Page 205 of 343
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:12 pm
by Something_Smart
In post 5095, skitter30 wrote:again i feel like i'm repeating myself a lot, as i wrote a bunch abt this a few days ago ...
but again: you're looking a lot like pyp. i can give it a pass for like a phase, maybe two, but we're starting to get into 'scum!you making a lot of observations without really doing anything territory', and i feel like i'd have a better sense for what town!you is thinking; i have no idea what your reads are or what you want to happen today and i find it troubling. and that coupled with the fact that i'm p sure i'm approaching the day wrong and that my reads aren't super on point made me decide to vote you so that i can start picking at this mess from another angle.
So... what changed, then? Surely you saying I was towny before was more than just "giving me a pass".
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:13 pm
by Almost50
In post 5084, skitter30 wrote:well i'm fine with peta > firebringer and i already said superbowl shouldn't be that low
a50 why am i town and why is superbowl that low?
I DON'T KNOW why superbowl isn't higher than where he ism but you can ask Annie/Brian.
As for you, when I "tried" to read both threads simultaneously (once upon a long ago) I had town pings from your early posts on D1 (iirc I hadn't read beyond post 2000 when I stopped following this thread altogether, and I didn't even know you claimed until someone made a list of claims on D1 in the forwards thread towards the end of the day (shortly before I questioned the number of investigative/informative claims and was shut down by Titus)
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:14 pm
by Deacon Blues
I thought I mentioned pisskop in that post somewhere. I feel like his lurkiness is moving/has moved into obstinate territory. I have no idea how to read that.
I'm glad being a dumping ground for the forwards thread ends today.
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:15 pm
by Dandelion Wine
In post 5098, Deacon Blues wrote:We'll probably put out a comprehensive reads list on Monday after bork catches up.
It's really strange. My reads are usually townread/POE. But in this thread I have actual scumreads.
I still don't like pooky and skitter but I'm feeling more indecisive about skitter. midway bear's content bugs me and I can't townread it. S_S has fallen into scumread territory. And Gamma has moved up from scum tier into tier 2-3 town. A50's play so far doesn't impress.
In the other thread, strongest townread is Annie and probably next is Brian. My townread of Dunnstral has degraded. My townread of Bell has seriously degraded. My reads of Spiffeh and zMuffin are in the tier 2-3 town range. I'm trusting Nacho on his Gypyx read.
What if we... swapped hydrae connections and we morph listed?
I'm here, and current, no need to wait till monday.
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:16 pm
by Deacon Blues
In post 5103, Dandelion Wine wrote: In post 5098, Deacon Blues wrote:We'll probably put out a comprehensive reads list on Monday after bork catches up.
It's really strange. My reads are usually townread/POE. But in this thread I have actual scumreads.
I still don't like pooky and skitter but I'm feeling more indecisive about skitter. midway bear's content bugs me and I can't townread it. S_S has fallen into scumread territory. And Gamma has moved up from scum tier into tier 2-3 town. A50's play so far doesn't impress.
In the other thread, strongest townread is Annie and probably next is Brian. My townread of Dunnstral has degraded. My townread of Bell has seriously degraded. My reads of Spiffeh and zMuffin are in the tier 2-3 town range. I'm trusting Nacho on his Gypyx read.
What if we... swapped hydrae connections and we morph listed?
I'm here, and current, no need to wait till monday.
Sounds good. How transparent?
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:18 pm
by skitter30
In post 5100, Something_Smart wrote: In post 5095, skitter30 wrote:again i feel like i'm repeating myself a lot, as i wrote a bunch abt this a few days ago ...
but again: you're looking a lot like pyp. i can give it a pass for like a phase, maybe two, but we're starting to get into 'scum!you making a lot of observations without really doing anything territory', and i feel like i'd have a better sense for what town!you is thinking; i have no idea what your reads are or what you want to happen today and i find it troubling. and that coupled with the fact that i'm p sure i'm approaching the day wrong and that my reads aren't super on point made me decide to vote you so that i can start picking at this mess from another angle.
So... what changed, then? Surely you saying I was towny before was more than just "giving me a pass".
it's the sort of read that erodes with time. there was some townvibes way back when (before you ask, no, i don't remember them offhand) but it's basically dissipated - it's the sort of read that needs to be maintained by you doing townie things and you just, well, haven't .
do you think i should be townreading you now?
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:19 pm
by Dandelion Wine
Very!
Muffin is almost certainly scum going refuge in audacity, by the by. The pre-discredit of myself and Bork is actually a checkpoint in the "what would scum-muffin do?" ohshitohfuck.txt I had going in my head pregame.
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:19 pm
by skitter30
In post 5101, Almost50 wrote: In post 5084, skitter30 wrote:well i'm fine with peta > firebringer and i already said superbowl shouldn't be that low
a50 why am i town and why is superbowl that low?
I DON'T KNOW why superbowl isn't higher than where he ism but you can ask Annie/Brian.
As for you, when I "tried" to read both threads simultaneously (once upon a long ago) I had town pings from your early posts on D1 (iirc I hadn't read beyond post 2000 when I stopped following this thread altogether, and I didn't even know you claimed until someone made a list of claims on D1 in the forwards thread towards the end of the day (shortly before I questioned the number of investigative/informative claims and was shut down by Titus)
his approach towards wanting me turnstiled was +town, as was how he was acting during the fl fiasco
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:20 pm
by Dandelion Wine
If I was a three shot hero dayvig in the forwards thread I'd be shooting muffin twice then picking between the fast food boy and Hench. Ceph obviously prefers hench.
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:21 pm
by Dandelion Wine
Oh and by the way, @A50:
Read on Dunn?
Anything stand out to you about that slot?
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:21 pm
by Deacon Blues
In post 5106, Dandelion Wine wrote:Very!
Muffin is almost certainly scum going refuge in audacity, by the by. The pre-discredit of myself and Bork is actually a checkpoint in the "what would scum-muffin do?" ohshitohfuck.txt I had going in my head pregame.
Noted. Was it pre though? I thought it was in response to one of your posts.
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:22 pm
by skitter30
who is the fast food boy ... did you guys ever say that?
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:22 pm
by Dandelion Wine
"one of the heads of deacon" was shade at bork, not me. But then he mentioned me. Felt like a "Look at me I can't even keep the hydrae heads togetehr lah de dah townread my robotics"
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:22 pm
by Dandelion Wine
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:25 pm
by Deacon Blues
So you're thinking 2 scum in {zmuffin, Hench, Bell}?
Did you agree with my post
5000 about hating everything about a Hench post?
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:25 pm
by petapan
In post 5102, Deacon Blues wrote:I thought I mentioned pisskop in that post somewhere. I feel like his lurkiness is moving/has moved into obstinate territory. I have no idea how to read that.
I'm glad being a dumping ground for the forwards thread ends today.
i would prefer he be replaced with someone who actually plays the game
it occurs to me only now how wildly pro-scum shunting lowposters who aren't reading the game into a different thread is; i wish i'd realized this sooner.
UNVOTE: pooky
as i am no longer without fear of an early hammer.
i'm meh on a50 because of that thing with him being sent to this game thread just now and not having reads, looking at his iso from the other thread doesn't really look scummy to me, it's just kind of whatever. actually i don't mind
3330. good clapback at bell. i'm not sure why the other thread thought him scummy other than not being active.
6/10
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:25 pm
by Almost50
@skitter:
OK, so both you AND Tammy/Nacho TR sb, so I guess I can promote him to.. erm.. between you and FB? I think if I did a reread I can figure him out, but this thread is even more noisy that the forwards thread and I don't have the time, will or energy to do long reading sessions. I am not even playing in any other games and I am limiting myself to one visit to MS a day.
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:26 pm
by Deacon Blues
In post 5112, Dandelion Wine wrote:"one of the heads of deacon" was shade at bork, not me. But then he mentioned me. Felt like a "Look at me I can't even keep the hydrae heads togetehr lah de dah townread my robotics"
I was insulted.
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:26 pm
by Something_Smart
In post 5105, skitter30 wrote:it's the sort of read that erodes with time. there was some townvibes way back when (before you ask, no, i don't remember them offhand) but it's basically dissipated - it's the sort of read that needs to be maintained by you doing townie things and you just, well, haven't .
The concept of a read that erodes with time doesn't really make sense to me... I feel like it hides a deeper reason. If the reason is just that everyone else has done towny things, that's fine. But I worry that it's just you attributing less strength to your past reasons because you can't remember them anymore.
do you think i should be townreading you now?
Given that you were townreading me before, yes. I don't think that read should have dissipated the way it did.
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:27 pm
by skitter30
yeah i wasn't sure if that was outed somewhere yet
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:27 pm
by Dandelion Wine
My ONLY thought on how 5k isn't as bad as I think it would be is if both heads of hench are completely unaware of how the whole cohort operates; and WHY we'd value tammycho's psots more just than "lol they were confirmed town even before death"
Mostly I'm holding out a little hope Ceph was wrong so I don't have to hear him telling me to suck it in our hydra discord.
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:28 pm
by Deacon Blues
It's not hard to figure out. Even Nacho, bless his heart, got it in one.
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:28 pm
by skitter30
In post 5116, Almost50 wrote:@skitter:
OK, so both you AND Tammy/Nacho TR sb, so I guess I can promote him to.. erm.. between you and FB? I think if I did a reread I can figure him out, but this thread is even more noisy that the forwards thread and I don't have the time, will or energy to do long reading sessions. I am not even playing in any other games and I am limiting myself to one visit to MS a day.
yeah that's fair. i'd say he's probably like in my top3 townreads and feel p settled with that. like i don't see myself voting him any time soon
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:29 pm
by Almost50
Dunn was town, I believe. A Town Lean, actually.
Say, wasn't it you who instructed Annie to "drop it" when she asked Dunn to claim his night action? Or am I mixing the hydrae?
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:30 pm
by Dandelion Wine
In post 5123, Almost50 wrote:
Dunn was town, I believe. A Town Lean, actually.
Say, wasn't it you who instructed Annie to "drop it" when she asked Dunn to claim his night action? Or am I mixing the hydrae?
It was indeed me. Why?