Mini 502: Basically Communist Mafia- Game Over. Who won?
Forum rules
- The Fonz
- The Fonz
-
The Fonz
- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 9014
- Joined: April 2, 2007
- Location: UK
OK, whatcha want? I would have thought it obvious why a doc claim benefits town- i'll happily explain why if need be. I really don't see how actively asking for a claim is fishing.JDodge wrote:Still waiting for The Fonz
AS for my scum suspicion, Gorck coming up scum hasn't exactly torpedoed my Gorck-Theo theory.
- JDodge
- JDodge
-
JDodge
- Accept it
- Accept it
- Posts: 5926
- Joined: May 6, 2005
- Location: Atop my cloud
- Contact:
The post you said you would make earlier.The Fonz wrote:OK, whatcha want? I would have thought it obvious why a doc claim benefits town- i'll happily explain why if need be. I really don't see how actively asking for a claim is fishing.JDodge wrote:Still waiting for The Fonz
AS for my scum suspicion, Gorck coming up scum hasn't exactly torpedoed my Gorck-Theo theory.
- Adel
- Adel
-
Adel
- Crystalline Logick
- Crystalline Logick
- Posts: 6743
- Joined: May 23, 2007
- Location: Central Oregon / High Desert
are you a ring thumper then, or the son of a ring thumper?The Fonz wrote:Post postponed due to Navy beating Notre Dame for the first time in over forty years.
GO MIDS!!!
reading thread.
kindly give me 72 hours to type something coherent.
- Adel
- Adel
-
Adel
- Crystalline Logick
- Crystalline Logick
- Posts: 6743
- Joined: May 23, 2007
- Location: Central Oregon / High Desert
Starting from the beginning, I see that:
Alive:
Dead:
I'm assuming that there is 3 Mafia Goons. with 1 possibly being a Godfather, and 1 SK.
So we know that Kate was a goon. looking through her posts:
~Random Vote:Rhakith
~interaction with Jack (mild scumtell against JDodge (replacing Jack) for being conspicuous interaction)
~lists White, the Fonz, and Kilroy as being scummy (mild scumtell against the Fonz for being part of a possible WIFOM trap)
~votes White in post where she quotes the bussing vote from gorcat.
~dies by lynching
we also know that SilverPhoenix was a goon. looking through his posts:
~ a random vote
then gorcat replaces SilverPhoenix:
~conspicuous interaction with the Fonz and pdcakes and Nocmen. conspisuous lack of interaction with JDodge
ok, so I don't get much out of that.
reading through Jacks posts:
~votes Kate
~leaves the Kate wagon to vote Max- acts convinced that Max is scum
reading through JDodge's posts:
~agrees with Kate, votes White (mild scumtell)
~revotes White the next day "Although Kate's alignment is a shocker, I still think White is scum. The way he went after her seems unnatural. Kilroy-town is fairly surprising as well." significant scum tell: Kate was scum, the other two were town
~votes Jennar
~ Vote: Nocmen
~Unvote, vote: pdcakes
~Unvote, vote: gorckat
~/not cop
~Vote: The Fonz
conclusion: kinda scummy
reading through Qman's posts:
~nothing
reading through Nocmen's posts:
~votes Kate
~votes white
~votes jennar
~ "I'm not a cop, and some of pdcakes actions make sense to me now."
the Fonz:
~votes kate
~votes gorcat
~flipflops on if cop should claim
~doesn;t post much, and doesn't say much when he does post. a major scumtell in my book
pdcakes:
~doesn't get replaced... a mild scumtell, all things considered
~votes White, and then unvotes
~votes the Fonz
conclusion: didn't vote for kate or gorcat. major scumtell
i've played with theopor-OCD before, I know his alignment was townie in this game, so since I trust his abilities i'm going to trust his judgement:
~"Jack and Undo look townish. Or at least make sense in my mind. "
~"Don't like pdcakes especially 68. "
~"pdcakes 209 is horrible. "
~not the cop
ok, so I'm not the cop, Nocmen is not a cop, and JDodge is not the cop.
did anyone claim doc or cop? if so, I didn't catch it.
I support a massclaim. I want to claim 3rd.
Alive:
JDodge (replacing Jack)
Nocmen (replacing Qman)
The Fonz (replaced Snow pregame)
pdcakes
Adel (replacing theopor_COD (replacing Rhakith)
Nocmen (replacing Qman)
The Fonz (replaced Snow pregame)
pdcakes
Adel (replacing theopor_COD (replacing Rhakith)
Dead:
Kate, mafia goon, Lynched day one
gorckat (replacing SilverPhoenix), mafia goon, stabbed night three
I'm assuming that there is 3 Mafia Goons. with 1 possibly being a Godfather, and 1 SK.
So we know that Kate was a goon. looking through her posts:
~Random Vote:Rhakith
~interaction with Jack (mild scumtell against JDodge (replacing Jack) for being conspicuous interaction)
~lists White, the Fonz, and Kilroy as being scummy (mild scumtell against the Fonz for being part of a possible WIFOM trap)
~votes White in post where she quotes the bussing vote from gorcat.
~dies by lynching
we also know that SilverPhoenix was a goon. looking through his posts:
~ a random vote
then gorcat replaces SilverPhoenix:
~conspicuous interaction with the Fonz and pdcakes and Nocmen. conspisuous lack of interaction with JDodge
ok, so I don't get much out of that.
reading through Jacks posts:
~votes Kate
~leaves the Kate wagon to vote Max- acts convinced that Max is scum
reading through JDodge's posts:
~agrees with Kate, votes White (mild scumtell)
~revotes White the next day "Although Kate's alignment is a shocker, I still think White is scum. The way he went after her seems unnatural. Kilroy-town is fairly surprising as well." significant scum tell: Kate was scum, the other two were town
~votes Jennar
~ Vote: Nocmen
~Unvote, vote: pdcakes
~Unvote, vote: gorckat
~/not cop
~Vote: The Fonz
conclusion: kinda scummy
reading through Qman's posts:
~nothing
reading through Nocmen's posts:
~votes Kate
~votes white
~votes jennar
~ "I'm not a cop, and some of pdcakes actions make sense to me now."
the Fonz:
~votes kate
~votes gorcat
~flipflops on if cop should claim
~doesn;t post much, and doesn't say much when he does post. a major scumtell in my book
pdcakes:
~doesn't get replaced... a mild scumtell, all things considered
~votes White, and then unvotes
~votes the Fonz
conclusion: didn't vote for kate or gorcat. major scumtell
i've played with theopor-OCD before, I know his alignment was townie in this game, so since I trust his abilities i'm going to trust his judgement:
~"Jack and Undo look townish. Or at least make sense in my mind. "
~"Don't like pdcakes especially 68. "
~"pdcakes 209 is horrible. "
~not the cop
ok, so I'm not the cop, Nocmen is not a cop, and JDodge is not the cop.
did anyone claim doc or cop? if so, I didn't catch it.
I support a massclaim. I want to claim 3rd.
- Adel
- Adel
-
Adel
- Crystalline Logick
- Crystalline Logick
- Posts: 6743
- Joined: May 23, 2007
- Location: Central Oregon / High Desert
I want Nocmen to claim first, followed by JDodge. I would like to clam 3rd, followed by pdcakes and then the Fonz.
i didn't put a whole lot of thought into that order. Debate on how the order should be changed would be illuminating.
i didn't put a whole lot of thought into that order. Debate on how the order should be changed would be illuminating.