Mafiascum.net

In post 48, CheekyTeeky wrote:Ok I get ya, can we give him room to play around his claim though? I don't want to narrow focus on Eddie and his claim right now. Things will become more apparent.

Agree with this

I apologize. You weren't asking what I thought you were, so the amended answer is because there are more town than scum, so AliPine hydra has a higher chance to be town than scum, and that's as good a reason as any for me to townread them this early.

In post 46, Lady Lambdadelta wrote:So in my mind, it's like, there's a lot of scum motivation to claim that role.

I would agree with this. If it helps, I've never faked miller or ascetic as scum in my history (and I've played with almost everyone in this playerlist) but that's mostly irrelevant because I think we both agree I'm not lying about my role. I can tell you why I told KTS we should claim if you'd like. He didn't really comment, just said sure.

LLD youre chasing a tinfoil here
Occam says that he just got that role as town and deemed it wise to inform us about what happens if we lynch him

@That person Did you receive my message? You know who you are.

Indeed

In post 53, Wisdom wrote:LLD youre chasing a tinfoil here
Occam says that he just got that role as town and deemed it wise to inform us about what happens if we lynch him

mmm.... fine.

Besides, scum won't kill them and if .

Because I just realized that if we give the same rope leeway to him as we do to millers (you're lynched the day before LyLo, you can extend this date by helping us lynch scum) then we will be fine because we can always assume that we're in lylo and that's .

Ok, if I could move my vote, I would.

Vig shouldn't shoot me anyways. Scum can if they want.

In post 57, MOMOMEN wrote:Vig shouldn't shoot me anyways. Scum can if they want.

yeah that's the idea.

mastina, what're your thoughts on Nico? I'm not sure how I feel yet, and frankly yours is the read I'd trust the most.

I don't see any scum motivation whatsoever to Momomen claiming that role. If I'd been issued it, I'd have shut up and essentially flipped Town off from the grave.

So it's either a fakeclaim or Town truth.

LLD's plan to treat it as a Miller claim works for me.

Pine

Oh, and talk to me, not KTS for the next couple IRL days. He's gonna be following but he's not posting.

Yawn.

Sorry for making you waste your vote LLD.

I have a weird kinship to Mastina this game and I don't like her being voted before even posting

In post 59, Sudowoodo wrote:mastina, what're your thoughts on Nico? I'm not sure how I feel yet, and frankly yours is the read I'd trust the most.

I don't see any scum motivation whatsoever to Momomen claiming that role. If I'd been issued it, I'd have shut up and essentially flipped Town off from the grave.

So it's either a fakeclaim or Town truth.

LLD's plan to treat it as a Miller claim works for me.

Pine

Did you receive my message? Yes or no?

Obviously.

Hush now.

Nico, did you message me too?

k, thanks.

@Momo Unfortunately, my message was a 1-shot.

Nico, I'd actually prefer if you didn't answer any more questions for a little while.

Trust me here.

But no seriously, I am gonna operate on the assumption you're 100% town up until the point we reach a day where it's the day BEFORE lylo.

We have 13 players, I assume 3 scum, so that would be when there are 9 players alive assuming no shenanigans and that we don't lynch any scum before then. If we lynch more scum, the day gets pushed back.

I will be vote parking you that day, but assume you're town completely otherwise prior, does that make sense?

Cool with that.

@Sudowoodo k, I won't.

In post 68, Eddie Cane wrote:Cool with that.

Anyways, topic starters!

Any benefit to mass flavour claiming rn? Any risk?

Eh, the standard. Scum have a better chance at guessing PRs if they know the flavor

In post 70, MOMOMEN wrote:

In post 68, Eddie Cane wrote:Cool with that.

Anyways, topic starters!

Any benefit to mass flavour claiming rn? Any risk?

It's not a Vi game, but there's always the risk for there to be a player who interacts with knowing the flavour identity of a person.

Beyond that, given I believe the role abilities are flavour tied to the character selected, it gives town potential to guess and narrow their shots a bit better.

So I'm against it. The only positive is that it locks people down into claims now, because they can't claim something that wouldn't fit their character, but I suspect the scum will be given safeclaim stuff to avoid this?

so yeah, Against, currently.

In post 71, Wisdom wrote:Eh, the standard. Scum have a better chance at guessing PRs if they know the flavor

what he said

dibs