A warlock, a werewolf, and a vampire... [Game Over]

[Cabd]

Some more game analysis: I believe that the scum team was particularly weak this round. Getting left out as scum in pre-dance should be avoidable as long as you didn't roll 3 gentleman or something ridiculous like that, and none of the scum players were much influential in the day game. Staying quiet and looking okay is passable, but you're never going to make the endgame pair like that. The mafia wins of the previous iterations had strong dayplay from the scum players, with possible exception of the summer waltz where Luna Fox threw. I agree with Something_Smart that losing the original gentleman 1 was quite a blow.

The fact that removing players based on post count was an instant win kind of says it all.




It's no wonder people had issues forming scum reads...


all the people who gave a shit were town.

[Something_Smart]

Fine with releasing the scum PT btw.

[Cabd]

G1 — hectic -> ??
G2 — ???
G3 — ???
G4 — midwaybear
G5 — dunn
G6 — cabd
G7 — ??
G8 — prefers to remain anonymous
G9 — ??

L1 — maria
L2 — S_S
L3 — lilith -> isis -> ??
L4 — sir cakez
L5 — yours truly
L6 — dann -> ??
L7 — beeboy -> ??
L8 — morning tweet

G2 is somebody from my era that recognized my signature arceus swearing. G8 is actually outed if you bother skimming the dead and lovers PTs he was in.

[Something_Smart]

In fairness, my post count wasn't low until I left for a 4-day V/LA and when I got back I decided my slot was unsalvageable so I just shut up.

[Menalque]

G8 is actually outed if you bother skimming the dead and lovers PTs he was in.

(I was trying not to draw attention to this)

[Cabd]

So I didn't guess who you were and the empire comparisons was just me self-referencing but holy shit what a co-incidence. I ruled you out from being in this game because I thought you'd perma-retired. How odd that we'd both come out of semi-retirement for the same altgame.

haha i just felt like playing in a mafia game for some reason but i forgot how much time i used to spend reading stuff in games i was invested in before and overestimated how much time i'd have to read this one :/

also i wanted to see who still plays. was disappointed to find that a lot of the players i used to like playing with are no longer really active (even though some older players seem to be crawling out of the woodworks in this endgame)

Mafia-me totally woulda gone anime grill. Very good call on my avatar.

There's a discord chat with me, ffery, borkie, empire, mina, syry, nacho, giffy, and tammy that occasionally talks about all mass-joining a game.

Oh and cephrir.

[Gentleman 8]

haha i don't care about the anonymity. i was mostly just keeping this game out of my egosearch

[Cabd]

haha i don't care about the anonymity. i was mostly just keeping this game out of my egosearch

Am i reading correctly that you thought G3 was me at one point?

When did I solid as g6 to you? The yomi thing?

[Gentleman 8]

uh... nah i thought you were gentleman 3 until he told me he wasnt and then i was like "hmmm" and then i read your posts and was like "ooooh"

like i said, i wasnt trying to alt-hunt. i assumed i would know no one

[Cabd]

When did he say he wans't... The dead thread?

[Gentleman 8]

well i knew you had to be someone from marketplace, i just didn't put two and two together that it was you until gentleman 3 said "nope"

and then i was like "well guess that makes gentleman 6 cabd then because literally no one else makes sense"

and yeah, dead thread

[Cabd]

I honestly wasn't sure that all the daughter-talk would do anything. But she turns one year old this wednesday and makes staying up posting REALLY difficult.


I miss Kagami. He was in the same boat a few years back.

[Isis]

Kagami played in starry night 2 dances ago, last year's may ish

[Gentleman 3]

This was fun to semi-watch!

Agree!

~f

Oh, it seems all the great old-timers are popping around. I really was lucky to replace into this game.

G3, I'm curious if guessed my identity correctly at any point?

Also who was Gentleman 7 and what was their deal with seals

No, actually. You were fairly well-hidden, I'd say. Your name came up, but I never really searched for a definitive answer on my lovely partner.

Funnily enough, I loosely suspect that Gentleman 7 thought that you were me.

[Cabd]

Kagami played in starry night 2 dances ago, last year's may ish

Last post November of 19, sadly.



Actually according to the posts, now has a (second?) kiddo.


I wish Kagami well, and we can probably trade stories!

[Cabd]

This was fun to semi-watch!

Agree!

~f

Oh, it seems all the great old-timers are popping around. I really was lucky to replace into this game.

G3, I'm curious if guessed my identity correctly at any point?

Also who was Gentleman 7 and what was their deal with seals

No, actually. You were fairly well-hidden, I'd say. Your name came up, but I never really searched for a definitive answer on my lovely partner.

Funnily enough, I loosely suspect that Gentleman 7 thought that you were me.

I summoned them all from the "we won't play mafia but will spectate cabd crying" discord channel.

[Isis]

G3 are you going not out that is altogether cruel

[Dannflor]

No, actually. You were fairly well-hidden, I'd say. Your name came up, but I never really searched for a definitive answer on my lovely partner.

You were a pleasure to play with for the short time we got! I do regret slipping right before your return.

Thanks for modding as always FakeGod

[Isis]

G1 — hectic -> ??
G2 — ???
G3 — ???
G4 — midwaybear
G5 — dunn
G6 — cabd
G7 — ??
G8 — prefers to remain anonymous
G9 — ??

L1 — maria
L2 — S_S
L3 — lilith -> isis -> ??
L4 — sir cakez
L5 — yours truly
L6 — dann -> ??
L7 — beeboy -> ??
L8 — morning tweet

georgebailey played and there was a mysterious newbie in there

[Menalque]

G1 — hectic -> ??
G2 — ???
G3 — GeorgeBailey ‘GeorgeBailey’ GeorgeBailey -> ???
G4 — midwaybear
G5 — dunn
G6 — cabd
G7 — ??
G8 — prefers to remain anonymous
G9 — ??

L1 — maria
L2 — S_S
L3 — lilith -> isis -> ??
L4 — sir cakez
L5 — yours truly
L6 — dann -> ??
L7 — beeboy -> ??
L8 — morning tweet

[Menalque]

Was the newbie the one in G6?

[Menalque]

I wanna know if G9 was right about me

[Cabd]

Yeah. The newbie was who I replaced early game after they got overwhelmed.


I maintain scum-newbie would have gotten help in the Mafia PT instead of replacing out like that.

[Isis]

This setup is hard enough for scum without people repping out in obvtown ways

[Cabd]

Yeah.

Technically, that was against global site rules. It sure as heck made the "i am new" part of the rep-out believable. I doubt any oldtimers risk punishment to replace out publicly.