Mafiascum.net

no nightkill?? did andres save twice??

HEAL: dwlee
HEAL: guilty

I also want to be an expert today

Sorry. I and Andate murdered Titus because i didn’t have time to sort.

Cephrir, CSF, andante,
Are very likely town to me.

But Titus asked that people suspect Andante for their push against them.

They also hard advocated for a Mistyx murder.

I don’t think Titus was a weird pick since from a certain lense they were obvious town. I just couldn’t let them pass until I was confident and I didn’t have time to be confident.
I ended up picking three town reads though. From baltar review, still in progress.

Anyone else have Baltar associative insights?

recap of last night: I said I was refusing to defuse the bomb, Titus caled me maf with Mistyx, and that was that

I still think Andante is town

In post 5230, Bell wrote:Anyone else have Baltar associative insights?

Menalque

Sorry Titus but we should have blown up the bomb last night. It's just basic risk mitigation.

Although tonight, if we lim scum today, we can possibly defuse again. The only person that we cannot allow to defuse a bomb is GuiltyLion, since he has already defused once, so I propose we expert him.

That really felt like frogster all over again, like, i was in the PT, “Let’s solve!!” and all titus gave was “andante maf” like… she never once said that in thread… i thought titus works better in PTs??? cause that was just sad last night

In post 5234, Cat Scratch Fever wrote:Sorry Titus but we should have blown up the bomb last night. It's just basic risk mitigation.

Although tonight, if we lim scum today, we can possibly defuse again. The only person that we cannot allow to defuse a bomb is GuiltyLion, since he has already defused once, so I propose we expert him.

i dont think we can with GL alive

I thought Enchant refusing to hammer VP was weird…

In post 5236, Cephrir wrote:

In post 5234, Cat Scratch Fever wrote:Sorry Titus but we should have blown up the bomb last night. It's just basic risk mitigation.

Although tonight, if we lim scum today, we can possibly defuse again. The only person that we cannot allow to defuse a bomb is GuiltyLion, since he has already defused once, so I propose we expert him.

i dont think we can with GL alive

Minor correction: I meant if we lim scum today (say, Misty, for example)

Then there's only 1 scum left going into night. Suppose the last scum alive is GuiltyLion

Then as long as he doesn't defuse any more bombs, we should be ok to let anyone else defuse at least for tonight only, right?

Yea if we lim scum we can let a person diffuse a bomb once without risk

In post 5233, Dwlee99 wrote:

In post 5230, Bell wrote:Anyone else have Baltar associative insights?

Menalque

yeah this

Mena's read on VPB changed in a way that is unlikely to come from town

killing titus was correct there

0-2 in [GL/Pooky/Ceph]

which leaves bell dwlee andante enchant csf mena

VOTE: GuiltyLion

if we flip this then pooky/ceph are town and we sort in the rest

i'd rank dwlee > bell > enchant/andante > csf > mena in that group probably

In post 5238, Cat Scratch Fever wrote:

In post 5236, Cephrir wrote:

In post 5234, Cat Scratch Fever wrote:Sorry Titus but we should have blown up the bomb last night. It's just basic risk mitigation.

Although tonight, if we lim scum today, we can possibly defuse again. The only person that we cannot allow to defuse a bomb is GuiltyLion, since he has already defused once, so I propose we expert him.

i dont think we can with GL alive

Minor correction: I meant if we lim scum today

that isn't GuiltyLion

(say, Misty, for example)

Then there's only 1 scum left going into night. Suppose the last scum alive is GuiltyLion

Then as long as he doesn't defuse any more bombs, we should be ok to let anyone else defuse at least for tonight only, right?

oh. got it

In post 5241, Mistyx wrote:killing titus was correct there

0-2 in [GL/Pooky/Ceph]

which leaves bell dwlee andante enchant csf mena

VOTE: GuiltyLion

if we flip this then pooky/ceph are town and we sort in the rest

i'd rank dwlee > bell > enchant/andante > csf > mena in that group probably

Why GL/Pooky/Ceph over Menalque

In post 5243, Dwlee99 wrote:

In post 5241, Mistyx wrote:killing titus was correct there

0-2 in [GL/Pooky/Ceph]

which leaves bell dwlee andante enchant csf mena

VOTE: GuiltyLion

if we flip this then pooky/ceph are town and we sort in the rest

i'd rank dwlee > bell > enchant/andante > csf > mena in that group probably

Why GL/Pooky/Ceph over Menalque

moreso risk/reward

when i say 0-2 i mean it's either GL/Pooky, GL/Ceph, or none of them

if gl is town we know scum are only at 2 and can make decisions on the bombs

if gl is scum we know scum are at 3 and can react accordingly

plus we get info on pooky/ceph

In post 5241, Mistyx wrote:
VOTE: GuiltyLion

if we flip this then pooky/ceph are town

and we sort in the rest

In post 5244, Mistyx wrote:when i say 0-2 i mean

it's either GL/Pooky, GL/Ceph, or none of them

What? This isn't even internally consistent?

Why are Ceph and or Pooky only scum with GL?

In post 5246, Dwlee99 wrote:Why are Ceph and or Pooky only scum with GL?

scum wouldn't send scum!gl to a group of three town bombers

and scum!pooky/ceph would take the chance to justify an explosion on town!gl

In post 5245, Cat Scratch Fever wrote:

In post 5241, Mistyx wrote:
VOTE: GuiltyLion

if we flip this then pooky/ceph are town

and we sort in the rest

In post 5244, Mistyx wrote:when i say 0-2 i mean

it's either GL/Pooky, GL/Ceph, or none of them

What? This isn't even internally consistent?

meant to say if this flips scum

In post 5247, Mistyx wrote:

In post 5246, Dwlee99 wrote:Why are Ceph and or Pooky only scum with GL?

scum wouldn't send scum!gl to a group of three town bombers

and scum!pooky/ceph would take the chance to justify an explosion on town!gl

What makes you so confident that pooky/ceph would explode gl if given the chance? Especially because they could set him up to be mislimmed later with this line of thought.