Mafiascum.net

It might be time to bring Benmage into the fold.

TOWNBLOCK:
Alfred Borden (Empire/Llamarble)
Cephrir
Nautilius (Nacho/Ellibereth)
ooba
SafetyDance
Tammy
Tierce
Zdenek Titus

NEW LYNCHBLOCK:
Benmage
elleheathen
Garuk Relentless (Natarisha/MafiaSSK)
kanyeknowsbest
Messiah Complex (Desperado/Formerfish)
Shadoweh
The Alchemist

Desperado, what do you think of the "no, that's probably just why AGar was killed" counterargument to the slam dunk case?

Messiah, Benmage, Shadoweh are the three I would probably remove the fastest. Shadoweh because of vigging weirdness, Messiah because of play, Benmage because of trust in meta.

Elle --> TheAlchemist --> Garruk --> kanye --> Benmage --> Shadoweh --> Messiah is probably how I'd lynch that.

the fuck naucho ?

Who do you think is the scumteam?

Also:

In post 5043, Nautilius wrote:I don't think kanye's observation of "oh she's careful but she missed something" is good at all.

In post 5049, Nautilius wrote:I guess The Alchemist/elleheathen/kanye/Garruk would be my guess for a scumteam currently, although it's weird because Garruk/kanye interactions and because elle/Garruk business with Tierce.

:/

not sure but its sure as fuck not this

In post 5057, Nautilius wrote:Also:

In post 5043, Nautilius wrote:I don't think kanye's observation of "oh she's careful but she missed something" is good at all.

and i think its good and i think shes fuckin scum,.

but lets assume shes town and im scum, where is the motivation in me flipping my read on her and going after something as "flimsy" as that. if i wanted something easy today id go "welp i dunno im just gonna sheep you on elle nacho."

Titus is careful about a lot of things. I don't think missing obvious things is a scumtell for her.

so you think she missed the entire conversation we had about why i thought alfred was scum and why you thought he was town?

adn that doesnt conflict with her showing evidence of taking meticulous notes on the game?

you dont think that all the shit zed did was scum?

what about spyrexs "ooba is scum if zed is scum" dance?

Let's be fair Nacho; if there's one read I can legitimately say I :haven't: been lazy on it's Elle.
I kept coming back to her because she fits the profile, for lack of a better term, but I got a townread every time.

In post 5062, kanyeknowsbest wrote:adn that doesnt conflict with her showing evidence of taking meticulous notes on the game?

yes

In post 5063, kanyeknowsbest wrote:you dont think that all the shit zed did was scum?

what about spyrexs "ooba is scum if zed is scum" dance?

zed looked scummy as fuck but zed sometimes looks scummy as fuck
the ooba is scum if zed is scum is too transparent to be a SpyreX scum tactic
it's too transparent to be a me scum tactic

In post 5064, Alfred Borden wrote:Let's be fair Nacho; if there's one read I can legitimately say I :haven't: been lazy on it's Elle.
I kept coming back to her because she fits the profile, for lack of a better term, but I got a townread every time.

if you can give me the Llamarble seal of approval on elle then we're looking at Garruk scum, Kanye town, probably.

and agars roleblock?

AGar's roleblock on Titus when?

night three.

a night w. no kill and no explanation for the lack of kill

you know, aside from the roleblock from the flipped town roleblocker

maybe.
could see the kill hitting something bulletproof/something doctorlike.

She had the seal of approval as of my last disappearance; I will want to check again though.

Re - Benmage:
Benmage has a strong scumgame.
I see a lot of hard to fake posts but no hard evidence for Benmage town. His bestest towntells are missing.
Benmage-scum makes things make more sense to me.

Benmage, if you're town in this game then tell me why.