In post 5105, skitter30 wrote:it's the sort of read that erodes with time. there was some townvibes way back when (before you ask, no, i don't remember them offhand) but it's basically dissipated - it's the sort of read that needs to be maintained by you doing townie things and you just, well, haven't .
The concept of a read that erodes with time doesn't really make sense to me... I feel like it hides a deeper reason. If the reason is just that everyone else has done towny things, that's fine. But I worry that it's just you attributing less strength to your past reasons because you can't remember them anymore.
do you think i should be townreading you now?
Given that you were townreading me before, yes. I don't think that read should have dissipated the way it did.
idk how to explain it. sometimes lower-tier reads just kinda wither away if they're not maintained. the fact that i can't remember why i was townreading you is kinda part of that, yes. and yeah the fact that i have too many townreads is part of that too, that kinda dictates who the 'lower tier' reads are and since literally everyone here can't be town, i gotta reamine the lower ones more closely
i also meant more: given what you've done thus far this game, do you think i should be townreading you at this juncture?
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:31 pm
by Deacon Blues
In post 5120, Dandelion Wine wrote:My ONLY thought on how 5k isn't as bad as I think it would be is if both heads of hench are completely unaware of how the whole cohort operates; and WHY we'd value tammycho's psots more just than "lol they were confirmed town even before death"
Mostly I'm holding out a little hope Ceph was wrong so I don't have to hear him telling me to suck it in our hydra discord.
I don't even think it takes a cohort decoder ring to figure that out, though.
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:32 pm
by Dandelion Wine
Let me have the hope, damn you. Smugceph is insufferable.
In post 164, Bell wrote:Sounds good Pisskop can we start with you.
you could.
but then i wouldnt be in the game anymore. Thus i must object. You need me, you see.
P: ummm idk. Id agree to no thread-swapping, but Im not so sure its in the spirit of the game. We might have some kind of hidden mechanic, and most likely scum can somehow influence the swaps or even make their own somehow.
Skitter needs to be yeeted. I'm only to post 201 but you should yeet him ASAP. The hyperfocus on yeeting Imperium is bad, particularly the early random shade. Most of her reads are shade. The townread on HP was unwarranted based on the their ISO at the time. Not sure if it's warranted now.
hmmmm this is good. A post by a person Ive known for years about a person I feel a connection with.
That's literally all Pisskop has done. We have "eliminated" scum in the forwards thread by turnstyling and eliminating. Two turnstyles means two opportunities to save scum from the elimination. We turnstyled Pooky and pisskop. Pooky's tried and got suspicion. Pisskop's been a bowl of lurky shit. His response to a prod is a prodge. That's inexcusable. Lim him.
Looking at Pisskop's posts, there's a major hint as to his partner. It's Brian Skies. He alludes to scum having a turnstyle mechanic because he already knows they have it.
Brian's role acts like a scum get out of jail free card. It can also act to disrupt another thread.
So I am strongly at Pisskop BS and Pooky all aligned.
The house of cards rests with Pisskop being scum. Flip him before Pooky.
We'll flip BS here first if I have a say.
VOTE: Brian Skies
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:40 pm
by Deacon Blues
I'm townreading brian. :/
Though it it weren't xmas week brian's activity level would be bugging me.
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:41 pm
by Something_Smart
In post 5125, skitter30 wrote:i also meant more: given what you've done thus far this game, do you think i should be townreading you at this juncture?
Maybe? I don't know exactly how your brain works wrt reading me. I think if not for PYP, you probably would have been. It's hard to tell if you would correct for PYP accurately (by no longer townreading things that aren't really towny) or inaccurately (by no longer townreading things that are towny overall but that I happened to do that game, or that I did differently and you failed to notice the difference).
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:43 pm
by skitter30
so i'm not following what part of my read/current approach is confusing?
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:44 pm
by Dandelion Wine
Notsci, your prior guess isn't in my dayvig list, take that as you will.
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:44 pm
by Deacon Blues
also, Brian's scumreading pisskop and seems to be suggesting we elim him before pooky?
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:48 pm
by petapan
lol that case on brian
i mean yes if pisskop isnt going to be removed we have to policy him at some point but im not sure hes the best kill today (its pooky). like if pisskop flips red thats a nice happy bonus but we wind up in the same place either way really
Deacon Blues wrote:also, Brian's scumreading pisskop and seems to be suggesting we elim him before pooky?
brian is insisting on a pooky townread that i dont care about
7/10
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:49 pm
by Deacon Blues
In post 5136, Dandelion Wine wrote:Notsci, your prior guess isn't in my dayvig list, take that as you will.
Are we working on a reads list or no?
My bailey's intake depends on your answer.
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:50 pm
by PookyTheMagicalBear
peta has turned into a "kill pooky robot"
why flip bad guys when theres an adorable teddy bear we can dunk instead.
In post 5136, Dandelion Wine wrote:Notsci, your prior guess isn't in my dayvig list, take that as you will.
Are we working on a reads list or no?
My bailey's intake depends on your answer.
I am.
The bailys might help some of the sad and rough conclusions I appear to be coming to.
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:57 pm
by Dandelion Wine
A50 is probstown, by the by.
I'm satisfied for now.
But we both know I have a weak spot for pantshittingly tonedeaf posting.
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2020 4:57 pm
by Almost50
In post 5130, skitter30 wrote:sorry, a50 did you answer: is your read on me largely from my claim or is it also cuz of play?
I said it was your earlier posts BEFORE you claimed. I missed the claim. I had no idea you claimed later on. I had a TR on you when I stopped reading this thread. HOWEVER, your claim was believable to me (I really can't tell if the claim strengthened the TR or if the TR was the reason I believed the claim)
In post 4041, Spiffeh wrote:@Deacon Blues did Nacho/Tammy ever explain why or how they wanted to 'look into' Brian Skies more today?
Tammy thought Brian's day 1 pooky fixation and defense was odd. She also noted that brian didn't take a strong stance about pooky being turnstiled, and then afterwards said something about not using his turnstile day 1 if he'd known pooky would be the turnstile-ee.
Nacho wanted brian pressed to explain his pooky read.
In post 5130, skitter30 wrote:sorry, a50 did you answer: is your read on me largely from my claim or is it also cuz of play?
I said it was your earlier posts BEFORE you claimed. I missed the claim. I had no idea you claimed later on. I had a TR on you when I stopped reading this thread. HOWEVER, your claim was believable to me (I really can't tell if the claim strengthened the TR or if the TR was the reason I believed the claim)
ah ok thanks. as a followup i'd want to know which posts prompted the townread at some point - dont' feel like you need to do this rn, i know this game is big and my iso is long, but i would like this at some point
In post 5130, skitter30 wrote:sorry, a50 did you answer: is your read on me largely from my claim or is it also cuz of play?
I said it was your earlier posts BEFORE you claimed. I missed the claim. I had no idea you claimed later on. I had a TR on you when I stopped reading this thread. HOWEVER, your claim was believable to me (I really can't tell if the claim strengthened the TR or if the TR was the reason I believed the claim)
ah ok thanks. as a followup i'd want to know which posts prompted the townread at some point - dont' feel like you need to do this rn, i know this game is big and my iso is long, but i would like this at some point
