Mafiascum.net

In post 453, VP Baltar wrote:Alice, are you an alt?

In post 500, VP Baltar wrote:

In post 453, VP Baltar wrote:Alice, are you an alt?

In post 499, Datisi wrote:alice, do you have slightly more elaborate opinions on anyone other than innocentvillager

In post 496, VP Baltar wrote:

In post 480, VP Baltar wrote:Anya, can we get some takes on non-GB people

In post 373, geraintm wrote:

In post 366, Wooper wrote:

In post 329, Iconeum wrote:i'll put it this way

if i had a spicey read i wanted to share, i would have done so

In post 331, Wooper wrote:I have a spciey read I don't want to share.

it was a joke Gera, you're getting PURE UNFILTERED WOOPER

i dont believe ive played with you before. can i get the filtered version?

In post 375, Anya wrote:i think people were asking me earlier why George was town

it was this post of his earlier that just made me really sure in his divine towniness:

In post 216, GeorgeBailey wrote:

In post 7, Gypyx wrote:on a more serious note, i'm a town informed, Georgebailey is mafia

Well, to say this is the fastest i've ever been scumread would be a lie. lmao.

In post 42, geraintm wrote:no, i meant my normal way of playing is to sit back and just not move my votes very much, people hate it. i don't plan on being as like that from now on, and see how it goes (i fully expect people to go "Why is geraint so different from usual, lets vote him?")

I mean yeah. The way you describe it, it sounds like you don't actively scum hunt? That's usually my basis for scumreading people. So like.. I look forward to the change!

In post 52, Datisi wrote:whenever someone says that you can't read anyone's alignment for certain on day 1 i have a fucking stroke

Ok ok but it's like 10000000x harder than literally any other day. But I do agree cause that one game with NPOM where he was literally too scummy on the first page opened up my eyes.

In post 67, Datisi wrote:

In post 62, Gypyx wrote:actually hmmmm

given the claim, there's a possibility for it being ico + gera

not really stuff i'd bank on, just higher odds

VOTE: gypyx

In post 70, geraintm wrote:

In post 62, Gypyx wrote:actually hmmmm

given the claim, there's a possibility for it being ico + gera

not really stuff i'd bank on, just higher odds

VOTE: gypyx

Geraint's sheep is kinda... bleh, like Datisi said it was a tonal read, which I don't see but sure. Geraint why did you vote here?

In post 75, Iconeum wrote:based on?

Based

In post 89, geraintm wrote:see, i said at the start i am fed up with always going through the same route in every game - people just dislike my way of playing. this game, i am not going to sit back and let day 1 drift and drift. i plan to get day 1 over and done with as quickly as possible

In post 95, geraintm wrote:i literally don't care what people think now. i hate day ones,

See:

In post 91, Datisi wrote:someone sitting on the sidelines going "boohoo day 1 bad" is killing information and is making people wanna policy you

Also uh,

In post 89, geraintm wrote:I will join the largest wagon at every reasonable opportunity. wonder if you can policy eliminate me for that?

This is what scum does in most games. It's literally the path of least resistance. I really wanna scumread you here but I have a feeling this is townie.

Geraint's day 1 hating posts are interesting so far, It kinda reads like... Newbie posts complaining about the game? I know Geraint is far from a newbie though, so I'm conflicted on it. I think the transparency on this is town. I don't see scum acting in such a way when the usual scum energy is ~~look i'm so calm relaxed and funny haha~~

In post 376, NorwegianboyEE wrote:Are you just being ironic or something?

In post 378, Datisi wrote:lol

In post 380, VP Baltar wrote:

In post 378, Datisi wrote:i feel like he shouldn't be dead null on me still?

Why? You're gonna have to build trust with me after I went easy on you last game. Clearly the things I find town from your playstyle are fakeable, so I think I have every right to be skeptical of my ability there, yeah?

In post 381, VP Baltar wrote:

In post 367, Wooper wrote:

In post 131, Datisi wrote:this is an odd sequence b

if I was on at this point I would have been like "O good catch let's yeet gypux" but alas I missed the fun so you get post-fun edgy wooper

my natural counterpoint is that it's an odd sequence because we are human beings/pokemon and human beings are odd human beings and gypux's flip didn't strike me as scummy because I wouldn't have really expected anyone to feel very attached to feelings from pg. 1-2 of this game! th y were very unexciting pages. maybe Gypyx is town for not pretending to have an opinion for clout points. I don't think this is really a scum tell and I'm not sure why you're identifying flipping as scum indicative here and then backing down liek "oh I suppose I can't read Gypyx aha"

I guess I'm not following what changed for you between then and now on Gypyx. You say you would have found it scummy in the moment, and then give some slight town points on it. I'm confused.

In post 385, VP Baltar wrote:lazy reads because he is chilling on a beach somewhere

In post 389, NorwegianboyEE wrote:I’m seeing a lot of comments that George’s post is either +town or +scum and i’d just like for someone to actually elaborate why?

In post 412, Datisi wrote:

Spoiler:

i am now lacking scumreads someone pls do something scummy thanks

In post 419, innocentvillager wrote:ok

yeah im just kinda meh about everything here rn. i don't really have a strong opinion on anyone other than geraint rn. i don't feel like making a readslist rn is helpful for me personally. i think i just need to see more stuff. like there are people whose alignments will just kind of become clearer over time {Wooper, Datisi, Ico, Luca, maybe Norway} and im okay waiting for that

In post 431, innocentvillager wrote:i think im forgetting how to read datisi or datisi is scum or both

In post 440, Luca Blight wrote:Not activity related. More his approach to me as well as his post above talking about his own play pinged me as Town

In post 457, innocentvillager wrote:oh i think i have a super secret read on Baltar too lol.

In post 472, Anya wrote:kinda weird you want me to talk about george bailey so desperately? feeling like he might be your partner and you're gauging whether you should kill me at night based on my read to keep him safe

In post 482, Anya wrote:he might even post more but then the villain WOOPER stormed in and started plotting to kill him

Spoiler: current feeling

In post 491, Datisi wrote:i walked down to the beach

the moonlight on the water is really pretty