Because most of my past games, I have gotten lazy and never gotten to it. I actually got to it this time, but I gave myself some time (all game, practically) in case I didn't get it done.
In post 518, Selkies wrote:I can't place it in a game, but I think I remember Cabd making a similar observation about a newbie player before. And I feel like I've seen SSK take up for a newbie player this way in the past.
I don't think it was the same game.
Is it alignment indicative in the past for either of them, or is the sample size too small?
Posted: Mon Jan 27, 2014 7:41 am
by Bert
In post 522, RossWilliam wrote:Katsuki is either a jester, or he's blatantly over this game, which tells me town.
Scum don't check out of a game on day 1
No. That's not a reliable statement.
In post 513, RossWilliam wrote:Can there be jesters in this game, or is that not in normal?
Either way, I think Katsuki would be a waste of a lynch.
Why is it a waste of a lynch to you?
Posted: Mon Jan 27, 2014 8:05 am
by Cabd
In post 521, Selkies wrote:I am kinda getting a tales upick vibe from some of your early posts.
That's pretty distressing given I don't think I'm playing anything like tales of upick.
Posted: Mon Jan 27, 2014 8:05 am
by Natirasha
Posted: Mon Jan 27, 2014 8:07 am
by The Goodfather
Please do not talk about ongoing games.
--Nat
Posted: Mon Jan 27, 2014 8:08 am
by Cabd
Uh...... This is a friendly reminder that even if dead, refrencing ongoing games is hella against the rules.
Posted: Mon Jan 27, 2014 8:09 am
by Selkies
In post 525, Bert wrote:Is it alignment indicative in the past for either of them, or is the sample size too small?
Small sample size, but more importantly, I can't place which game(s) were involved. May have been games I followed, not games I played.
Katsuki is either a jester, or he's blatantly over this game, which tells me town. Scum don't check out of a game on day 1
In the past, sure. But modern site meta has given a blank check to gain townpoints for apathy, and several posters have made their game plan prod dodging to victory. Kats is one of those. MafiaSSK is another, although his day one was a strong start.
and my completed games are all on another site where the phases are typically 24 hours or less
and there are no hydras.
I was asking about these games.
Posted: Mon Jan 27, 2014 8:20 am
by The Goodfather
In post 538, Cabd wrote:GF, we're asking if you have games off site that are completed.
yes, I was modkilled in my first game cause i hinted to hard at my role and hinting was forbidden that game. I also got majority lynched in another game off site. I started by playing a handful of mafia academy game on another site. Basically 9 players, 7 town 2 mafia, and a specific set of roles.
Currently on MS tho, all of my games are active
Can i say the other site, or is that against the rules? (i ask because on the other site you can't reference other websites wihtout getting an infraction cause they consider it advertising)
Posted: Mon Jan 27, 2014 8:22 am
by Cabd
You can link to the games, so long as they are completely over and a victory has been declared.
Posted: Mon Jan 27, 2014 8:25 am
by Bert
I think Cabd's town because gut!
Posted: Mon Jan 27, 2014 8:26 am
by Cabd
And what does your other head think?
Posted: Mon Jan 27, 2014 8:26 am
by Natirasha
A simple guide to if you can reference a game.
1. Has the moderator of the game declared the game is over?
If Yes->Reference and quote as much as you want!
If No->Don't!
1. Has the moderator of the game declared the game is over?
If Yes->Reference and quote as much as you want!
If No->Don't!
^Trufax
Posted: Mon Jan 27, 2014 8:30 am
by Bert
In post 543, Cabd wrote:And what does your other head think?
Town! I might sheep you later because Ffery hasn't been town enough yet - she should lead but isn't really taking charge yet and apparently isn't caught up....which has me wondering...I'm looking for where she pronounces something and like I instantly want to consider buying in...I don't feel that yet with her
Posted: Mon Jan 27, 2014 8:31 am
by Cabd
I would like an actual case from somebody on the selkies wagon, though. Somebody not named "katsuki" is preferable.
In post 538, Cabd wrote:GF, we're asking if you have games off site that are completed.
yes, I was modkilled in my first game cause i hinted to hard at my role and hinting was forbidden that game. I also got majority lynched in another game off site. I started by playing a handful of mafia academy game on another site. Basically 9 players, 7 town 2 mafia, and a specific set of roles.
Currently on MS tho, all of my games are active
Can i say the other site, or is that against the rules? (i ask because on the other site you can't reference other websites wihtout getting an infraction cause they consider it advertising)
24 hour game days and majority lynch rules are something else.
I asked because prior to playing at MS I hardly ever played games with majority lynch rules, and my playstyle and strategies are shaped somewhat by that, as well as by a curious combination of phobia about accidental quickhammering and not quite enough obsessiveness about checking the vote count once wagons start to mount. I wondered if some of what I'm picking up in your play comes from a similar mindset.
This last game got interrupted because of site maintenance, so this is only half the game thread because the other half is missing.
This is everything completed on the other site. And the site One Piece Bay (OPB) has mafia as a secondary aspect of the site, whereas it is the primary focus of mafiascum.net