

{This is my username}
{TheTrollie}
{Postie}
{PantherPunt}

Off of 2.

[Ranger]

{This is my username}
{TheTrollie}
{Postie}
{Killthestory}
{Rhaegar}
{PantherPunt}

I need someone from my group other than me to post before I can finish my list.

[Ranger]

Actually,
{This is my username}
{TheTrollie, Postie}
{Rhaegar}
{Killthestory}
{PantherPunt}

This is more accurate.

[PantherPunt]

TIMU is being too reckless for scum

PP is calculated but says some off things

You are town-mediating their argument

p-edit: my scumread of PP has nothing to do with the post about lurking

The ole too scummy to be scum argument? That's how you're justifying a townread on TIMU?

I'd love it if you could cite where I'm saying "off" things. Anyone can give a scumread and say "he said scummy things" or "he said off things", it's lazy and scummy and a cop out. Point to something and justify yourself. Otherwise you're just saying words without logic.

[PantherPunt]

p-edit: my scumread of PP has nothing to do with the post about lurking

[/u]
You made a scum read on me in post 27. If that had nothing to do with the post about lurking, please tell me EXACTLY what on the first page incited a scum read. Thanks

[PantherPunt]

Actually,
{This is my username}
{TheTrollie, Postie}
{Rhaegar}
{Killthestory}
{PantherPunt}

This is more accurate.

Have you seriously constructed a read list that includes a 0-poster and someone who has only ego-posted?
Or is this not a T>S read list and instead something else?

[Ranger]

Have you seriously constructed a read list that includes a 0-poster and someone who has only ego-posted?
Or is this not a T>S read list and instead something else?

Guess.

[Postie]

The ole too scummy to be scum argument? That's how you're justifying a townread on TIMU?

That's... not really what he said.

[This is my username]

Actually,
{This is my username}
{TheTrollie, Postie}
{Rhaegar}
{Killthestory}
{PantherPunt}

This is more accurate.

Have you seriously constructed a read list that includes a 0-poster and someone who has only ego-posted?
Or is this not a T>S read list and instead something else?

Why do you paint everyone who's suspicious of you as scummy?

[PantherPunt]

Actually,
{This is my username}
{TheTrollie, Postie}
{Rhaegar}
{Killthestory}
{PantherPunt}

This is more accurate.

Have you seriously constructed a read list that includes a 0-poster and someone who has only ego-posted?
Or is this not a T>S read list and instead something else?

Why do you paint everyone who's suspicious of you as scummy?

Questioning =\= scum-read. but you're putting words in my mouth again.
Do you have a problem with me asking about it?