Mafiascum.net

In post 523, theloveofneroandmollie wrote:

In post 495, Shadowy Poison wrote:

In post 272, theloveofneroandmollie wrote:Why do you think DV as town would claim he thinks a game is MB on day 1 just for no reason?

In post 273, Rail Tracer wrote:i dunno... maybe because he does? that would seem like the obvious answer

I agree with RT

Why does that not surprise me?

Of course he believes that or else he wouldn't say that. The question is

WHY

he believes that and the fact that he won't state WHY he believes that is pretty alarming.

I don't mind muffin being derpy about it 'cause its muffin. but ya'll sheeping that is pretty horrible.

Why do you have a town read on Kats/PV?

luna called kats town and claimed kats was playing like always yet a check of his games indicates that is a false statement.

In post 495, Shadowy Poison wrote: {dopog, Nani, BBmolla, Dante, ooba}

So this is not a scumlist? What is it then?

Knowing that a game is multiball isn't information that town should have on day 1 and I think any townie worth their weight in salt would be very cautious about that post. I think if he were town and had that belief he'd have no trouble telling us why he thinks that. The fact he's ignoring it and hoping that it (the question) just goes away also doesn't make me think its pro-town.

Tell me what you guys think of the Kat/PV slot?

In post 526, theloveofneroandmollie wrote:

In post 495, Shadowy Poison wrote: {dopog, Nani, BBmolla, Dante, ooba}

So this is not a scumlist? What is it then?

Knowing that a game is multiball isn't information that town should have on day 1 and I think any townie worth their weight in salt would be very cautious about that post. I think if he were town and had that belief he'd have no trouble telling us why he thinks that. The fact he's ignoring it and hoping that it (the question) just goes away also doesn't make me think its pro-town.

Tell me what you guys think of the Kat/PV slot?

Yes it's a scumlist. That doesn't make the other 11 town by default.

Nothing stood out about Kat for either of us. And I have some experience with Peregrine so I'm going to give him some space and sort him later.

In post 526, theloveofneroandmollie wrote:

In post 495, Shadowy Poison wrote: {dopog, Nani, BBmolla, Dante, ooba}

So this is not a scumlist? What is it then?

Knowing that a game is multiball isn't information that town should have on day 1 and I think any townie worth their weight in salt would be very cautious about that post. I think if he were town and had that belief he'd have no trouble telling us why he thinks that. The fact he's ignoring it and hoping that it (the question) just goes away also doesn't make me think its pro-town.

Tell me what you guys think of the Kat/PV slot?

Yes it's a scumlist. That doesn't make the other 11 town by default.

Nothing stood out about Kat for either of us. And I have some experience with Peregrine so I'm going to give him some space and sort him later.

Also: I call bullshit.

Deas didn't say he "knew" it was multiball, he said it's "very likely." That's speculation.

Here's mollie speculating multiball D1 in Red Wedding

Mollie is entirely correct when she says site meta points towards multiball.

Really not like this from you Nero.

- Des

In post 529, Shadowy Poison wrote:Also: I call bullshit.

Deas didn't say he "knew" it was multiball, he said it's "very likely." That's speculation.

Here's mollie speculating multiball D1 in Red Wedding

Mollie is entirely correct when she says site meta points towards multiball.

Really not like this from you Nero.

- Des

is this about me not replying to you or something

I haven't been in this game as much cos I think kasuki should have been lynched right away. I am with nero and his reads but I want to add that luna thing on the list. problem is they have both been so genuinely terrible as far as leadership goes that I can't tell

oh god now nero is getting hysterical about something

In post 530, theloveofneroandmollie wrote:is this about me not replying to you or something

No, it's about Nero's position on Deas speculating multiball D1 as town. It's really really wrong and not in a town-Nero way.

In post 532, Desperado wrote:

In post 530, theloveofneroandmollie wrote:is this about me not replying to you or something

No, it's about Nero's position on Deas speculating multiball D1 as town. It's really really wrong and not in a town-Nero way.

- Des

In post 529, Shadowy Poison wrote:Also: I call bullshit.

Deas didn't say he "knew" it was multiball, he said it's "very likely." That's speculation.

Here's mollie speculating multiball D1 in Red Wedding

Mollie is entirely correct when she says site meta points towards multiball.

HA!

There's a big difference between this game and red wedding. red wedding was based on a show/theme. Mollie is 100% correct that MB is very commom around here but those are usually in larger games. A 5/12 split seems reasonable for this size of game. A 5 man scum team or a 4 man team and a sk are both plausible. "Speculating" on a 3 man/2 man split looks like inside info. Its completely reasonable to ask him why he has such a belief.

In post 534, theloveofneroandmollie wrote:

In post 529, Shadowy Poison wrote:Also: I call bullshit.

Deas didn't say he "knew" it was multiball, he said it's "very likely." That's speculation.

Here's mollie speculating multiball D1 in Red Wedding

Mollie is entirely correct when she says site meta points towards multiball.

HA!

There's a big difference between this game and red wedding. red wedding was based on a show/theme. Mollie is 100% correct that MB is very commom around here but those are usually in larger games.

A 5/12 split seems reasonable for this size of game. A 5 man scum team or a 4 man team and a sk are both plausible.

"Speculating" on a 3 man/2 man split looks like inside info. Its completely reasonable to ask him why he has such a belief.

Correct me if I'm wrong but don't you consider scum + SK to be multiball?

In post 535, Shadowy Poison wrote:

In post 534, theloveofneroandmollie wrote:

In post 529, Shadowy Poison wrote:Also: I call bullshit.

Deas didn't say he "knew" it was multiball, he said it's "very likely." That's speculation.

Here's mollie speculating multiball D1 in Red Wedding

Mollie is entirely correct when she says site meta points towards multiball.

HA!

There's a big difference between this game and red wedding. red wedding was based on a show/theme. Mollie is 100% correct that MB is very commom around here but those are usually in larger games.

A 5/12 split seems reasonable for this size of game. A 5 man scum team or a 4 man team and a sk are both plausible.

"Speculating" on a 3 man/2 man split looks like inside info. Its completely reasonable to ask him why he has such a belief.

Correct me if I'm wrong but don't you consider scum + SK to be multiball?

I don't consider scum + sk to be multiball.

-mollie

In post 530, theloveofneroandmollie wrote:

In post 529, Shadowy Poison wrote:Also: I call bullshit.

Deas didn't say he "knew" it was multiball, he said it's "very likely." That's speculation.

Here's mollie speculating multiball D1 in Red Wedding

Mollie is entirely correct when she says site meta points towards multiball.

Really not like this from you Nero.

- Des

is this about me not replying to you or something

I haven't been in this game as much cos I think kasuki should have been lynched right away. I am with nero and his reads but I want to add that luna thing on the list. problem is they have both been so genuinely terrible as far as leadership goes that I can't tell

what the hell is this.

you're not in the game because one of your scumreads didn't get lynched immediately?
a scumread that you never ever talked about?

In post 535, Shadowy Poison wrote:

In post 534, theloveofneroandmollie wrote:

In post 529, Shadowy Poison wrote:Also: I call bullshit.

Deas didn't say he "knew" it was multiball, he said it's "very likely." That's speculation.

Here's mollie speculating multiball D1 in Red Wedding

Mollie is entirely correct when she says site meta points towards multiball.

HA!

There's a big difference between this game and red wedding. red wedding was based on a show/theme. Mollie is 100% correct that MB is very commom around here but those are usually in larger games.

A 5/12 split seems reasonable for this size of game. A 5 man scum team or a 4 man team and a sk are both plausible.

"Speculating" on a 3 man/2 man split looks like inside info. Its completely reasonable to ask him why he has such a belief.

Correct me if I'm wrong but don't you consider scum + SK to be multiball?

if you are asking this you have clearly not read the whole conversation.

Which only bolsters my scumread on your slot.

Just so I have this straight, you have enough experience to guess he is the SK in a multiball setup that slipped that it's multiball, but town Deas can't come to the same conclusion?

- Des

Yep. I don't think he's in your scum group and traditional MB seems very very unlikely so if we see a second kill I'm going to think its an SK kill.

So you're town and had no trouble assuming scum + SK, but Deas made the same assumption...and it's an SK slip?

God, this geme, someone tell me who I should vote and why.

In post 510, Luna Lovegood wrote:

In post 484, Shadowy Poison wrote:

In post 478, Luna Lovegood wrote:Vote: Shadowy Poison

I guess I'll wait for the reason behind this

just, don't kill me

What are you thinking about this fine game we have going on in front of us?

I think that nero/mollie is still really freaking town so I'm disengaging this 1v1 before it gets out of hand

Town
theloveofneroandmollie (Nero Cain/pirate mollie hydra)
ooba


BBmolla
Luna Lovegood* (Nachomamma8/Andrius hydra)


Diabolik (replaced SleepyKrew)
Metal Unites Mutley* (Metal Sonic/Mutleyddmc hydra)

Null
Nani*
Dante
Rail Tracer (Xegarus/zMuffinMan hydra)
PeregrineV (replaced Katsuki)
Viera Assassin
Vifam*
mnemonicdevice

Scum
dopog
DeasVail
PeaceBringer

In post 545, Shadowy Poison wrote:Null
Nani*
Dante
Rail Tracer (Xegarus/zMuffinMan hydra)
PeregrineV (replaced Katsuki)
Viera Assassin
Vifam*
mnemonicdevice

Tracer, PV, and Viera move to the townish side of null

Tracer could be stronger I guess, Desp certainly thinks he's town and alot of his more recent posts cancel out alot of the reasons to why I thought he was scummy earlier

Neromollie, I'm not going to explain why I think it could be multiball. If you want to think I'm scum for it, fine, but I am town.

I'm still pretty happy voting PV and don't really have much else to say.

In post 538, Luna Lovegood wrote:you're not in the game because one of your scumreads didn't get lynched immediately?
a scumread that you never ever talked about?

nero has been talking about it ever since he came up for air, how are you even missing this. unless your angle is that I did not push the case myself.

I agreed with the read.

plz drop a freaking towntell so I don't have to go paranoid on you both.

In post 535, Shadowy Poison wrote:

In post 534, theloveofneroandmollie wrote:

In post 529, Shadowy Poison wrote:Also: I call bullshit.

Deas didn't say he "knew" it was multiball, he said it's "very likely." That's speculation.

Here's mollie speculating multiball D1 in Red Wedding

Mollie is entirely correct when she says site meta points towards multiball.

HA!

There's a big difference between this game and red wedding. red wedding was based on a show/theme. Mollie is 100% correct that MB is very commom around here but those are usually in larger games.

A 5/12 split seems reasonable for this size of game. A 5 man scum team or a 4 man team and a sk are both plausible.

"Speculating" on a 3 man/2 man split looks like inside info. Its completely reasonable to ask him why he has such a belief.

Correct me if I'm wrong but don't you consider scum + SK to be multiball?

I don't-