Mafiascum.net

why do you TR joey?

In post 518, PMysterious wrote:Why did Mafia put scum-read players on the chopping block instead of prominent town players? Titus has been scum read by other players (yes, I read this game), Correspondence has been inactive and just now replaced, and Norway, as mentioned, hammered after declaring intent (yes, that is true), but without giving Mutant a chance to respond. In Day 2, wouldn't you put in 3 of the biggest town reads into the nomination pool just to sack one of them off?

my thoughts on this

I think it's most likely they nommed one of themselves and two slots they felt were most mislynchable to muddy all three slots for future odd day lynches. I don't really agree with the "even lynches are glorified NKs" idea, I think if you nommed three obvtown players that'd be fairly transparent and wouldn't give you a useful foundation for the rest of the game. Maybe you pull that move on Day 4 but if I were scum and scumread I feel I'd be guaranteeing a D3 or D5 lynch on myself rolling with all obvtown even day pools.

though now I'm thinking by that logic if scum!Titus got nommed here then it's likely the other two scum feel they're in a stronger position than she is here, which doesn't really vibe with Dong/PM scum

I TR Joey mainly for 221. I don't think scum would go through that level of effort for towncred from WKing a nearly-lynched slot. Timing was genuine too as he was clearly working on that pre-hammer

Ok. I finished reading through. My internet went out halfway through so I am phone posting right now. Of the nominees, this is where I’m at.

T
GuiltyLion
NorwegianBoyEE
Titus
S

I have a full read list but I don’t think I want to post it just yet (plus it’s on my computer).

In post 517, Menalque wrote:are you an alt suji?

No. I am familiar with the site though. A friend invited me to play here.

In post 529, Sujimichi wrote:

In post 517, Menalque wrote:are you an alt suji?

No. I am familiar with the site though. A friend invited me to play here.

Oh shit, okay, I thought I’d seen you before

Can you say which friend it was?

In post 511, Menalque wrote:awoo how do you feel about joey atm?

Joey feels like an easy consenus townread that makes me slightly uneasy but I'm willing to ignore that feeling until I see more flips.

In post 528, Sujimichi wrote:Ok. I finished reading through. My internet went out halfway through so I am phone posting right now. Of the nominees, this is where I’m at.

T
GuiltyLion
NorwegianBoyEE
Titus
S

I have a full read list but I don’t think I want to post it just yet (plus it’s on my computer).

Also why don’t you wanna post your full reads?

See the big brain play is to nom all the scum

In post 527, GuiltyLion wrote:I TR Joey mainly for 221. I don't think scum would go through that level of effort for towncred from WKing a nearly-lynched slot. Timing was genuine too as he was clearly working on that pre-hammer

Okay I dig this

Also, when I try to think about why I feel uneasy, I can't actually substantiate anything.

Awoo
GuiltyLion
Joey

Creature
Pk

Norwegian
Suki
Titus

Wait am I missing someone

In post 532, Menalque wrote:

In post 528, Sujimichi wrote:Ok. I finished reading through. My internet went out halfway through so I am phone posting right now. Of the nominees, this is where I’m at.

T
GuiltyLion
NorwegianBoyEE
Titus
S

I have a full read list but I don’t think I want to post it just yet (plus it’s on my computer).

Also why don’t you wanna post your full reads?

I think how this nomination phase plays out could impact it quite a bit. Plus, it’s on my computer, and I don’t feel like typing it out in my phone.

Oh I forgot PM lol

Awoo
GuiltyLion
Joey

Creature
Pk

Norwegian

Suji
Titus
PM

Stronger on the order in my townreada than my scumreads

In post 526, GuiltyLion wrote: though now I'm thinking by that logic if scum!Titus got nommed here then it's likely the other two scum feel they're in a stronger position than she is here, which doesn't really vibe with Dong/PM scum

To be fair, Dong and PM were exiting D1 being light town? I think mutant called PM town because he narrated some events. Maybe not dong, I think he was called out by menalque, but it works for PM though. Good for consideration though

In post 538, Sujimichi wrote:

In post 532, Menalque wrote:

In post 528, Sujimichi wrote:Ok. I finished reading through. My internet went out halfway through so I am phone posting right now. Of the nominees, this is where I’m at.

T
GuiltyLion
NorwegianBoyEE
Titus
S

I have a full read list but I don’t think I want to post it just yet (plus it’s on my computer).

Also why don’t you wanna post your full reads?

I think how this nomination phase plays out could impact it quite a bit. Plus, it’s on my computer, and I don’t feel like typing it out in my phone.

Why can’t you let us know where your head is at now?

It’s not really benefitting us as town to not see your thought process

I can provide a list like you did, but I’m not typing out my reasons why on my phone.

T
Joey_
GuiltyLion
Creature

TL
Menalque
Awoo

N
NorwegianBoyEE

SL
pisskop

S
PMysterious
Titus

Yeah that was all I was looking for

That’s a v convenient readslist

Looking forward to seeing the reasons

What do you mean it’s convenient?

Oh, maybe this is active again.