In post 494, Hel wrote:Read Menalque's plan again, Titus. We play normally with the only difference being replacing the L-1 and hammer votes with HURT: votes. Once we've "lynched" two people, we let the shipmaster (Not Known 15) decide on who we really lynch of the two.
This is actually preferable to playing normally and accidentally wagoning and driving a lynch on the Tomboy Daughter, because that would be an autoloss then if the shipmaster mysteriously decided to out and veto that lynch suddenly.
Oh, wait, I just realised the Tomboy Daughter could technically claim shipmaster if driven to L-1 and that would be fine too, but it still gives scum a 50/50 on that person if it happens.
I disagree because now NK 15's reads are placed above that of town. What if NK 15 gets agency captured?
This is a common gripe with unkillable town. Scum know exactly where they need to play around.
This same problem made T v A immensely hard for me and I didn't have to force town into wagoning two people at all.
Not Known 15 doesn't need to give out reads. He just gets the final pick of the 2 lynches so we have a fail-safe in case the Daughter is one of them.
Posted: Sat Jul 04, 2020 4:51 am
by Menalque
In post 499, Hel wrote:I think I require enlightenment on this meme. Explanation requested.
It’s commentary on the recent policy change away from using “lynch” on site. It would appear that notscience is backing the terrible “clowned” replacement option, instead of the fantastic “guillotined” replacement.
Posted: Sat Jul 04, 2020 4:51 am
by Menalque
In post 479, Datisi wrote:unless mena and nk15 are scum together and this is an elaborate galaxy brain gambit
Posted: Sat Jul 04, 2020 4:52 am
by NorwegianboyEE
In post 501, Menalque wrote:is backing the terrible “clowned” replacement option,
I was gonna say I’m like 80% on town you and then I was like “hey, that should be 80% above the pure rand chance then right?” and when I worked out the random chance I wasn’t sure what 80% above that would be but I wouldn’t say I’m like 90% sure you’re town so I just went with it
In post 298, Menalque wrote:I’m concerned that there is the attempt to force a townbloc on page 12 with 2 of my scumreads in it
You're not normally this shallow.
@notscience usernames unawareness and anger looks quite real to me and hard to fake with how he handled the situation what pinged you for it?
Side note: Now that it's Kuri does that change anything?
Posted: Sat Jul 04, 2020 5:09 am
by Maki Harukawa
I wish Alisae and Mena would hush for a day. They have 2/5th of the games posts and it's quite annoying to read. Although I am voting Mena so that should help.
The only thing I got from this catchup was my read on Norwe going up to nullish and RR is probably town.
Posted: Sat Jul 04, 2020 5:13 am
by Maki Harukawa
So only three of you know who I am? Interesting given this is a public alt. I don't know how this affects my reads. I'll have to think about it.
Execute Mena
Posted: Sat Jul 04, 2020 5:14 am
by NorwegianboyEE
Ok i just discovered your main by searching your alt name on google. (Spoilers obviously)
Posted: Sat Jul 04, 2020 5:19 am
by FakeGod
Posted: Sat Jul 04, 2020 5:20 am
by Titus
In post 511, Maki Harukawa wrote:So only three of you know who I am? Interesting given this is a public alt. I don't know how this affects my reads. I'll have to think about it.
Execute Mena
I know. I just am sitting on it. Meta is weak anyway. If that factors in at all, you should know that.
Posted: Sat Jul 04, 2020 5:20 am
by Craig Pelton
I’ll probably quieten down when I’m more comfortable with the gamestate, and if I feel like people who I’m scumreading or otherwise uncomfortable aren’t trying to lead the game
I think the approach you’re taking to me is odd, maki
Posted: Sat Jul 04, 2020 5:21 am
by Menalque
In post 515, Craig Pelton wrote:I’ll probably quieten down when I’m more comfortable with the gamestate, and if I feel like people who I’m scumreading or otherwise uncomfortable aren’t trying to lead the game
I think the approach you’re taking to me is odd, maki
fuck
Posted: Sat Jul 04, 2020 5:22 am
by Titus
In post 508, Maki Harukawa wrote:I wish Alisae and Mena would hush for a day. They have 2/5th of the games posts and it's quite annoying to read. Although I am voting Mena so that should help.
I specifically want Ali to comment on the problem I see with NK claiming early and how it screws up town dynamics.
Posted: Sat Jul 04, 2020 5:25 am
by Maki Harukawa
In post 517, Titus wrote:I specifically want Ali to comment on the problem I see with NK claiming early and how it screws up town dynamics.
Do you think it is strongly AI for the answer? Atm I have you/myself/Username/RR/Alisae as strong townreads. Any you disagree on here?
In post 515, Craig Pelton wrote:I’ll probably quieten down when I’m more comfortable with the gamestate, and if I feel like people who I’m scumreading or otherwise uncomfortable aren’t trying to lead the game
I think the approach you’re taking to me is odd, maki
In post 517, Titus wrote:I specifically want Ali to comment on the problem I see with NK claiming early and how it screws up town dynamics.
Do you think it is strongly AI for the answer? Atm I have you/myself/Username/RR/Alisae as strong townreads. Any you disagree on here?
I don't think it's strongly AI unless someone replies with something blatantly false. Town and scum would both be concerned with game health overall and both would agree with the concerns I am raising.
Ftr, I don't believe NK15 felt he was antitown by outing. He wasn't part of T v A and didn't see how someone being conftown and in control of lynches (despite trying not to) impacts the game. The less controlling I was, the better town did. So the dual lynch thing might be the best we have, but it's still a problem.
Posted: Sat Jul 04, 2020 6:08 am
by Titus
In post 518, Maki Harukawa wrote:Atm I have you/myself/Username/RR/Alisae as strong townreads. Any you disagree on here?
I don't see enough from RR to justify including him. I am ok with the others.
Posted: Sat Jul 04, 2020 6:09 am
by notscience
In post 507, Maki Harukawa wrote:@notscience usernames unawareness and anger looks quite real to me and hard to fake with how he handled the situation what pinged you for it?
Side note: Now that it's Kuri does that change anything?
Yes it’s why I unvoted , see my explanation about the thriller movies
What was really him alluding to kuribo I thought was scum grandstanding. But looking back with that new lens it’s obvious my reasons for suspecting him were wrong and the reaction to me felt Genuine.
Posted: Sat Jul 04, 2020 6:51 am
by Umlaut
Well looks like some things happened.
UNVOTE: NK15
Catching up in a bit.
Posted: Sat Jul 04, 2020 7:35 am
by Umlaut
I really hate that claim (that big bold "
Enough
" is really lame) and how NK15 has basically excused himself from playing the game, but I may as well provisionally accept it since it gets confirmed tomorrow anyway.
Scattered thoughts:
I think we all agree Menalque is town.
I've decided Radical Rat is town as well; his gamesolving attempts seem to come from a town place (though also seem a bit like cat-herding; his plan in 460 requires close to unanimous agreement to be workable)
I agree with the arguments that username tone-slipping so quickly is probably a towntell.
notscience' vocal suspicion of the NK claim is weird and pings me
I kind of agree with 493 but given the cat is out of the bag we have to make the best of it.
I think there's a high probability there is at least one smuggler in those who haven't posted since NK15 outed. (Which is six players so that's not a hugely impressive deduction I guess)
