Mafiascum.net

In post 13, ceejayvinoya wrote:

In post 10, awestfie wrote:VOTE: awestfie

Uh wtf is this

This reaction is really bad. What made you "question" the RVS self-vote here?

i thought it was a pretty reasonable reaction

you know what would be super funny
if S_S rolled scum for the 3rd time in a row in boon games

In post 50, RAS wrote:

In post 13, ceejayvinoya wrote:

In post 10, awestfie wrote:VOTE: awestfie

Uh wtf is this

This reaction is really bad. What made you "question" the RVS self-vote here?

What's fucking with my head right now is why no one is questioning it.

Is this normal rvs behavior for a large theme game?

It doesn't strike me as scummy, hence I didn't vote, but it's very anti town.

In post 53, ceejayvinoya wrote:

In post 50, RAS wrote:

In post 13, ceejayvinoya wrote:

In post 10, awestfie wrote:VOTE: awestfie

Uh wtf is this

This reaction is really bad. What made you "question" the RVS self-vote here?

What's fucking with my head right now is why no one is questioning it.

Is this normal rvs behavior for a large theme game?

It doesn't strike me as scummy, hence I didn't vote, but it's very anti town.

I can't speak for the RVS behavior comment since I'm unfamiliar with large games, however, the RVS self-vote gave me town vibes. I saw it as a way to fish out reactions from players, and an attempt to get us out of the RVS as soon as possible. The reason why I got town vibes from it is that I thought it would give us better reactions than your typical random vote. There's no other reason that I can see why she would self-vote in that situation. Her vote in Post 49 only reinforces what I said regarding fishing out a reaction.

In post 52, XtoxicNim wrote:you know what would be super funny
if S_S rolled scum for the 3rd time in a row in boon games

VOTE: Something_Smart - just in case.

In post 13, ceejayvinoya wrote:

In post 10, awestfie wrote:VOTE: awestfie

Uh wtf is this

The question you should really be asking is wtf is





Distant stare? Tilted head look? Cigarette hanging out? Coincidence? I think not...

In post 50, RAS wrote:

In post 13, ceejayvinoya wrote:

In post 10, awestfie wrote:VOTE: awestfie

Uh wtf is this

This reaction is really bad. What made you "question" the RVS self-vote here?

more like why wouldn't you question a self vote

why would you be ok with someone self voting

In post 58, Sheldon Cooper PhD wrote:

In post 50, RAS wrote:

In post 13, ceejayvinoya wrote:

In post 10, awestfie wrote:VOTE: awestfie

Uh wtf is this

This reaction is really bad. What made you "question" the RVS self-vote here?

more like why wouldn't you question a self vote

why would you be ok with someone self voting

This seems like a weird response to me considering you never questioned it yourself, nor did you ever point out how it wasn't okay until just now. I never said I was okay with someone self-voting, but this is way different than your regular self-vote considering it's a self-vote on Page 1 and is very clearly a vote to gather reactions.

You're almost treating this as a late-day/game self-vote as opposed to what it is with the way you worded things. The vote isn't as important as some of you are making it out to be.

I generally don't really read RVS naked votes because what's the point
I only noticed that self vote happened because someone quoted it later
Gotta talk about something to get out of RVS - I think given awestfie went directly onto ceejay with her vote, it was kinda planned...Do you think awestfie believes the reaction test is a good scum catching mechanism or do you think awestfie just wanted a reason to lay down any old vote, ie manufacturing a reason, or maybe it's just some way to get the first wagon of the day going

thoughts?

In post 60, Sheldon Cooper PhD wrote:I generally don't really read RVS naked votes because what's the point
I only noticed that self vote happened because someone quoted it later
Gotta talk about something to get out of RVS - I think given awestfie went directly onto ceejay with her vote, it was kinda planned...Do you think awestfie believes the reaction test is a good scum catching mechanism or do you think awestfie just wanted a reason to lay down any old vote, ie manufacturing a reason, or maybe it's just some way to get the first wagon of the day going

thoughts?

I can't speak as to why she voted ceejay, but my guess is because of she believed that the reaction was poor (as I did). I'm sure awestfie will respond to this soon enough considering just how much discussion there is around her actions, however, I believe that the action of self-voting was done because of either:

– She wanted to get reactions, and to get out of the RVS as soon as possible. If this was her goal, I would say this was a success considering how much discussion has been done around that one post alone.

– She wanted to get reactions, and to pressure whoever reacted badly to her vote. It's possible she uses it as a way to catch scum, however it seems like a really weak way to do so.

One could argue the self-vote itself was just a joke, and it might be a possibility, however, given awestfie's vote in Post 49, I don't think this is the case.

awestfie hasn't played in years, but I went back and read through some of her games to see her actions during the RVS to see if I could notice any type of pattern, and she seems like the type of player who nearly never participates in RVS.

Here's what I collected from her previous games:



TL;DR: She has 6 games with no RVS, 1 game with RVS and 1 game that could be argued either or. I think it's fair to assume that the self-vote here was to draw a reaction, and I also think it's very fair to assume that she wanted to get out of the RVS as soon as possible given her previous comments in games.

In post 46, UnaBombaH wrote:Only a couple of players I haven't played with in this game, so I think I'm gonna do well.

Also, because everyone else is already doing these kinds of gimmicks: I'm a "non-consecutive night Commuter".

I'll probably start commuting tonight as to avoid dying N1 as I'm a huge threat to scum, and then claim D2 that I didn't actually commute N1 to get myself to D3 because scum are afraid to miss a nightkill N2, only to realize that I really DID start commuting N1 meaning that I'll also commute N3 meaning that they can't kill me then either....

All hail the unkillable god UnaBombah! \o/

Also isn't that the role Mulch had in the danganronpa alt trainwreck game (and I was ascetic in that one too! )

-smart

In post 52, XtoxicNim wrote:you know what would be super funny
if S_S rolled scum for the 3rd time in a row in boon games

No that would actually be tragic, especially since poor Baezu would be dragged into my curse...

...but fortunately it didn't happen

-smart

-Can you prod Xtoxm

So out of curiosity- is it normal to """mass-claim""" early on in BooneyTunes?
Damn, I have to think about whether I buy any of this.

@The guys talking about the self-vote talk and filler- it's NAI.
RAS gets town points for the RVS analysis.

@NC- still disliking the Sheldon character?

In post 65, Vorkuta wrote:@NC- still disliking the Sheldon character?

What's the point of this question?

I have 9 town reads.

In post 12, Nero Cain wrote:lets pl the stupid gimmick alt.

Still valid or have you reconsidered?

In post 65, Vorkuta wrote:So out of curiosity- is it normal to """mass-claim""" early on in BooneyTunes?

Claiming negative utility roles is a sitewide thing. una's claim is just a troll.

In post 68, Vorkuta wrote:

In post 12, Nero Cain wrote:lets pl the stupid gimmick alt.

Still valid or have you reconsidered?

Has my vote switched, no but why are you overly concerned with why I want the slot dead?

In post 69, Nero Cain wrote:una's claim is just a troll.

I... believe... one of you?

In post 70, Nero Cain wrote:why are you overly concerned

Quick and easy low-hanging-fruit mislynch?
Your PL vote would be valid if he were making Bazinga posts every post, but I see a normal player with his self-vote analysis.

Maybe that's why he's scum? Like he's intentionally not playing to his gimmick alt b/c if he did it would be extremely grating and everyone would want him dead.