Posted: Wed Jun 02, 2021 5:02 am
Thank you Not_Mafia for the $100 bribe I just checked my paypal
Page 3 of 173
Posted: Wed Jun 02, 2021 6:26 am
ego
Posted: Wed Jun 02, 2021 8:34 am
In post 12, Not_Mafia wrote:You can treeust in me
Posted: Wed Jun 02, 2021 8:36 am
I'm 100% picking bodyguard if I'm stumpIn post 36, House wrote:A role.In post 31, NorwegianboyEE wrote:Apparently the stump needs to come up with town power roles too? Should we discuss that now?
I'm thinking either weak hider or bulletproof.
Weak Hider is better than cop, but a little trickier to play.
Bulletproof is usually a scummy claim to make, but if claimed on D1 in an open game it gives us confirmed town that mafia can't touch.
up to you to tell if this is serious
Posted: Wed Jun 02, 2021 9:04 am
Yes.
Posted: Wed Jun 02, 2021 9:07 am
In post 40, Titus wrote:Exclude myself as stump. I've been both a town and scum stump before. Let someone else have a turn.
Titus is no longer a valid tree stump selection.
Posted: Wed Jun 02, 2021 9:12 am
ego
Posted: Wed Jun 02, 2021 9:13 am
i'd believe you gamma
~ vex
~ vex
Posted: Wed Jun 02, 2021 10:31 am
In post 46, Nancy Drew 39 wrote:disloyal vigilante or loya neighbourizing masons?
Clarification, because I've had multiple people ask:
The criteria for a Stump's submission require that a submission be a single valid role to be put in a Normal game of mafia. As such, disloyal vigilante, loyal neighborizing mason (Although this role would add a player to a separate neighborhood, not the masonry they were part of), and full bulletproof are all equally valid submissions.
A role that is normal like but belongs to two players (a masonry with a shared vig shot, for example) is not a single normal role and is thus not an eligible submission.
You could also choose to submit something monstrous, like, for example loyal combined rolestopper-hider-cop-neighborizer, in which case I would probably use my right of refusal per the rules and veto the selection, resulting in a VT.
The 1 Shot ability activated by the sacrifice of a Treestump and any Mafia roles added to the game for balance are NOT required to be normal roles, but will not be bastard. That means, among other things, there will be no Janitors, cultists, Sauluses, Framers, Tailors, Lawyers, etc. Godfather is specifically possible, but unlikely, due to my dislike of that role. I will not be using any serious mafia mutations mechanics wise, so there will be no roles like Mafia Hero, Arsonist or Mafia Kingmaker.
Basically, the stronger the town roles you choose, the more design space you give me to work with for the scum team.
A full list of Normal Roles and Modifiers you may use can be found on the wiki.
The criteria for a Stump's submission require that a submission be a single valid role to be put in a Normal game of mafia. As such, disloyal vigilante, loyal neighborizing mason (Although this role would add a player to a separate neighborhood, not the masonry they were part of), and full bulletproof are all equally valid submissions.
A role that is normal like but belongs to two players (a masonry with a shared vig shot, for example) is not a single normal role and is thus not an eligible submission.
You could also choose to submit something monstrous, like, for example loyal combined rolestopper-hider-cop-neighborizer, in which case I would probably use my right of refusal per the rules and veto the selection, resulting in a VT.
The 1 Shot ability activated by the sacrifice of a Treestump and any Mafia roles added to the game for balance are NOT required to be normal roles, but will not be bastard. That means, among other things, there will be no Janitors, cultists, Sauluses, Framers, Tailors, Lawyers, etc. Godfather is specifically possible, but unlikely, due to my dislike of that role. I will not be using any serious mafia mutations mechanics wise, so there will be no roles like Mafia Hero, Arsonist or Mafia Kingmaker.
Basically, the stronger the town roles you choose, the more design space you give me to work with for the scum team.
A full list of Normal Roles and Modifiers you may use can be found on the wiki.
Posted: Wed Jun 02, 2021 10:49 am
These Boots Were Made For Stumping
Posted: Wed Jun 02, 2021 11:05 am
I feel like Nancy Koba hydra could be a pretty good stump. So if they want to be i’d vote for them maybe.
Posted: Wed Jun 02, 2021 11:05 am
And you also get two for the price of one.
Posted: Wed Jun 02, 2021 11:07 am
VOTE: Not Known 15
I am a good selection for treestump. People frequently suspect me - probably because my play as Mafia is not that different from my play as town...
I can ask difficult questions and if they come from confirmed town they won't get shot down as "scummy". I, however, can also let the game develop without interfering in everything(so that it is more difficult for people to pocket me). I will not pressure everyone to vote my prefered selection - except maybe at the final one - because that will cause the game to go into inactivity.
Now, to the roles...
I will not submit Masons, ever. Mason is the worst possible pick:Masons will have TMI just like scum, and that is the reason why they are TERRIBLE. They dilute reads and allow(if made public, atrocious) Mafia to masonhunt by simply mafiahunting, obscuring everything but TMI until the Masons claim.
But what else I pick... that's up to me; I have a nice idea but it would be a bad idea to publicize it.
I am a good selection for treestump. People frequently suspect me - probably because my play as Mafia is not that different from my play as town...
I can ask difficult questions and if they come from confirmed town they won't get shot down as "scummy". I, however, can also let the game develop without interfering in everything(so that it is more difficult for people to pocket me). I will not pressure everyone to vote my prefered selection - except maybe at the final one - because that will cause the game to go into inactivity.
Now, to the roles...
I will not submit Masons, ever. Mason is the worst possible pick:Masons will have TMI just like scum, and that is the reason why they are TERRIBLE. They dilute reads and allow(if made public, atrocious) Mafia to masonhunt by simply mafiahunting, obscuring everything but TMI until the Masons claim.
But what else I pick... that's up to me; I have a nice idea but it would be a bad idea to publicize it.
Posted: Wed Jun 02, 2021 11:15 am
You're my second pick.In post 5, NorwegianboyEE wrote:But i can be much more funny.
Posted: Wed Jun 02, 2021 11:20 am
yeah masons would probably just muddy things up
but idk if I particularly care for NK15 being a stump just yet
VOTE: Not_Mafia for the first stump btw
but idk if I particularly care for NK15 being a stump just yet
VOTE: Not_Mafia for the first stump btw
Posted: Wed Jun 02, 2021 11:27 am
Announcement: I have altered the rules. Pray I do not alter them further. The following rule has been added to the Game Specific Rules section of the ruleset. It is largely irrelevant, but I am obliged to inform you of this alteration due to an implicit social contract that my behavior as a mod not impact your Game Experience.
Posted: Wed Jun 02, 2021 11:28 am
VOTE: nm
just so we don't have to deal with them as not-confirmed town
~ vex
just so we don't have to deal with them as not-confirmed town
~ vex
Posted: Wed Jun 02, 2021 11:29 am
I promise to be the stumpiest stump to ever stump
Posted: Wed Jun 02, 2021 11:56 am
How many people pay as much as i?In post 49, Not_Mafia wrote:You all need to step up your game activity-wise, make me a stump as an active contributor
Posted: Wed Jun 02, 2021 11:57 am
i'm of the opinion that townstumps are better used as people we want bulletproof rather than some kind of pre-emptive investigation, or choice for people we think will be hard to sort. i feel as though using it that way is more akin to choosing someone to just remove from the game rather than choosing a voice we want around for the entire game
Posted: Wed Jun 02, 2021 12:03 pm
blah blah blah stump meIn post 69, northsidegal wrote:i'm of the opinion that townstumps are better used as people we want bulletproof rather than some kind of pre-emptive investigation, or choice for people we think will be hard to sort. i feel as though using it that way is more akin to choosing someone to just remove from the game rather than choosing a voice we want around for the entire game
Posted: Wed Jun 02, 2021 12:03 pm
the best point for making NM the stump is no quickhammers
Posted: Wed Jun 02, 2021 12:05 pm
Except that having me around for the entire game is a good idea as long as people have trust in my towniness. You basically get two for one.In post 69, northsidegal wrote:i'm of the opinion that townstumps are better used as people we want bulletproof rather than some kind of pre-emptive investigation, or choice for people we think will be hard to sort. i feel as though using it that way is more akin to choosing someone to just remove from the game rather than choosing a voice we want around for the entire game
Posted: Wed Jun 02, 2021 12:55 pm
I'd have to disagree here. I think making someone like NM, who nobody is gonna really have a good time sorting is perfectly valid.In post 69, northsidegal wrote:i'm of the opinion that townstumps are better used as people we want bulletproof rather than some kind of pre-emptive investigation, or choice for people we think will be hard to sort. i feel as though using it that way is more akin to choosing someone to just remove from the game rather than choosing a voice we want around for the entire game
Plus I know NM is a good player, so making them a stump would force them to have to actually play more or less, since we'd be expecting on them to lead town a bit.
~ Kori
Posted: Wed Jun 02, 2021 12:58 pm
Correction: I am not a good player, please don't denigrate my troll credentials like that