With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.
Day 2 deadline will hit in: (expired on 2014-09-13 13:15:56).
Posted: Thu Sep 04, 2014 10:31 pm
by DeasVail
I will post tonight!
Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2014 1:48 am
by DeasVail
Unvote: Chaoslord
Vote: Shaddowez
This is the new path of light and rainbows and happiness!
↑Aneninen wrote:Nevertheless, I'll ISO Chaos as soon as I have time for that but meanwhile, I'd like to hear more from MalaKitty and DeasVail about the topic.
Yeah, I don't really want to lynch him today now. Sorry.
↑tman2nd wrote:I'm sorry I flaked again. I have a hard time getting reads on people. Does anyone have any advice?
Nooo, don't make me doubt my townread on you. I think it's still intact, but this kind of post gives me the tingles! To seriously answer your question, if I'm already up to date on the game, I'll often look through player ISOs and try and determine whether posts/phrases/actions come from a scum mindset or a town mindset. Sometimes I have a lot of difficulty with this though, and I'm not a great player, so go with whatever works for you. That's just what I try and do I guess.
~~
My vote on Shaddowez is not really due to anything extra that Shaddowez has done, but more because I've become unsure of Chaos after looking through his posting again with Shaddowez being the next best bet.
↑tman2nd wrote:I'm sorry I flaked again. I have a hard time getting reads on people. Does anyone have any advice?
Nooo, don't make me doubt my townread on you. I think it's still intact, but this kind of post gives me the tingles! To seriously answer your question, if I'm already up to date on the game, I'll often look through player ISOs and try and determine whether posts/phrases/actions come from a scum mindset or a town mindset. Sometimes I have a lot of difficulty with this though, and I'm not a great player, so go with whatever works for you. That's just what I try and do I guess.
I'm realizing that what I was having trouble with is trying to do a reads list on everyone with explanations. So, now that it's the morning, I'm going to take a look at Oso.
Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2014 7:53 am
by Aneninen
↑phokdapolees wrote:@anen: True, you're not easy lynches at this very moment,
but it'd be most likely be much easier to push a case and lynch on you or tman than anyone else.
(...)
Why do you think so? I still don't think that too many players would keep me on their scumlist and it's only me who's been trying pushing the Tman wagon.
↑DeasVail wrote:
My vote on Shaddowez is not really due to anything extra that Shaddowez has done, but more because I've become unsure of Chaos after looking through his posting again with Shaddowez being the next best bet.
What have you found reading Chaos? Also, besides it's a PoE (as far as I know), are there any reasons for your Shadowez vote?
Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2014 8:04 am
by SleepyKrew
Oso has requested replacement. BipolarChemist replaces Oso.
Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2014 8:05 am
by BipolarChemist
Swag. Will Read/Post/Change Av tonight!
Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2014 8:15 am
by Aneninen
Chaos-mix.
First of all, his voting pattern (see 462) gives him a lean scum read.
As for his posts:
182 – a readlist. I reflected to this before, very little explanation but at least, it hadn't been a "copycat" list.
248 – the Rack-case is okay, the MalaKittyPryde case is weak. (Though, I might be biased because of my own reads.)
256 – about Flames/Neil; unsure how to interpret this, it could come from a townie and from a scum player too.
339 – i still think that would have been an unnecessary vote if Chaos were scum. 341 seems to be a town-push for me. 412 too.
364 – how exactly did that post make sense? (Did I skim over something? I don't really understand his next three posts but in this case I daresay, I might have forgotten the topic of those dialogues.)
467 – and MalaKitty was his strongest townread at that time? What had changed? Hadn't he scumread her before? Weird.
503 – yet again, there was not too many reasoning here. He promised that he would make a longer post but that hasn't happened yet.
Conclusion. Call me an idiot but I still don't find anything obviously scummy here. He's still lean town on my list.
_____
Hi, BipolarChemist! ^_^
Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2014 8:18 am
by shaddowez
↑DeasVail wrote:My vote on Shaddowez is not really due to anything extra that Shaddowez has done, but more because I've become unsure of Chaos after looking through his posting again with Shaddowez being the next best bet.
So I haven't done anything, but I'm your second best bet on being scum? I'd like to point out that this vote came after me reading your slot as scum, and saying you haven't done anything to change that mind. On that same note, the rest of this post doesn't really do anything to do so either. There's more words without saying much.
(This post is short because it's primarily a prod dodge, will post again tomorrow)
Oso has requested replacement. BipolarChemist replaces Oso.
Well, after looking through Oso's ISO, I don't see anything that strongly pushes me in one direction or the other, so I will base my reads on this slot completely on the replacement.
Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2014 8:35 am
by tman2nd
So, I guess chaos would be the best place to focus mu attention given the wagon there.
Not sure when you last played but daytalk has become pretty standard fare....
[snip]
But you don't believe that is the case here. Why even bring up daytalk?
I literally never said that. So when you say "Hey how would I have been coached?" and I say "Because daytalk is a common thing," well, that's why I bring up daytalk.
Hi BPC! Sorry, BPC!
Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2014 9:11 am
by tman2nd
↑chaoslord54 wrote:Okay so my strongest read at the moment as a town tell is Malakittens
From there I feel that it goes
Agar
Deasvail
My leans town are
Phokdapolees
Implosion
My Nulls are:
Grande
Shadoweez
My leans scum:
Aneninen
Tman2nd
Oso
I have not been able to feel strong enough about my list except for my read on Malakittens so that's why I don't want to say I have with complete certainty someone I feel is scum. I will post reasoning in my next post after my classes.
This list makes no sense to me. How did you go from scumreading Mala and defending me to Mala being your biggest townread, and leaning scum on me? None of your current scumreads have any explanation. Two of them you haven't said anything about really.
Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2014 9:22 am
by Malakittens
Haiiii.
Okay so DV or BPC can one of you change your avvie just for this game? If I'm phone posting I might accidentally confuse you due to them.
Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2014 9:36 am
by Malakittens
↑Aneninen wrote:Tman: my scumread on you is based upon the Day1 vote movement, you can check it in the spoiler part of the post linked by you. However, I think I should examine other possibilities too. I might have misinterpreted or skimmed over facts.
yeah not sure if this makes him scum. Why would scumbuddy jump off a wagon that he knows will get lynched in teh future due to fake claiming.
doesn't make sense, sorry~
Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2014 9:40 am
by Malakittens
hmm, I thought I saw a post that made someone town. I actually thought it was Chaos, but it in fact wasn't. I need to find that post right now.
Also I'm not sure if I want to eye Oso or Agar for a comment made in the last few pages.
@agar:
Why are you more confident that scum-day talk is becoming more popular in normal games?
Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2014 10:35 am
by BipolarChemist
↑BipolarChemist wrote:Swag. Will Read/Post/Change Av tonight!
Okay so DV or BPC can one of you change your avvie just for this game? If I'm phone posting I might accidentally confuse you due to them.
Lazy colour change enough??
ya thats fine
Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2014 12:13 pm
by tman2nd
I would vote for chaos, but he's disappeared and might end up replaced. So, I'll look at some other people.
Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2014 12:33 pm
by SleepyKrew
chaoslord54 has been prodded.
Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2014 1:01 pm
by implosion
This is also a prod dodge but I'll try to say something today.
Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2014 3:55 pm
by BipolarChemist
It’s been a long week, so forgive me if anything is a bit skimpy and PLEASE ask me questions on stuff! I hate when I say that and no one asks me questions ugh.
Spoiler: Agar
Day 1 Thoughts:
He was totally right about Tammy. Glad to see he picked up on Tammy’s tell of always being town. A+ marks for that. You go girl. I wanted to go into looking at you as though you were scummy and the others were wrong and you were just playing really well as scum, but dude, top quality scum hunting happening here. I really love Post 110, especially on Flames, couldn’t agree more. My only issue going through is I hear a lot of hate on Rack throughout his posts but the best explanation I see is that he’s an alt that is strange and awkward, which apparently all alts are anyways. It felt like hugely circular logic. I like the thought process on Flames possibly being scum gaining town cred early on with Rack and then jumping on the wagon later. I agree with thoughts on Anen, but these are the feelings I get most every game I see him in. AND I JUST REALIZED FLAMES WAS SCUM OKAY. You were so hard on him from the start. Either this is a super early bus, or you’re town. The bus option isn’t like totally out of the realm of possibility, given Flames kinda awkward first few posts, but ehhh I doubt it right now.
Day 2 Thoughts:
I’m not even gonna disagree with you on Oso, that was a shit entrance. I guess my only thought there is to really think about motives I guess? But that would probably look bad too. He was a fluff poster but would replacement-scum coming into the game blatantly do that? (ugh the more I keep reading Oso the more I cringe, I swear I’m town). HI AGar! Fuck you, AGar! <3
Spoiler: chaoslord54
Can I say I think he’s townish for having the balls to put Flames as town that early?
Post 256, would you like some maple syrup with that waffle? In conjunction with Flame’s flip, this post looks bad, man. OH NO YOU STILL TRY TO SAVE HIM 295, DUDE. Oh and there’s the nail in the coffin 339, way to flip on a dime, with the most half assed read of life. I wanna think you are scummy so much, I dooo, gut is saying no, logic is saying yesss. Grrrr…
Spoiler: Malakittens
Dude, we get that you have a ladyboner for Tammy, but you can probably drop that past the first couple of posts Okay, I do like that you were having fun for the first day. Ugh you just look like you are having so much fun this game. Anyone wanna tell me if she’s always this fun? I’d really like to know! Thanks!
I don’t know about points on Anen, this is just how he’s been every time I see him. Not very serious and like <5% real content. This is almost the feel I’m getting on you, being halfway through your ISO. Lots of just joking around and explaining how you do things. Some scumhunting but eh nothing really…much? Then grr grr, I don’t know what to think about you possibly thinking Flames was town then goin pretty harsh onto Neil, then clamoring for the hammer. Just super enthusiastic about lynching? Or excited for a bus of their partner? HMMMMM, I’m actually not sure…especially with the reads list at the end of Day 1. So much WIFOM!
Nothing really in the way of thoughts for her Day 2 play!
Spoiler: Aneninen
Oh god dude, I never know what to think of you. So much fluff and nonsensical crap and just, what the hell, man. The constant poking of himself being an idiot and stuff does feel a bit scummy. Almost like “Hey guys, don’t mind me, I’m just an idiot meandering about, no looking here!”. Then excuses start to pile a bit and it all just feels a bit sketch. To be fairly honest here, I have a hard time reading this guy’s posts…Then post 390 happens and I just feel like there’s no way scum would just blatantly say something like that, but then again it’s Anen…
Everytime I click one of your spoilers and it’s a pigeon, I die a little on the inside.
Hi Anen…
Spoiler: Phokdapolees
Day 1, pretty much nothing pinged to me on you. Posts aren’t really fluffy, but also just not much at the same time. Overall, YOU’RE BORING. BE MORE INTERESTING.
Day 2 though!!!! Ehhh. I see that you see that Oso was being picked on heavy, a possible lynch for the day and you are one of the few to defend a bit. This comes across as a bit scummy to me, you trying to win some towncred there. (This is in post 507. That’s about it though! I’m watching you >.>
Spoiler: Grandi (Rack)
Okay, I kinda get where AGar was going with the awkward bit…I’m half way through Rack and I don’t really have any grasp on him. I don’t really know why others pinged here, I think he was just a boring ass slot who didn’t show up. Replacement has been a super big help on this slot too :/ And WTF, you thought Chaos’ LATER posts were less scummy? UMMM….UMMMMMMMMMMMMMM…No.
The last 4 I need to go through I will either do later tonight or tomorrow. I am getting tired and need to shut off my brain for a bit! <3 So come check out my GTKAS
