↑The Goat wrote:PirateHydra...whichever head I'm speaking to at the moment:
You had a bad read on me. It's okay to think that. However...I'm going to apologize in advance for excessive sarcasm if you continue to chase minutia.
are you being serious you can't tell mala and I apart
she capitalises and punctuates and stuff
also she is the sane one
no one can accuse me of being these things ever
Posted: Wed Mar 20, 2013 3:03 pm
by Angelious Nero
So AP isn't scum...his reads are just terrible or so he says.
Posted: Wed Mar 20, 2013 3:04 pm
by The Goat
Random thought: Can someone post a link to where AN explains why he/they/whatever think Majiffy is scum? If there is no such link, I'd like to hear the case. Majiffy is cracking me the hell up, and I'd like to make sure that's not blinding me to something obvious.
↑The Goat wrote:PirateHydra...whichever head I'm speaking to at the moment:
You had a bad read on me. It's okay to think that. However...I'm going to apologize in advance for excessive sarcasm if you continue to chase minutia.
are you being serious you can't tell mala and I apart
she capitalises and punctuates and stuff
also she is the sane one
no one can accuse me of being these things ever
Noted. MollieK = crazy one with indifference to punctuation and capitalization. Thank you.
Posted: Wed Mar 20, 2013 3:06 pm
by Piratecat
↑The Goat wrote:Also for what it's worth, it looks to me PirateCat is shaking the trees to see what comes falling out. Is that the typical MO for her as town?
for me?
yes
mala is the brainier of the 2 of us
Posted: Wed Mar 20, 2013 3:11 pm
by Angelious Nero
Shhh! Mollie will think we're coordinating and getting online at the same time.
I think Majiffy is being more hardheaded than usual. I don't like his still "RVSing" when there was content and then kept on refusing to read said content and participate in the game. Then he claims that his vote was actually a "policy vote" which is not that much better than RVS and pretty much the same thing. Then claiming that we (my slot) is scummy 'cause we are "anti-town" when he himself is anti-town. That logic sucks.
Posted: Wed Mar 20, 2013 3:17 pm
by AngryPidgeon
↑Angelious Nero wrote:So AP isn't scum...his reads are just terrible or so he says.
When did I say my reads were terrible?
Posted: Wed Mar 20, 2013 3:24 pm
by Piratecat
↑AngryPidgeon wrote:MollieK, I really want to talk. I'm one of the few people not town-reading you this game and I can't tell if its because I'm paranoid (definitely possible) or we really aren't working towards the same win con. So what is your read on me right now? I'd appreciate a stream of thoughts from one of yo about why your opinion of me is what it is. Why is mastin such a liability that he should be vig'd? Mastin is more valuable than you think. I really don't get why you would think he is town but insist that he must go for his claim.
If you had to give me your combined top 5 townreads and top 2 scumreads, who would they be?
Okay we can talk. Probably because you are being paranoid or it's because having two players who share an account is really hard to read. Trust me - why I hate hydra's due to never being able to correctly read them. If you are town, which I have a weak town read on you, then we are going towards the same win con. Mala-head has a town read on you. Why? One. Gut Two. You are being aggressive and trying to make people come to an agreement. You keep allowing everyone to know what you are thinking and not holding back. Now when I told Mollie I thought you were town based on aggressiveness she told me scum could also be aggressive, but I told her I don't think he's scum being aggressive. Now - I'm not the one who made the post regarding Mastin and being vig'd. I rather not have him vigged or even lynched at this point because I believe he's town. When someone is town I don't want them killed and I will defend them if the read I have on them is strong enough. I don't believe Mastin is gambiting nor do I think he's lying. He is valuable - I agree. I'm currently trying to talk to Mollie regarding Mastin and we have been coming to a conclusion he's town. I have also gotten her to warm up to the idea that AP you are town also.
The whole Ms Marangal thing will be something Mollie has to explain.
I need to talk to Mollie about the combined top town reads, but so far:
Jal, Mastin, Qwints & Goats.
I have a town read on AP, but Mollie does not.
Mollie has a slight town read on PV, but I do not. Although I think I'm confusing him with another player and have to go reread the Marketplace Game.
I also have a slight town read on KoC, but that's due to him being different from the first game we played together.
Cyro is a scum read.
~
Bitmap is a bit quiet for my liking and I need to discuss that with Mollie.
I have to also talk to her about Jiffy and Col Guile.
It always pings our 'dar when anyone posts something like the above and doesn't put their money where there mouth is. In the post this came from, you even unvoted...so it's not like you just forgot. If we are your only scum read, why is your vote not on us?
Posted: Wed Mar 20, 2013 4:51 pm
by Ms Marangal
because you aren't Mollie/Mala's only scum read?
I'm pretty sure they have stated they had a scum read on a few other people
Posted: Wed Mar 20, 2013 5:12 pm
by Venmar
Posted: Wed Mar 20, 2013 5:51 pm
by Majiffy
↑Angelious Nero wrote:Why don't you state those opinions?
So far she had only two logics may three (including her thing Slaandar)
Because I'm looking for scum, not stupid. I'm going to poke and prod her in other ways so I can determine her alignment, not her intelligent quotient.
↑The Goat wrote:Also for what it's worth, it looks to me PirateCat is shaking the trees to see what comes falling out. Is that the typical MO for her as town?
That's Mollie's (uncapitalized), I don't know about Mala's.
↑Angelious Nero wrote:Then claiming that we (my slot) is scummy 'cause we are "anti-town" when he himself is anti-town. That logic sucks.
Yeah, you haven't explained how anything I've done is anti-town.
↑CryoChemist wrote:So....this head doesn't really feel like reading 22 pages....
Anyone want to sum them up for us?
Don't do that, they'll think you're scum if you don't read.
>Quickwagon on ANG
>Mini counterwagons on a few other people
>Nero is dumbtown, AP and Mastin are town, Mollie seems to be keeping up with her town self
>We're lynching Messiah
Hope this helps.
Posted: Wed Mar 20, 2013 6:11 pm
by CryoChemist
Can't argue the flow chart.
VOTE: Messiah
...Didn't we try and do this before the game even started?
Posted: Wed Mar 20, 2013 6:18 pm
by AngryPidgeon
It was destiny. Who else is mentioned in your role card btw?
I kinda want to form a town bloc with Goat, Slandaar, mastin2, Majiffy and AA9/Nero. Pretty sure of those townreads (just gotta stop Nero/AA from trying to kill Majiffy). And most of those townreads are sure of MollieK. In hindsight, I think Majiffy is right about Mollie playing par for the town course.
Other town reads: Jal, PV, Bork, Mac
Posted: Wed Mar 20, 2013 6:20 pm
by Majiffy
Not with me, I wasn't around.
p-edit: to Cryo
Posted: Wed Mar 20, 2013 6:21 pm
by Majiffy
Explain your Slandaar and Jal town reads please.
Posted: Wed Mar 20, 2013 6:41 pm
by AngryPidgeon
Jal is a little weaker read. Her mastin2 vote is really bad. But I feel like shes stepping on a lot of people's toes and doesn;t really care. Outing the hydra identity is not something you do when you are trying to get on people's good side; feels like Rob V Mollie did in NY161.
She feels a bit unconcerned with what people think of her posts. Like her theory that mastin2 is more likely 3rd party than scum and her vague stance on the goat in 235. I know those are small things, but she just feels like shes taking the game in her own stride and uninterested in other people's bullshit. Not the strongest read I've ever had, but its there. I feel like mastin
Slandaar...I see Jal's point about his scum play and this not looking like it. His shove on Cryonudist feels townie. Hes just kind of calling them confscum and making a case that is fairly personal and unlikely to be easy to convince the masses of. It feels like he really believes his case; if he is scum, he is shoving an awfully construed point against them. He feels bold and a bit carefree. And I like a lot of his reads. And I 100% understand why he has a null read on me. Dunno, just feel like I get him. In a similar way that I think mastin2 is town this game.
Posted: Wed Mar 20, 2013 7:09 pm
by Majiffy
I'll re-read those two tomorrow or friday in light of that. Thanks.
Posted: Thu Mar 21, 2013 12:31 am
by The Goat
↑AngryPidgeon wrote:It was destiny. Who else is mentioned in your role card btw?
I kinda want to form a town bloc with Goat, Slandaar, mastin2, Majiffy and AA9/Nero. Pretty sure of those townreads (just gotta stop Nero/AA from trying to kill Majiffy). And most of those townreads are sure of MollieK. In hindsight, I think Majiffy is right about Mollie playing par for the town course.
Other town reads: Jal, PV, Bork, Mac
I'm not usually much of a "joiner" - will there be bacon? Or bourbon? Or bacon-wrapped bourbon?
Posted: Thu Mar 21, 2013 12:53 am
by The Goat
Strongest town reads thus far (in no particular order):
